Increasing Transparency at the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence – Lawfare
In 2018, Congress established the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence (NSCAI)a temporary, independent body tasked with reviewing the national security implications of artificial intelligence (AI). But two years later, the commissions activities remain little known to the public. Critics have charged that the commission has conducted activities of interest to the public outside of the public eye, only acknowledging that meetings occurred after the fact and offering few details on evolving commission decision-making. As one commentator remarked, Companies or members of the public interested in learning how the Commission is studying AI are left only with the knowledge that appointed people met to discuss these very topics, did so, and are not yet releasing any information about their recommendations.
That perceived lack of transparency may soon change. In June, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia handed down its decision in Electronic Privacy Information Center v. National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence, holding that Congress compelled the NSCAI to comply with the Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA). Under FACA, the commission must hold open meetings and proactively provide records and other materials to the public. This decision follows a ruling from December 2019, holding that the NSCAI must also provide historical documents upon request under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). As a result of these decisions, the public is likely to gain increased access to and insight into the once-opaque operations of the commission.
Lawmakers established the NSCAI in the John S. McCain National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for fiscal 2019 1051, which tasked the commission with consider[ing] the methods and means necessary to advance the development of artificial intelligence, machine learning, and associated technologies to comprehensively address the national security and defense needs of the United States. The commissions purview includes an array of issues related to the implications and uses of artificial intelligence and machine learning for national security and defense, including U.S. competitiveness and leadership, research and development, ethics, and data standards.
The NSCAI is currently chaired by Eric Schmidt, the former executive chairman of Googles parent company, Alphabet. The commissions 15 membersappointed by a combination of Congress, the secretary of defense and the secretary of commercereceive classified and unclassified briefings, meet in working groups and engage with industry. They report their findings and recommendations to the president and Congress, including in an annual report.
The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC), a research center focused on privacy and civil liberties issues in the digital age, submitted a request to the NSCAI in September 2019, seeking access to upcoming meetings and records prepared by the commission under FACA and FOIA. In the six-month period prior to the request, the NSCAI held more than a dozen meetings and received more than 100 briefings, according to EPIC. At the time it filed the lawsuit, EPIC noted that the commissions first major report was also one month overdue for release. When the commission did not comply with the requests under FOIA and FACA, EPIC brought suit under the two laws.
EPICs complaint alleged that the NSCAI had conducted its operations opaquely in its short lifespan. Since its establishment, the commission has operated almost entirely in secret with meetings behind closed doors[,] and has failed to publish or disclose any notices, agendas, minutes, or materials. If Congress had intended the NSCAI to comply with FOIA and FACA, such activity would not satisfy the statutes requirements. Given the potential implications of federal artificial intelligence decisions for privacy, cybersecurity, human rights, and algorithmic bias, EPIC argued that [p]ublic access to the records and meetings of the AI Commission is vital to ensure government transparency and democratic accountability. The complaint also noted the potential ramifications of commission activities for the government, private sector, and public, as well as the importance of artificial intelligence safeguards in the national security context due to limited public oversight. According to EPIC, increasing public participation would permit greater input into the development of national AI policy by those whose privacy and data security could potentially be affected.
The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia addressed EPICs FOIA claim in a December 2019 decision. FOIA requires agencies to disclose their records to a party upon request, barring exemptions (including for information classified to protect national security). EPIC alleged that the NSCAI failed to uphold its obligations under FOIA to process FOIA requests in a timely fashion; to process EPICs FOIA requests in an expedited manner, in accordance with EPICs claims of urgency; and to make available for public inspection and copying its records, reports, transcripts, minutes, appendixes, working papers, drafts, studies, agenda, or other documents. The commission, which at the time did not have a FOIA processing mechanism in place or other pending FOIA requests, argued that it was not an agency subject to FOIA.
