Mediaboss Marketing

from the don't-feed-the-trolls dept

Weve noted for a while that Trumps alternative social media platform, Truth Social, isnt doing particularly well. Being a Trump product, the platform (surprise!) began with a lot of money slushing around that wasnt spent in any coherent way. Its also just generally glitchy and terrible. And its not helped much by the fact that after all of his whining about social media censorship (read: minimal accountability for saying stupid and sometimes dangerous things), Trump doesnt even use the product.

Then theres been the slow realization by the company that it still has to deal with the headaches of reality and content moderation at scale, which weve also noted isnt going particularly well. If you want a platform that isnt just a pit of bile and illegal content, you have to have moderation standards, which is why Parler, Gab, and now Truth Social (which muzzled some racist drivel by right wing dirty ops shitlord Roger Stone last week) have barred obnoxious people from doing dumb and sometimes illegal things.

Truth failed to gain traction even with the National Republican Senatorial Committee spamming its support for the platform like a feverish street corner huckster:

Putting the corruption, grift, and technical incompetence aside (and theres a lot to put aside), when the political mainstream press discusses the struggles of Social and other GOP social media platforms, one of the top arguments explaining why they fail is because echo chambers are just no fun:

I think the challenge that a lot of these newer ones have is to not be an echo chamber for people who hold similar beliefs, said Alex Weber, a content creator who was embraced by conservatives online after posting videos criticizing mask mandates, vaccine mandates and the mainstream media. I think why Instagram and Facebook and all these are so impactful is because youve got all different types of people.

While thats true to a point, it misses a key part of the failure. The problem isnt just that such groups corral like-minded people into groups made specifically for them. Hell, huddling with like-minded people is 80 percent of the reason Reddit was created and a major reason for its success.

No, one of the major reasons such projects fail is because they break the GOPs troll and inadvertent amplification cycle. How many times does a right wing personality say something grotesque, racist, or otherwise terrible on Twitter only to have it hate retweeted countless times by numerous people, usually partisan opposites, who think theyre dunking on, correcting, or punishing the content?

The entire success of modern GOP discourse is based on trolling. On any given day on Twitter and Facebook, theres a ceaseless array of left wing and centrist accounts hate retweeting every idiotic and racist thing Fox personality Tucker Carlson says, expanding distribution of his viewpoints exponentially.

Right wing celebrities like Ann Coulter have paid their mortgage for 30 years by intentionally saying stupid and controversial things, then soaking up free advertising as the outraged amplify said stupid and controversial thing to a significantly larger audience that might have never seen it otherwise.

Twitter dunks work to amplify dodgy and shitty trolls in much the same way. Theres just a countless array of folks who think theyre helping by dunking on terrible takes, when theyre only really amplifying those terrible takes to a much broader audience. Its utterly counterintuitive, and in some cases punished by engagement and ad engines (across both online and traditional cable media), to do anything else. Controversy sells. Nuance does not.

So while platforms like Truth Social are stumbling because theyre badly made by incompetent people who arent magically immune from the challenges of content moderation, theyre also stumbling because they break a cornerstone of online right wing discourse: trolling to amplify propaganda. A room full of terrible trolling propagandists has nobody to troll but themselves. And what fun is that?

Most of the Section 230 and conservatives are being silenced discourse is falsely framed as a conversation about free speech in punditry and the press. In reality, what the modern Trump GOP wants is the mandated carriage of propaganda. The dominant U.S. press simply cant help but frame Trump GOP concerns of censorship as legitimate, which speaks to the propagandas effectiveness.

Its why the GOP freaked out when DirecTV made the ordinary business decision to kick the conspiracy and fantasy channel off of its lineup. Its why the GOP despises big techs belated and often sloppy attempt to clean up race-baiting GOP propaganda on their platforms. Its why the party adores media consolidation at the hands of Sinclair, and the steady destruction of genuine local news reporting.

The modern Trump GOP cant just come out and admit their goal is mandated carriage of bigoted propaganda designed to rile up low-information Americans, so they have to dress it all up as something grander, including the Trump GOPs performative support of antitrust reform (read: an attempt to gain leverage over tech giants to mandate the carriage of, you guessed it, propaganda).

Shifting demographics and a fading (and dying) electoral base arent great news for the modern GOP, which increasingly alienates a big chunk of independent voters with unhinged behavior and positions. As a result, like many global authoritarian movements, theyve been forced to embrace online propaganda, fabricated culture war, and victimization porn to agitate and befuddle the public.

