Archive for the ‘Chess’ Category
Chess.com Files Motion To Dismiss Niemann Case
Chess.com has formally requested the Eastern Missouri District Court to dismiss GM Hans Niemann's defamation lawsuit. The motion to dismiss, filed on December 2, 2022, asserts that the lawsuit "could have been brought only as a public relations stunt."
Chess.com's answer to Niemann's complaints comes 43 days after the lawsuit was brought to court by Niemann's lawyers on October 20. In their motion, the Chess.com lawyers present a set of arguments as to why the court should not allow the suit to move forward.
In addition to Chess.com, Niemann's lawsuit names GM Magnus Carlsen, GM Hikaru Nakamura, the Play Magnus Group, and IM Danny Rensch as defendants and seeks at least $100 million in damages. Against all five entities, Niemann is claiming slander, libel, unlawful group boycott under the Sherman Act, tortious interference with contract and business expectancies, and civil conspiracy.
Chess.com's lawyers claim that all five elements of Niemann's complaint are "plainly without merit." They reference 71 earlier cases in a motion to dismiss that spans 27 pages. By default, a motion cannot exceed 15 pages, but a joint request by Chess.com and Carlsen to exceed this limit was granted by the court.
Chess.com first addresses Niemann's attempt to assert a federal antitrust claim under the Sherman Act. Niemann's suit suggests that he was unreasonably limited in his ways to make a living through chess tournaments, endorsements, and other business opportunities because Chess.com, PlayMagnus, Carlsen, Nakamura, and Rensch had "concerted actions to ban and blacklist Niemann" from the "global competitive chess industry."
In the motion, Chess.com's lawyers assert that Niemann fails to adequately demonstrate the existence of a conspiracy or group boycott, that there was an actual antitrust injury, and also that there was any alleged agreement that unreasonably restrained trade.
Niemann's asserted claims for libel, slander, tortious interference, and civil conspiracy are "meritless on their face," according to Chess.com lawyers, and "must be dismissed at the threshold because they are barred by Connecticuts anti-Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (anti-SLAPP) statute." This statute allows defendants to file a special motion to dismiss when a complaint is based on the opposing partys exercise of its right of free speech, right to petition the government, or right of association" under the U.S. or Connecticut constitutions.
Chess.com's motion notes that a similar defense has been brought up by Carlsen's lawyers, who have claimed that Connecticuts anti-SLAPP statute precludes all of Niemanns state law claims because Missouri federal courts apply the law of the jurisdiction in which the plaintiff resideshere, Connecticutwhen evaluating state-law claims that, like Niemanns, are rooted in alleged defamation.Citing the suit Fuqua Homes, Inc. v. Beattie (2004), Chess.com argues that Connecticut, therefore, has the "most significant relationship to the issues presented in the case."
Should the court disagree with Chess.com and Carlsen here and deem Connecticuts anti-SLAPP statute irrelevant, the Chess.com lawyers argue that Niemann's defamation claims also fail under the law of Missouri. In their opinion, the allegations require that the defendant must have published a defamatory statement that is "actionable," meaning, "objectively false." Additionally, when a defamatory statement is allegedly made about a public figure, the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution requires the plaintiff to also demonstrate that the statement was published with actual malice. According to Chess.com, none of their statements were objectively false. They are opinions and do not demonstrate actual malice.
Niemanns tortious interference claim fails as well, according to Chess.com. He had argued that, because of actions by Chess.com, PlayMagnus, Carlsen, Nakamura, and Rensch, his scheduled match with the young German grandmaster Vincent Keymer was canceled and that negotiations with the Tata Steel Chess Tournament were abruptly ended. Chess.com states that Niemann "fails to allege any facts regarding Chess.coms actual knowledge of his negotiations with the Tata Steel Chess Tournament or a planned match with Keymer."
Finally, Niemanns standalone claim for civil conspiracy fails, according to Chess.com, because "it is derivative of his other claims" and this conspiracy claim "fails for the independent reason that Niemann does not allege any agreement among the Defendants."
What will happen next is not clear yet. Niemann's lawyers have a chance to respond to this motion, but if they do, Chess.com has an opportunity to submit a reply brief. The court will then likely take the matter up at a hearing before issuing a decision. At the time of writing, it is unclear if other defendants have also issued a motion to dismiss.
Previous coverage:
Read the rest here:
Chess.com Files Motion To Dismiss Niemann Case
The Guardian view on chess cheating claims: innocent until proven guilty – The Guardian
Chess generally hits the headlines only for reasons external to the game itself: Bobby Fischers eccentricity; Viktor Korchnois allegations that the Soviet Union was using hypnotism to undermine him in his 1978 world title match with Anatoly Karpov; the Toiletgate furore that marred the 2006 world championship. Now, the reigning world champion Magnus Carlsens airing of suspicions over the play of the 19-year-old US grandmaster Hans Niemann has put chess into the spotlight again.