The courts inquiry centered on whether the NSCAI is an agency under FOIA. Comparing the language establishing the NSCAI with FOIAs definition of agency, the court held that the NSCAI is subject to FOIA. In his decision, District Judge Trevor McFadden noted that Congress could have hardly been clearer. As a result, since that time, the commission has had to produce historical documents in response to FOIA requests.
FACA, by contrast, applies forward-looking requirements specifically to federal advisory committees. These mandates include requiring committees to open meetings to the public and announce them in the Federal Register, and to make reports, transcripts and other commission materials publicly available. The measures aim to inform the public about and invite public engagement with the committees that provide expertise to the executive branch. EPIC alleged that the NSCAI violated FACA by failing to hold open meetings and provide notice of them, and by failing to make records available to the public. EPIC sought mandamus relief pursuant to the alleged FACA violations.
In its June decision, the district court ruled that FACA applies to the NSCAI. The commission had filed a motion to dismiss the FACA claims, arguing that it could not be subject to both FOIA and FACA. Since the court had previously held the NSCAI to be an agency for purposes of FOIA, the commission reasoned that it could not simultaneously be an advisory committee under FACA. McFadden disagreed. Invoking the Roman God Januss two facesone forward-looking and the other backward-facinghe wrote, [L]ike Janus, the Commission does indeed have two faces, and ... Congress obligated it to comply with FACA as well as FOIA. The court could not identify a conflict between the requirements of the two statutes, despite differences in their obligations and exceptions. Rather, it noted that if such conflicts arise, it will be incumbent on the parties and the Court to resolve any difficulties. The court dismissed additional claims under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, as it determined that the commission is not an agency under the APA definition.
The courts decision turned on whether the NSCAI is an advisory committee subject to FACA. The court determined that the statutory text of the 2019 NDAA establishing the NSCAI fit[s] the [FACA] definition of advisory committee like a glove. Furthermore, turning to the full text of the 2019 NDAA, the court noted that the law contains at least two instances in which it explicitly exempts a government body from FACA. The court read the 2019 NDAA as silent when FACA applies and explicit when FACA does not apply. Given Congresss silence on the applicability of FACA to the NSCAI in the 2019 NDAAand again in the 2020 NDAAthe court reasoned that Congress intended the NSCAI to be subject to FACA.
In determining the NSCAI to be subject to FACA, in addition to FOIA, the court has compelled the commission to adopt a more transparent operating posture going forward. Since the December 2019 decision on FOIA, the NSCAI has produced a number of historical records in response to FOIA requests. The recent ruling on FACA grounds requires the NSCAI to hold open meetings, post notice of meetings in advance and make documents publicly available. As a result, the commissions process of compiling findings and developing recommendations for government action related to artificial intelligence and machine learning will likely become more accessible to the public.
The two court decisions come in time to have a noticeable impact on the remaining term of the temporary commission. While the NSCAI was previously due to disband later in 2020, the NDAA for fiscal 2020 1735 extended the commissions lifespan by one year, to October 1, 2021. Citing federal budgetary timelines and the pace of AI development, the commission released its first set of recommendations in March 2020 and expressed its intent to publish additional recommendations on a quarterly basis thereafter. The commission is due to submit its final report to Congress by March 1, 2021. As the NSCAI prepares to enter its final year of operations and develop its closing recommendations, the public will have a clearer window into the commissions work.
