Is there something in the California water that makes Silicon Valleys censorious dweebs so damned shameless?
On Wednesday, Facebook revised its policy of banning posts suggesting the coronavirus was man-made because the COVID situation is, er, evolving, as a spokesman told Politico.
Gee, thanks. The flip-flop comes more than a year after the social-media giant banned a well-reasoned Post opinion column by China scholar Steven Mosher that speculated about a potential lab leak. Will our columnist receive an apology? Of course not. But its the American people who should be holding the Menlo Park tyrants to account.
Think about it: If you were Xi Jinping, and you wanted to deploy an information-control operation over the origins of COVID-19, you couldnt have done better than to just let Facebook, working in conjunction with Americas bottom-feeding fact-checking industry, do its thing.
The Chi-Coms, after all, were held in odium in the US eye long before the first COVID cases arrived: How much more effective and devious to have a gazillion-dollar US tech firm shut down public inquiry into the virus origins, and that with the help of well-credentialed experts and fact-checkers.
Its worth returning to what Mosher wrote to see how shameful Facebooks censorship was. For starters, note that Mosher didnt definitively claim that COVID-19 had leaked from a lab. What he argued, rather, is that a lab leak should be plausible to anyone familiar with Chinese realities. Among the pieces of evidence he marshaled:
The fact that Xi himself had, in the early days of the crisis, warned about lab safety as a national-security priority.
The fact that, following Xis guidance, the Chinese Ministry of Science and Technology released a new directive titled: Instructions on strengthening biosecurity management in microbiology labs that handle advanced viruses like the novel coronavirus.
Above all, the fact that the Middle Kingdom has only one Level 4 microbiology lab that can handle deadly coronaviruses and that lab just happens to be located at the epicenter of the epidemic.
Set aside any other scientific questions about the virus (many remain unresolved): Didnt it at least merit some thought that the countrys sole coronavirus lab is located at the outbreaks ground zero?
Even if Mosher were wrong and a growing number of US security officials and top scientists are coming around to his side didnt Americans and their policy makers have the right to consider the possibility? The virus true origins, after all, would inform any number of concrete decisions, not least whether Beijing and the curiously Beijing-subservient World Health Organization deserved US cooperation.
But no. Facebook and its experts knew better and moved to suppress a vital column, distorting the US debate when it mattered most.
Oh, about those experts, whose testimony was used to justify the ban: At least one of them Danielle E. Anderson, an assistant professor at Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore regularly collaborated with the Wuhan virologists, hardly an unconflicted source.
Another expert insisted that no responsible government would permit such deadly leaks, and the quaint assumption that China ranks among responsible governments was enough to merit banning Moshers column to her mind.
Similarly dubious expert claims, amplified by partisan fact-checking outfits like Politifact, were used to frame as conspiracy nuts anyone who dared warn of a potential lab leak. (Politifact has now quietly taken down its denunciation of Fox News Tucker Carlson as a leading conspiracy theorist on this issue.)
This pattern of Big Tech censorship, enabled by unaccountable fact-checkers, poses a catastrophic danger to Americas ability to govern herself and respond to crises.
The problem isnt just that it leaves ordinary Americans in the dark, but that it insulates elites themselves from uncomfortable realities such as the possibility that their beloved Chinese trading partner might be responsible for a pandemic that cost millions of lives.
Enough is enough. Facebook and the other Big Tech giants are irreformable. Only political action in the form of removing the special status that allows them to act like publishers without any of a traditional publishers liabilities can save us from this private tyranny.
Sohrab Ahmari is The Posts op-ed editor and author of the new book The Unbroken Thread: Discovering the Wisdom of Tradition in an Age of Chaos.
Twitter: @SohrabAhmari
See the original post:
Facebook's lab-leak censors owe The Post, and America, an apology - New York Post