Carlsen has been world champion since 2013. Niemann is a tyro who has made astonishingly rapid progress recently. Carlsen has publicly questioned that trajectory, saying on Twitter last week that his over the board progress has been unusual. These days, most elite players become grandmasters in their early teens Carlsen was 13. Niemann, a charismatic character who says his life has been devoted to proving critics who said he wasnt good enough wrong, was a late-developing 17, and his rise to super-GM level has been meteoric.
The controversy erupted when Niemann beat Carlsen last month in the Sinquefield Cup. Niemann said he had somehow guessed what opening Carlsen would play. It was Carlsens first defeat in 53 classical (long-form) games, and he reacted by withdrawing from the tournament, making gnomic references to something being not quite right. If I speak I am in big trouble, he tweeted. Some of his supporters filled in the blanks, with claims that Niemann had computer help. Elon Musk unhelpfully suggested that he was using unusual methods; Niemann countered by offering to strip naked.
Carlsen and Niemann met again last month in an online game, and the world champion sensationally resigned after making just one move. Carlsen said he was unwilling to play against people that have cheated repeatedly in the past, and that he believed the younger man had cheated more than he has admitted. Niemann has acknowledged cheating online as a teenager, but insists he has never done so in an over-the-board game and angrily denies the new claims. Once a cheat, always a cheat, chorus his detractors, but Niemann should surely not be condemned for youthful misdemeanours in games where little was at stake. There is no evidence that he cheated when he beat Carlsen.
The world champion is right to say that cheating poses an existential challenge to chess there have been many examples at less exalted levels of the sport. But he is wrong to muddy the waters around Niemann without substantive evidence. Britains former world title contender Nigel Short says that the young American is at risk of suffering death by innuendo. Experts reckon Carlsen played unusually poorly in his defeat to Niemann. Maybe it was just a bad day at the office. Or perhaps it was the result of paranoia: once a player believes their opponent is cheating, that inevitably affects their own play. Carlsen needs to produce concrete evidence ideally as part of the inquiry announced on Thursday by the International Chess Federation or let Niemann get on with his career. Only by playing over a long period will the latters true playing strength emerge while any repeated cheating in the rarefied conditions of elite tournaments would soon be exposed.
Read more:
The Guardian view on chess cheating claims: innocent until proven guilty - The Guardian
Chess legends to be inducted into the U.S. and World Chess Halls of Fame – ChessBase
Chess history will be made this year at induction ceremonies recognizing several exceptional contributors to the iconic game as the newest members of the U.S. and World Chess Halls of Fame. The first ceremony will honor 2022 U.S. Chess Hall of Fame inductees Daniel Willard Fiske, James Tarjan and John Watson, as well as 2021 World Chess Hall of Fame inductees Miguel Najdorf and Eugene Torre. This ceremony will take place during the public opening ceremony of the 2022 U.S. Chess Championship and U.S. Womens Chess Championship, featuring the strongest chess players in Americaheld at the St. Louis Aquarium at Union Station in Saint Louis, Missouri, on October 4, 2022, at 5:30 p.m. The tournament itself will be played at the Saint Louis Chess Club, which has hosted the U.S Chess Championships for the past 13 years. The second ceremony, which will honor 2021 World Chess Hall of Fame inductee Judit Polgar, will be announced at a future date.
Master Class Vol.1: Bobby Fischer
No other World Champion was more infamous both inside and outside the chess world than Bobby Fischer. On this DVD, a team of experts shows you the winning techniques and strategies employed by the 11th World Champion.
Grandmaster Dorian Rogozenco delves into Fischers openings, and retraces the development of his repertoire. What variations did Fischer play, and what sources did he use to arm himself against the best Soviet players? Mihail Marin explains Fischers particular style and his special strategic talent in annotated games against Spassky, Taimanov and other greats. Karsten Mller is not just a leading international endgame expert, but also a true Fischer connoisseur.
In 2022, three candidates were selected for induction into the U.S. Chess Hall of Fame by the US Chess Recognitions Committee and confirmed by the U.S. Chess Trust: Daniel Willard Fiske, a major pioneer in chess organization, journalism and more, who originated the idea of a nationwide American Chess Congress and helped make it a reality in 1857, in addition to influencing the creation of the American Chess Association (a precursor to todays US Chess) and playing an important role in standardizing the rules of chess; James Tarjan, who represented the United States in five Chess Olympiads, winning four team and three individual medals with a winning percentage that places him equal second to Bobby Fischer, and also achieved the best-ever rating performance by an American player aged 65 or older; and John Watson, one of the greatest writers in the history of American chess who authored many groundbreaking books during the past four decades including Secrets of Modern Chess Strategy (2002) and Chess Strategy in Action (2023), and was the first-ever US. National High School champion and a U.S. Chess Championship participant.
