Archive for the ‘Erdogan’ Category

Erdogan Cancels Meeting With Bolton, As U.S. Seeks To …

Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan canceled a meeting with U.S. national security adviser John Bolton on Tuesday, in an apparent snub. Erdogan disagrees with U.S. calls to protect Kurdish militants in Syria who have helped in the fight against ISIS. Burhan Ozbilici/AP hide caption

Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan canceled a meeting with U.S. national security adviser John Bolton on Tuesday, in an apparent snub. Erdogan disagrees with U.S. calls to protect Kurdish militants in Syria who have helped in the fight against ISIS.

Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has apparently snubbed U.S. national security adviser John Bolton, canceling a planned meeting to discuss the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Syria as well as the fate of a U.S.-allied Kurdish militia fighting ISIS in Syria.

Bolton's meeting with Erdogan was canceled moments before it was to begin, reflecting Turkish anger at Bolton's insistence that those Kurdish forces be protected after more than 2,000 American troops exit northeastern Syria.

Erdogan cited the "local election season and a speech to parliament for not meeting with Bolton," The Associated Press reports. But the Turkish leader also used his speech to rail against protection for the YPG, which he considers a terrorist organization allied with separatist Kurdish groups operating within Turkey.

Bolton's trip to Turkey comes as he and U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo are visiting American allies in the region, seeking to quiet concerns and ease confusion about U.S. policies following President Trump's surprise announcement last month that all U.S. troops will be leaving Syria.

Trump's withdrawal order sparked questions and pushback including the resignation of Defense Secretary Jim Mattis. And key questions remain about ISIS, the fate of Kurdish fighters and control over the land they've seized in Syria's long-running civil war.

Unlike the U.S., Turkey "sees these Kurdish authorities as being aligned with militants it considers terrorists, and has threatened to attack the parts of Syria they control," NPR's Ruth Sherlock reports.

The distrust runs both ways. In Syria, Kurdish leaders aren't happy at the possibility their territory might fall into Turkey's grasp leading them to hold previously unthinkable negotiations with Syrian President Bashar Assad's government.

"Kurdish militias here have sacrificed hundreds of lives in fighting ISIS and taking control of this territory," Sherlock reports, "and they see Turkey as a bigger threat than ISIS to their survival."

Bolton did meet with Turkish presidential adviser Ibrahim Kalin on Tuesday, but that session didn't seem to produce any breakthroughs. Afterward, Kalin said that while Turkey is willing to coordinate some activities, its military doesn't need to ask anyone's permission to conduct operations over the Syrian border.

Around the time of the Bolton-Kalin meeting, Erdogan was speaking to Parliament and renewing his public stance against the YPG.

"Erdogan said preparations for a military operation in northern Syria are 'complete,' " NPR's Peter Kenyon reports from Istanbul. "He added there would be 'no concessions' in Turkey's fight against terror groups, and rejected Bolton's comment that Syrian Kurdish fighters would not be harmed."

By emphasizing the differences between his views and Bolton's, Erdogan echoed his New York Times op-ed piece from Monday, in which he said that with the U.S. leaving, it's time for Turkey's military to take control.

But that same day, Pompeo said the Turkish leader had previously offered reassurances that Turkey would protect U.S. allies referring to the Kurds. Pompeo said Erdogan made the commitment during a phone call with Trump just before the U.S. president announced the troop withdrawal.

On Dec. 19, when Trump ordered the Pentagon to pull U.S. troops out of Syria, he said he was doing so because their mission was over.

"Our boys, our young women, our men, they're all coming back, and they're coming back now," Trump said, as he declared victory over ISIS.

But Trump has recently acknowledged that ISIS has not been eradicated entirely, and his mentions of the timing for withdrawal have become much less concrete.

"We won't be finally pulled out until ISIS is gone," Trump said Sunday.

Over the weekend, Bolton said the drawdown is subject to conditions and that there is no set deadline.

"There are objectives that we want to accomplish that condition the withdrawal," Bolton told reporters in Jerusalem. "The timetable flows from the policy decisions that we need to implement," he said, seemingly in reference to the fight against ISIS and the future of the Kurdish militia.

The mixed messages have created confusion over exactly what the U.S. policy is in Syria and the broader region and that perception has persisted, despite State Department officials' insistence last week that "the United States is not leaving the Middle East."

Hoping to clarify American policy for some of its most vital allies, Pompeo has begun a weeklong trip through the region. He started it off in Amman, Jordan, where he said Tuesday that the Syrian pullout doesn't mean the U.S. is abandoning the international fight against ISIS.

"That battle continues," Pompeo said. "The president's decision to withdraw our folks from Syria in no way impacts our capacity to deliver on that."

There is also some fence-mending to do. Bolton's visit to Ankara comes one week after Pompeo angered the Turkish government by saying the U.S. wants to be sure "the Turks don't slaughter the Kurds."

Pompeo doesn't plan to visit Turkey on his current trip. After Amman, Pompeo is slated to visit at least eight Middle East capitals, from Cairo to Riyadh and Kuwait City.