Read more:
Increasing Transparency at the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence - Lawfare
- Senate bill targets the use of artificial intelligence in Mississippi - WAPT Jackson - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- will.i.am and Sean Paul on embracing artificial intelligence in music - Sky News - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- As Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks Fall, Investors Should Consider Buying More of These 2 Powerhouses - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- FSUs Graduate School hosts workshop on artificial intelligence to explore the impact of AI on teaching and research - Florida State News - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Artificial Intelligence Optimization (AIO): The Next Frontier in SEO - hackernoon.com - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- The U.S. Army, Artificial Intelligence, and Mission Command - War On The Rocks - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- 2 Stock-Split Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks to Buy Before They Zoom Higher, According to Wall Street Analysts - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- AI in the classroom: How artificial intelligence is helping teachers - Bay News 9 - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Video: Daryl Morey Says 76ers Use Artificial Intelligence for Input on Team Decisions - Bleacher Report - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Better Artificial Intelligence Stock: AT&T vs. Verizon Communications - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- NVIDIA GTC 25: What To Expect From the Years Biggest Artificial Intelligence Event - BizTech Magazine - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- 2 Stock-Split Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks to Buy Before They Zoom Higher, According to Wall Street Analysts - MSN - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- DEI Erosion Threatens Safety. Artificial Intelligence May Help Pick Up the Slack. - Inbound Logistics - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Saint Vincent conference will examine broad impact of artificial intelligence - TribLIVE - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- As Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks Fall, Investors Should Consider Buying More of These 2 Powerhouses - MSN - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- 3 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks You Can Buy and Hold for the Next Decade - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- This Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock Has Surged 1,000% Over the Past 2 Years. Is a Split on the Horizon? - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Move Over, Artificial Intelligence (AI) -- Businesses Are on Pace to Spend More Than $10 Trillion on This Trend Over the Next Decade - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Here Is My Top Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock to Buy Right Now - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Nasdaq Sell-Off: 2 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks Down 20% and 49% to Buy Hand Over Fist on the Dip - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- 1 Top Artificial Intelligence (AI) Chip Stock to Buy Hand Over Fist Before It Jumps - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- [Latest] How Artificial Intelligence is Shaping the Emc Shielding And Test Equipment Market - openPR - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Nasdaq Correction: 5 Reasons Nvidia Stock Is Still a Top Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock to Buy Right Now - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Artificial Intelligence (AI) Adoption Rates Appear Low, but This Technology Leader Could See a Massive Surge in Demand in the Next 10 Years. Here's... - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- [Latest] The Influence of Artificial Intelligence on the Augmented Reality (Ar) Shopping Market - openPR - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Oracle Just Shared Some Amazing News for the Entire Artificial Intelligence (AI) Industry - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- 1 No-Brainer Artificial Intelligence (AI) ETF to Buy With $40 During the Nasdaq Sell-Off - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Inside The Artificial Intelligence That Can Clone Your Mind - Forbes - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Why Tesla Could Be a Massive Winner in the Artificial Intelligence (AI) Race - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- 4 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks Worth Buying in the Tech Sell-Off - The Motley Fool - March 15th, 2025 [March 15th, 2025]
- Impact of Artificial Intelligence (AI) on Media and Creative Industries - EDMO - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- 1 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock That Could Be Bigger Than Nvidia in 5 Years - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- This Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock Is Up 15% in 2025 Already. It Is Still a Solid Buy? - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Can artificial intelligence be the future solution to the enormous challenges and suffering caused by Schizophrenia? - Nature.com - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Applications of Artificial Intelligence in Medical Education: A Systematic Review - Cureus - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- This Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock Is Up 15% in 2025 Already. It Is Still a Solid Buy? - AOL - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Federal Executive Forum Artificial Intelligence Strategies in Government Progress and Best Practices 2025 - Federal News Network - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Introduction to Artificial Intelligence for General Surgeons: A Narrative Review - Cureus - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- How is Artificial Intelligence Affecting Health Care? - Workers Comp Forum - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- 1 Spectacular Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock to Buy With $50 Right Now - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- 20+ Advantages and Disadvantages of AI | Pros of Artificial Intelligence - Simplilearn - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Prediction: This Top Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock Will Start Skyrocketing After March 6 - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- 1 Surprising Stock Harnessing the Power of Artificial Intelligence (AI) - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- 2 Top Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks to Buy On the Dip Amid Nasdaq Selloff - Yahoo Finance - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Review: Artificial intelligence is shaping the future of diabetes care - News-Medical.Net - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Prediction: This Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock -- a 1,020% Gainer Since Its IPO -- Won't Split Its Stock in 2025. Here's Why - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- A Nobel laureate on the economics of artificial intelligence - MIT Technology Review - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Prediction: This Top Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock Will Start Skyrocketing After March 6 - Nasdaq - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Meta Platforms Just Caused This Crucial Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock to Plummet. Should You Buy the Dip? - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Artificial Intelligence - AI Update, February 28, 2025: AI News and Views From the Past Week - MarketingProfs.com - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- The Ultimate Artificial Intelligence (AI) ETF to Buy With $50 Right Now - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Prediction: This Artificial Intelligence (AI) Company Will Split Its Stock in 2025 - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Should You Forget Nvidia and Buy 2 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks Instead? - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Why Artificial Intelligence Stocks SoundHound AI, IonQ, and C3.ai Are Struggling Today - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- 2 Top Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks Ready for a Bull Run - The Motley Fool - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- AI Cant Do This Anymore: The Dangers of Artificial Intelligence in Academia - Skidmore News - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Whats Next in Artificial Intelligence: Agents that can do more than chatbots - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Geopolitics of artificial intelligence to be focus of major summit in Paris; AP explains - Yahoo - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Geopolitics of artificial intelligence to be focus of major summit in Paris; AP explains - The Associated Press - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- 3 Top Artificial Intelligence Stocks to Buy in February - MSN - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Geopolitics of artificial intelligence to be focus of major summit in Paris; AP explains - Lufkin Daily News - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- 2 of the Hottest Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks on the Planet Can Plunge Up to 94%, According to Select Wall Street Analysts - The Motley Fool - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- These 2 Stocks Are Leading the Data Center Artificial Intelligence (AI) Trend, but Are They Buys Right Now? - The Motley Fool - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Book Review | Genesis: Artificial Intelligence, Hope, and the Human Spirit - LSE - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- The Artificial Intelligence Action Summit In France: Maintaining The Dialogue On Global AI Regulation - Forrester - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Is prediction the next frontier for artificial intelligence? - Healthcare IT News - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- The Artificial Intelligence in Medicines Market Is Set to Reach $18,119 Million | CAGR of 49.6% - openPR - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Geopolitics of artificial intelligence to be focus of major summit in Paris; AP explains - The Audubon County Advocate Journal - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Around and About with Richard McCarthy: Asking AI about itself: Will artificial intelligence ever surpass humankind? - GazetteNET - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Will the Paris artificial intelligence summit set a unified approach to AI governanceor just be another conference? - Bulletin of the Atomic... - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Apple Stock Jumps on Artificial Intelligence (AI) Driving iPhone Sales. Here's Why It's Not Getting Crushed by the DeepSeek Launch. - The Motley Fool - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Who will win the race to Artificial General Intelligence? - The Indian Express - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Prediction: This Artificial Intelligence (AI) Chip Stock Will Win Big From DeepSeek's Feat - The Motley Fool - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Prediction: 2 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks That Will Be Worth More Than Nvidia 3 Years From Now - The Motley Fool - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- State of Louisiana Launches Innovation Brand, Announces Creation of $50 Million Growth Fund and Artificial Intelligence Research Institute - Louisiana... - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Using smart technologies and artificial intelligence in food packaging can reduce food waste - Yahoo News Canada - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- BigBear.ai Wins Department of Defense Contract to Prototype Near-Peer Adversary Geopolitical Risk Analysis for Chief Digital and Artificial... - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Should Investors Change Their Artificial Intelligence (AI) Investment Strategy After the DeepSeek Launch? - The Motley Fool - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- 1 Unstoppable Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock to Buy Before It Punches Its Ticket to the $4 Trillion Club - The Motley Fool - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Got 10 Years and $1000? These 3 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks Are Set to Soar. - The Motley Fool - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]