All three of this years inductees have made an incredible impact on the game and sport of chess, said US Chess Trust President E. Steven Doyle. Fiskes influence as an early U.S. chess journalist, Tarjans distinctive Chess Olympiad accomplishments and Watsons lifetime of chess instruction and coaching are accolades deserving of recognition in the U.S. Chess Hall of Fame.
In 2021, the International Chess Federation (Fdration Internationale des checs or FIDE) nominated three new members for the World Chess Hall of Fame. Inductees include Judit Polgar, who is universally considered to be the strongest woman chess player of all time and broke Bobby Fischers record as the worlds youngest grandmaster; Miguel Najdorf, whose name is associated with one of the most famous openings in chess, the Najdorf Variation of the Sicilian Defense, in addition to being one of the most successful performers in Chess Olympiad history; and Eugene Torre, a trailblazer for Asian chess for half a century, achieving a number of continental milestones including the first grandmaster, first to defeat a reigning world champion, and first to reach the Candidates stage of the World Championship.
The 2021 World Chess Hall of Fame inductees exemplify the global impact and inclusivity chess has to offer, and were honored to include their contributions to the games rich history, said FIDE Special Project Director Willy Iclicki.
Inductees of both Halls of Fame are chosen for their impact on the sport and have included players, authors, journalists, scholars, organizers and supporters of the game. Each player will be commemorated at the World Chess Hall of Fame (WCHOF) in Saint Louis with a plaque bearing their image and biography. Notable games and highlights will also be featured in a digital interactive gallery.
The World Chess Hall of Fame in Saint Louis commends all of the 2021 and 2022 inductees and we look forward to celebrating their unique achievements at their induction ceremonies, said Shannon Bailey, WCHOFs chief curator.
For more information about the Chess Halls of Fame, please visit the WCHOFs website at worldchesshof.org. For more information about the U.S. Chess Championship and U.S. Womens Chess Championship, please visit saintlouischessclub.org. To schedule interviews, please contact WCHOF Marketing Manager Brian Flowers at brian.flowers@worldchesshof.org or call (314) 243-1571.
Daniel Willard Fiske(1831-1904)
Daniel Willard Fiske was a major pioneer in chess organization, journalism, literature and historical preservation whose influence is still felt today. He originated the idea of a nationwide American Chess Congress and helped to make it a reality in 1857. Without this tournament, it is doubtful whether American chess star Paul Morphy would have achieved more than local fame. Fiskes massive book on the event not only gives the games of the Congress but also deals with the creation of the American Chess Association (a precursor to todays US Chess) and the authors important role in standardizing the rules of chess. He was also arguably the most influential early U.S. chess journalist, earning renown through his magazine The Chess Monthly and newspaper column in the New York Saturday Press.
James Tarjan(1952- )
Few have represented the United States in Chess Olympiads with greater distinction than James Tarjan. He played five times from 1974 to 1982, winning four team (one gold, three bronze) and three individual (two gold and one bronze) medals. His lifetime winning percentage of 75.5% places him equal second among Americans with Bobby Fischer and Arthur Dake. An active player from 1965 to his 1984 retirement, Tarjan returned to the game in 2014 with spectacular results. In 2017, he defeated former World Champion Vladimir Kramnik, then ranked number three in the world at 2803 FIDE, en route to a rating performance of 2671, to date the best ever result by an American player aged 65 or older.
John Watson(1951- )
John Watson is one of the greatest writers in the history of American chess. Among the many important books he has authored during the past four decades are the groundbreaking Secrets of Modern Chess Strategy (2002) and Chess Strategy in Action (2003). He authored seminal works on the English Opening and French Defense. A frequent contributor to Chess Life since the 1970s, Watson is well-known for his insightful book reviews. He was a pioneer in early internet journalism, with weekly shows including Chess Talk with John Watson for the Internet Chess Club. An international master, Watson was the first U.S. National High School champion and a U.S. Chess Championship participant. He has a lifetime of experience in chess teaching and coaching.
Judit Polgar(1976- )
Judit Polgar is universally recognized as the strongest female player of all time. She was first rated in the top 100 players in the world at age 12 when she won three gold medals at the 1988 Olympiad in Thessaloniki. This performance also catapulted Judit to the world's number 1 ranking for women, a position that she maintained for the next 26 years. Judit broke Bobby Fischers record as the youngest grandmaster in 1991. Polgar is the only woman to have ever reached the Candidates stage in the world, and to have been rated over 2700, reaching a peak of 2735 in 2005. During her career, she defeated 11 current or former world champions in rapid or classical chess. Polgar was a member of the 2014 silver medal-winning Hungarian Olympiad team and won seven other medals in Olympiads.