The idea that doing absolutely anything to rein in race-baiting propaganda in online or traditional media is censorship or the silencing of conservatives is itself propaganda, and it would be lovely if the broader discourse and press would wake up to this fact before were all drowning in many of the even uglier aspects of rank authoritarianism.

Filed Under: big tech, big tech censorship, censorship, conservative censorship, propaganda, section 230, silenced conservatives, social media, trolling, trollsCompanies: truth social

See original here:
GOP Social Media Experiments Fail (In Part) Because They Break The Troll/Amplification Cycle - Techdirt

This kind of foolishness, which arrived on April Fools Day no less, deserves nothing more than an eye roll and a trip to the recycling bin. But the invocation of QAnon makes this something beyond another sketchy promotion. The senders address is given as a post office box in Portsmouth, N.H., but no one seems to know whos behind this mailing, whos footing whats probably a sizable tab, or the motive behind it.

Get Weekend Reads from IdeasA weekly newsletter from the Boston Globe Ideas section, forged at the intersection of 'what if' and 'why not.'

Perhaps Id find clues if I scanned the cards QR codes or visited its email address, but my mother cured me of that sort of thing. Years ago, an envelope arrived from what appeared to be the Unification Church, led for decades by Rev. Sun Myung Moon, who conducted mass weddings for church-arranged marriages, claimed he was the messiah, and bought full-page newspaper ads defending Richard Nixon during the Watergate scandal.

That letter disturbed my mother so much, she made me throw it away but not in the house. I tore it up, balled up the remains, and tossed it in a public trash container a few blocks away.

Without question, Moon was a cult leader. But unlike QAnon followers, Moons devotees never participated in a deadly insurrection to overturn the results of a presidential election.

Unlike other cults, QAnon has no designated leader. According to the Southern Poverty Law Center, which tracks hate groups, the Q name is the umbrella term for a sprawling spider web of right-wing Internet conspiracy theories with antisemitic and anti-LGBTQ elements that falsely claim the world is run by a secret cabal of pedophiles who worship Satan and are plotting against former president Donald Trump.

Somehow theyve overlooked the fact that Trump was a longtime friend of convicted sex offender and accused pedophile Jeffrey Epstein.

Trump isnt mentioned in the postcards text, but his photo is featured alongside those of Big Tech megalomaniacs (Amazon founder Jeff Bezos, Facebooks Mark Zuckerberg, Elon Musk); politicians (former president Barack Obama, Senator Mitt Romney of Utah, former New York governor Andrew Cuomo); performers (Mel Gibson, Kanye West, Jay-Z, Taylor Swift); and far-right provocateurs (Alex Jones, Ann Coulter); among others.

While the postcard is certainly controversial, Steve Doherty, a United States Postal Service spokesman, told NBC 10 Bostons Alison King, there doesnt appear to be anything in the mailing that would make it illegal to send through the mail.

If these postcards violate no law, this could mean we should expect more of this propaganda from an unhinged lot the FBI labeled a domestic terrorism threat and that was before the Jan. 6 insurrection. Prominent among the throngs with Trump banners and Confederate flags were people wearing QAnon garb and holding up handmade Q signs. Some of them breached the US Capitol, pummeled police officers, and went hunting for lawmakers barricaded in their offices.

Instead of shunning QAnon, Republican lawmakers adopted its mendacious talking points on nonexistent voter fraud, the efficacy of COVID protocols, and purported pedophilia rings among Democrats. This was glaringly obvious in some GOP senators disgraceful performances during last months Supreme Court confirmation hearing for Ketanji Brown Jackson. Unable to attack Jacksons qualifications, they drilled down on a manufactured theme that she gave lenient sentences to those convicted of possessing child pornography. That it was untrue didnt matter; Republicans followed through on a scurrilous lie Senator Josh Hawley of Missouri tweeted before the hearings.

It was perhaps the most significant Republican nod yet to the QAnon faithful, a boost to normalizing the conspiratorial claptrap doused in hate, racism, and attempts to shred democracy. About 16 percent of Americans now say they adhere to QAnon theories that government, media and financial worlds are controlled by Satan-worshipping pedophiles, an even larger percentage than when Trump was president.

Under normal circumstances, one could laugh at the ridiculousness of it all. But this perilous moment is anything but normal. With little daylight between many Republicans and QAnon, American right-wing politics is mainlining extremism. Now after spilling from the bowels of the Internet to the halls of Congress, these dangerous beliefs are literally landing on our doorsteps.

Rene Graham can be reached at renee.graham@globe.com. Follow her on Twitter @reneeygraham.

Read the original post:
What is QAnon doing in my mailbox? - The Boston Globe

Millions flee Ukraine.

Where will they go?

Some want to come to America. But doing that legally is hard. A complex system is supposed to determine which people deserve to get in line to get in.

"The line is broken," explained Reason Magazine editor at large Matt Welch in my new video.

For example, America has a nursing shortage, but immigration authorities turn away foreign nurses. A Mexican teenager who wants to help build houses might be admitted, but he'd have to wait 100 years. No wonder people sneak across the border.

This month, President Joe Biden announced the United States would take in 100,000 refugees from Ukraine.

"He could snap his fingers and make it 250,000 if he chose," said Welch, and he should, because "we're a refugee country, and the people who come here tend to be the best."

"But they could be the worst," I point out.

Even the supposed "worst of the worst," Welch replied, made America better.

That's a reference to 1980, when Fidel Castro let 100,000 people out of jail and encouraged them to go to America. Some were his political opponents, but most were, as a Miami TV anchor put it, "bums off the streets of Havana -- murderers, thieves, perverts, prostitutes."

Castro assumed they'd cause problems in America.

But "that was wrong," Welch said. Despite their past problems, "they enriched Miami. They added to the economy and didn't detract from the people who lived there."

A study showed the Cuban exodus raised wages of low-skilled Miamians.

Immigrants improved America even when we took in people who'd tried to kill us, and who we had tried to kill. Ronald Reagan and Jimmy Carter eagerly took in refugees from Vietnam and Cambodia. Reagan, campaigning for the presidency, said immigrants make us better.

"They share the same values, the same dream," he said.

"He was bragging on this as a conservative and American value," Welch said. "It is no longer a conservative value."

Today, conservatives are more likely to argue against letting in refugees, saying, as Ann Coulter put it, "Things can turn overnight when you're bringing in these masses of people from very, very different cultures." Then she joked, "And make it a hate crime to ask them to assimilate."

It wasn't entirely a joke. Some leftists call asking Latinos to assimilate "racist repression."

More reasonably, many Americans fear that crime will rise if we let in more immigrants. But that's unlikely.

"They commit far less crime than native-born Americans," Welch points out.

He's right. Native-born Americans were 11.6 times more likely to be jailed than Afghan immigrants.

"It's hard for us to process that fact," Welch said. "It feels like it should be wrong, but it isn't. People who go to the lengths to get to this country tend to be less criminal than the native-born population."

"What if they just feed off welfare?" I asked.

"Then they would be the exception," he responded.

Immigrants, overall, collect less welfare than native-born Americans.

Still, people feel threatened when large numbers of foreigners arrive. Polish people protested when Syrian refugees came to Poland.

But now Poles welcome Ukrainians.

Some call that racism.

"Maybe it is racism," Welch responded. "But maybe when someone you speak a common language with, and have a common history with ... lives right next door, it's just a different story. ... Can we spare a moment and say, they've just assimilated an astonishing number of refugees. And they're not in tents in camps, shivering. They're staying with people in their apartments!"

That sure seems like a good thing.

Soon more refugees will come to America. Welch argued we should let more in.

"America is an assimilation machine," he said. "It's something that we should do more of because we're really good at it!"

I agree.

As long as people are peaceful, let them come.

John Stossel is creator of Stossel TV and author of "Give Me a Break: How I Exposed Hucksters, Cheats, and Scam Artists and Became the Scourge of the Liberal Media."

Read more here:
Let them in - Jefferson City News Tribune

When Donald Trumps handpicked White House photographer Shea Craighead asked him to write the foreword to her book of Trump-era White House photos, he had one thought: How can I make money off this?

Trump's first idea, according to a New York Times story, was to take a cut from Craigheads royalties. In the end, the former president decided to simply beat her to market by publishing his own book of photos and pocketing millions in royalties himself.

Craighead put her book on ice when she learned she would be competing with Trump.

The reaction today, to the Times piece and other stories about this incident, is that Trump ripped her off. Some of the people who feel Trump mistreated Craighead are former Trump employees:

Sheas a very talented photographer and this was really all of her hard work, Stephanie Grisham, Trumps former press secretary, told the Times. I just keep thinking: What a shame that he is actually now profiting off of it. But then again, this is the guy who is hawking caps and all kinds of stuff right now to raise money for himself.

Other critics are former Trump supporters:

Ann Coulter is right. Donald Trump never looks out for the little guy, the working man, or even his own supporters. He occasionally acts as if he does but really only to benefit himself. Politicians being greedy and turning their power into personal wealth is nothing new, but Trump is more blatant and more greedy than his predecessors on this score.