Miguel Najdorf(1910-1997)
Miguel Najdorf, whose name is associated with one of the most famous openings in chess, was one of the top players in the world in the 1940s and 1950s. Born in Poland, he settled in Argentina after playing in the 1939 Buenos Aires Chess Olympiad. He was also one of the most successful performers in Olympiad history, winning seven team (four silver and three bronze) and four individual medals (three gold and one silver) in 14 competitions over four decades. In 1947, he faced 45 opponents in blindfold chess, setting a record that stood until 2011.
Eugene Torre(1951- )
Philippine grandmaster Eugene Torre has been a trailblazer for Asian chess for half a century, achieving a number of continental milestones including first grandmaster (1974), first to defeat a reigning world champion (Anatoly Karpov in 1976) and first to reach the Candidates stage of the World Championship (1982-1983). A member of the Philippine Olympiad team a record 23 times, Torre won three individual medals on board one (silver at Nice 1974 and bronze at Malta 1980 and Dubai 1986). He also won a bronze medal on board three at Baku 2016 at the age of 64. Torre was the official second of Bobby Fischer in his 1992 rematch with Boris Spassky.
The World Chess Hall of Fame (WCHOF) celebrates the accomplishments of the game's greatest players from the United States and across the globe. The institution houses both the U.S. and World Chess Halls of Fame. New inductees are honored in an annual ceremony, which has been held in Saint Louis, Missouri, since 2011. Since 2012, the inductions have been held during the opening ceremonies for the annual U.S. Chess Championship and U.S. Womens Chess Championships.
The Saint Louis Chess Club (STLCC) is a nonprofit, 501(c)(3) organization that is committed to making chess an important part of our community. In addition to providing a forum for the community to play tournaments and casual games, the Club also offers chess improvement classes, beginner lessons and special lectures.
Recognizing the cognitive and behavioral benefits of chess, the Saint Louis Chess Club is committed to supporting those chess programs that already exist in area schools while encouraging the development of new in-school and after-school programs. For more information, visit saintlouischessclub.org.
Each year, candidates for induction to the U.S. Chess Hall of Fame are nominated by the US Chess Recognitions Committee. which includes leading chess historians. The Committees selections are sent to the US Chess Executive Board for review, and the Board's recommendations are then forwarded to the US Chess Trust. whose Trustees have the official authority to determine inductees into the US Chess Hall of Fame. The induction ceremony takes place at the World Chess Hall of Fame or at the annual US Chess Awards luncheon. A representative of the US Chess Trust performs the official induction, using the official Hall of Fame gavel.
Representatives of the World Chess Federation (Fdration Internationale des checs, or FIDE) nominate and select new candidates for induction into the World Chess Hall of Fame. Members of the World Chess Hall of Fame are chosen for their total contribution to the sport. Players as well as others who have made an impact as authors, journalists, organizers and in other ways are eligible for induction.
The US Chess Trust is a nonprofit, 501(c)(3) organization. Through the Trust, the Samford Fellowships have helped develop our nations top young chess players. Typically, nine of 12 players in the U.S. Championship are former or current Samford Fellows.
The Trust sponsors the senior, junior and girls national invitational events for state champions at the annual U.S. Open and provides numerous college scholarships. For more information, visit uschesstrust.org.
The US Chess Federation (US Chess) is the official governing body and nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization for chess players and chess supporters in the United States. Our mission is to empower people, enrich lives, and enhance communities through chess. Our vision is that chess is recognized as an essential tool that is inclusive, benefits education and rehabilitation, and promotes recreation and friendly competition.
US Chess represents the United States in the World Chess Federation (FIDE), connecting our members to chess players around the world. Founded in 1939 with the merger of the American Chess Federation and the National Chess Federation, US Chess has grown to serve over 93,000 members and 2,000 affiliated chess clubs and organizations today. For more information, visit uschess.org.
The World Chess Hall of Fame (WCHOF) is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization committed to building awareness of the cultural and artistic significance of chess. It opened on September 9, 2011, in the Central West End after moving from previous locations in New York; Washington, D.C.; and Florida. The WCHOF is located at 4652 Maryland Avenue, housed in a historic 15,900 square-foot residence-turned-business, featuring World Chess Hall of Fame inductees, United States Chess Hall of Fame inductees selected by the U.S. Chess Trust, displays of artifacts from the permanent collection and exhibitions highlighting the great players, historic games and rich cultural history of chess. The WCHOF partners with the Saint Louis Chess Club to provide innovative programming and outreach to local, national and international audiences. For more information, visit worldchesshof.org.
View post:
Chess legends to be inducted into the U.S. and World Chess Halls of Fame - ChessBase