His campaign spent millions at his own hotels, thus funneling donor money into his own pockets. As president, he made it clear that anyone seeking his favor would stay at his properties again, converting his position of public trust into his own private profit. And after he lost the election, he has continued his charade partly in the service of filling his own bank accounts. He gets supporters to donate to what they think is a cause, but is really just him. As Grisham points out, selling Trump merchandise seems to regular supporters like a way to support a political cause, but Trump uses it simply to further enrich himself.

Nobody should be surprised. Donald Trump is a conman and always has been a conman. Since 2015, hes just added tens of millions of new marks. And now his former photographer, Shea Craighead, is just the latest in a long line of people, including his wives, who have learned that if you get in business with Trump, you end up losing.

View original post here:
Trump ripped off his White House photographer because he rips off everyone who gets close to him - Washington Examiner

There is a very good reason why we here in America, Jews especially, should fear Vladimir Putin. He is the poster boy for white Christian nationalism worldwide, and especially so here in the United States.

Asked if the far right here is influencing Russia in any way, or if Russia is influencing the far right, Johns Hopkins University Prof. Thomas Rid said, they are influencing each other. They are pushing the same narratives.

Putin speaks their language. The world must be turned into a Christian world as he and they define that. Anyone elseJews and other non-whites especiallyare to be put down to the lowest rungs of the social ladder, or simply put down.

Get The Jewish Standard Newsletter by email and never miss our top storiesFree Sign Up

This white Christian nationalism Putin promotes was graphically on display at the U.S. Capitol during the January 6th insurrection. Many of the insurrectionists carried large portraits of Jesus and chanted about how his blood would cleanse Congress sins. They saw in the date Congress must certify presidential elections as an omen from heaven: January 6 was once believed to have been the real date of Jesus birth. It is celebrated today as the day the Three Wise Men who heralded Jesus as the messiah.

A video taken by a New Yorker magazine reporter showed the bare-chested QAnon Shaman Jacob Chansley, he with the Viking horns, offering this prayer after occupying the Senate chamber: Thank you Heavenly Father for gracing us with this opportunity to send a message to all the tyrants, the Communists and the globalists, that this is our nation, not theirs. Thank you for filling this chamber with patriots that love you and that love Christ. Thank you for allowing the United States of America to be reborn.

According to the Rev. Wesley Granberg-Michaelson, who chairs the board of the ecumenical Christian organization Sojourners, Putin claims to be preserving Christian civilization against the secular decadence of the West.

The University of California Riverside history professor Georg Michels, a Russia specialist, notes that Christian nationalism in the 19th century was used as a weapon to fight revolutionaries many of them women demonize civil liberties and parliamentarism, and suppress non-Russian minorities. This Christian nationalism is what motivates Putin, Michels says.

Putin, he notes, [flaunts] his religious faith; he is often seen on television praying, crossing himself, kissing icons, and lighting candles. Priests have held ceremonies to bless Putin, and [the Russian Orthodox] Patriarch Kirill has called Putin a miracle of God.

Michels also notes that Putin models himself after the Russian Orthodox saint Vladimir the Great, whose statue he ordered erected outside the Kremlin. Vladimir laid the moral foundations on which our lives are still based today, Putin said in dedicating the statue. It was a strong moral bearing, solidarity, and unity which helped our ancestors win victories for the glory of the fatherland, making it stronger and greater with each generation.

That such a victory is Putins goal is clear from what his Russian supporters assert openly. For example, Konstantin Malofeev, who heads a Russian Orthodox group known as the St. Basil the Great Foundation, said that with Putin at the helm, Christian Russia can help liberate the West from the new liberal anti-Christian totalitarianism of political correctness, gender ideology, mass-media censorship and neo-Marxist dogma.

Putin said as much in a televised speech on February 24, the day the invasion of Ukraine began. Using code words and phrases that resonate with the white Christian nationalists, he accused the West of trying to destroy our traditional values and force on us their false values that would erode us, the attitudes they have been aggressively imposing on their countries, attitudes that are directly leading to degradation and degeneration, because they are contrary to human nature.

As Michels puts it, Putin and the white Christian nationalists are motivated by the belief in a mythologized Christian realm, the rejection of democratic values, the attack on gay rights and feminism, and the popularity of authoritarian strongmen.

According to Marilyn Mayo, a senior research fellow at the Anti-Defamation Leagues Center on Extremism, far right white Christians see Putin as conserving white Christendom in Europe. This grouping is opposed to globalism, multiculturalism, promoting what they see as modernist values like promoting the LBTGQ community, diversity, and allowing liberalism to dominate.

Some years ago, the American Family Associations Bryan Fischer began his radio program by declaring Putin to be the lion of Christianity, the defender of Christian values.

Most Republicans today are anti-Putin, but it took some time for many of them to get there. They had two fears: Donald Trumps support for Putin in the run up to the invasion (he has since walked back some of his comments) and the very vocal support for Putin and the invasion coming from the partys extreme right.

Fox News host Tucker Carlson, long a Putin booster, was unapologetic in his support before the invasion. Although he has since changed his tune somewhat, Russian media consider Carlson a strong supporter. In mid-March, for example, a Russian television commentator said of his Ukraine waffling, obviously [he] has his own interests. But lately, more and more often, theyre in tune with our own.

Others continue to be Putin-boosters, including far-right icons Steve Bannon and Ann Coulter. Another icon, Pat Buchanan, has called Putin a God-and-country Russian patriot who pits Christianity against the Western progressive vision of what mankinds future ought to be. The Holocaust-denying, Jew-hating onetime Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke once described Russia under Putin as the key to white survival.

On March 22, as Russias atrocities in Ukraine were mounting, Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) blamed Ukraine for poking the bear, which is Russia. She then crowed that Russia is being very successful in their invasion, even though we hear different things on television. In other words, reports that Ukrainian forces are pushing back on the invaders are all fake news.

The white supremacist America First Political Action Conference was held on February 25, the day after Ukraine was invaded. AFPAC was founded in 2020 by the antisemitic Holocaust denier Nicholas Fuentes. Greene was one of its featured speakers. She began her remarks with these words. My name is Marjorie Taylor Greene, I am the daughter of the King, the one true living God, the Alpha, the Omega, our Father in heaven, and I am a forgiven sinner washed in the blood of our savior, Jesus Christ.

The crowd responded with a favorite chant of the white Christian nationalists crowd: Christ is king! To this, Greene responded: Praise God. Amen. Christ is king.

In his speech, Fuentes praised Putins invasion of Ukraine. Said he, Can we give a round of applause for Russia? When the crowd responded with chants of Putin, Putin, Fuentes responded by saying, Absolutely, absolutely.

Here is something else Fuentes told the gathering in his speechand please recall what the neo-Nazi white supremacist thugs shouted in Charlottesville in 2017: Jews will not replace us. Said Fuentes, To the people that [sic] have thrown out and disrupted our country, we are coming for you. You think you can replace us? You are wrong. We will replace you!

Lauren Witzke, who ran as the Republican nominee for Senate from Delaware in 2020, was euphoric in praising Putins Christian nationalism. After all, as Witzke told her AFPAC audience, Russia is a Christian nationalist nation.

Another speaker was Andrew Torba, the CEO of a social networking platform called Gab, which serves as an Internet hangout for the white nationalist/neo-Nazi/white supremacist/QAnon crowd, virulent antisemites all. America is a Christian nation, he said, and it is in need of a great restoration.

Devin Burghart, executive director of the Institute for Research and Education on Human Rights, warns that some extremist rightwing militias even see Putins invasion as their model for what has to happen here. They see a societal collapse and need to prepare for an impending civil war, and their focus is on preparing for the battles of that here in the U.S., he says.

Torba would seem to be one of them. Echoing Jesus advice to his apostles on the morning before the so-called Last Supper, Torba told his AFPAC audience, If you dont have a sword, then sell your cloak and buy one. Whatever Jesus meant by those words, what Torba was saying was that it is time for the American people to rise up in force against what he calls the Synagogue of Satan.

Along the route of Bostons St. Patricks Day Parade a week ago Sunday, a group of roughly 20 members of the neo-Nazi Nationalist Social Club brazenly unfurled a banner that read, Keep Boston Irish. The message should be clear to everyone because Boston has a Midwest-born mayor of Chinese descent, Michelle Wu. Said Dave Falvey, commander of the South Boston Allied Veterans Council, the group that sponsored the parade, As a Jewish American, it hits especially close to home for me.

White Christian Nationalist support for Vladimir Putin should hit all of us close to home.

Shammai Engelmayer is a rabbi-emeritus of Congregation Beth Israel of the Palisades and an adult education teacher in Bergen County. He is the author of eight books and the winner of 10 awards for his commentaries. His website is http://www.shammai.org.

See original here:
Putin, the haters White Knight - The Jewish Standard