In the background of the talk about ISIS and Kurdish fighters, another spat is bubbling between the U.S. and Turkey, centering on the NATO ally's recent arms deal with Russia.

As NPR's Kenyon reports, "Washington is displeased with Ankara's move to buy Russian S-400 missiles, and has recently offered to sell them Patriot missiles instead."

NPR Diplomatic Correspondent Michele Kelemen contributed to this story.

See the original post:
Erdogan Cancels Meeting With Bolton, As U.S. Seeks To ...

Turkey’s Erdogan blasts John Bolton over ‘unacceptable …

Turkey's Erdogan blasts John Bolton over 'unacceptable' comments on Syrian Kurdish militia (function(){ var zergnet = document.createElement('script'); zergnet.type = 'text/javascript'; zergnet.async = true; zergnet.src = (document.location.protocol == 'https:' ? 'https:' : 'http:') + '//www.zergnet.com/zerg.js?id=63310'; var znscr = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; znscr.parentNode.insertBefore(zergnet, znscr) })(); "+"ipt>";var zergnet_below_content_code = "(function(){ var zergnet = document.createElement('script'); zergnet.type = 'text/javascript'; zergnet.async = true; zergnet.src = (document.location.protocol == 'https:' ? 'https:' : 'http:') + '//www.zergnet.com/zerg.js?id=65997'; var znscr = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; znscr.parentNode.insertBefore(zergnet, znscr) })(); "+"ipt>";var survey_code = "";var connatix_in_content_code = '';var ora_below_content_code = "";//console.log( "lazy load connatix in content" ); jQuery('#story-page-embedded-after2-ad').html( connatix_in_content_code );//console.log( "lazy load ora below content" ); jQuery('#oratv-desktop-container').html( ora_below_content_code );console.log( "lazy load zergnet below_content" );jQuery('#zergnet-below-content-ll-target').html( zergnet_below_content_code );console.log( "lazy load zergnet sidebar" );jQuery('#zergnet_lazy_target').html( zergnet_sidebar_code );console.log( "lazy load below content survey" );jQuery('#below-comment-survey').html( survey_code);}); Google+

Visit link:
Turkey's Erdogan blasts John Bolton over 'unacceptable ...

Erdogan Refusing to Meet Bolton in Ankara over Dishonorable …

Photo Credit: Screenshot

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Tuesday refused to meet with US National Security Adviser John Bolton in Ankara, according to US officials.

Bolton came on a two-day visit in Turkey to discuss the withdrawal of 2,000 US troops from Syria. On Sunday, while in Israel, Bolton said he would seek assurances from Erdogan not to harm the Kurds the US would be leaving behind unprotected in Syria, which appears to have a condition of the withdrawal.

On Tuesday, Erdogan slammed Bolton for his recent claim that Turkey targets Kurds in Syria.

It is impossible to accept the message given by Mr. Bolton in Israel, Erdogan told members of his ruling Justice and Development [AK] Partys parliamentary delegation.

The claims that Turkey targets Kurds in Syria are dishonorable, ugly, vulgar and defaming, Erdogan said.

Bolton was demoted to meeting with a Turkish delegation that did not include the president. National Security Council spokesman said the two sides had a productive discussion. The meeting took place at the Presidential Complex in Ankara and lasted around two hours.

Bolton left the Turkish capital on Tuesday, leaving behind Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Joseph Dunford and Special Envoy for Syria James Jeffrey.

Turkey announced last month that it was planning a counter-terrorist operation targeting both Turkish and Syrian Kurdish military forces in Syria.

Read the original here:
Erdogan Refusing to Meet Bolton in Ankara over Dishonorable ...

Erdogan, Trump, and the Khashoggi Murder | Center for …

December 12, 2018

Saudi dissident journalist Jamal Khashoggi was posthumously named Times Person of the Year, along with four other journalists, for taking great risks in pursuit of greater truths on December 11. The terrible fate of Khashoggi, who paid the ultimate price in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul on October 2 at the hands of 15 agents who had arrived from Riyadh the previous day, not only triggered a global storm of indignation but also set in motion a major diplomatic gambit by President Recep Tayyip Erdogan in the pursuit of a number of related objectives involving President Donald Trump and impacting U.S.-Turkish relations.

Erdogans primary aim was to effectively and irrevocably tie Khashoggis disappearance and murder to Saudi Arabia and, without ever naming him directly, Mohammad bin Salman (MBS), the crown prince and de facto ruler of Saudi Arabia, who had elevated himself into an obstacle to Turkish regional calculations through his public identification of Turkey under Erdogans leadership as a major threat in the region along with Iran as well as his ongoing blockade of Qatar. His next goal was to try to force the Trump administration, which had been backing MBS without any apparent reservation prior to the murder as a key partner in its Middle East plans, to review its relationship with him. Lacking significant direct leverage over Riyadh, Erdogan hoped to induce pressure by Trumpinconceivable before Khashoggis murderto either force MBS out or to weaken him into ineffectiveness.

At the same time, Erdogan wished to use interaction on this issue with Washington to improve his relationship with Trump, which had been shaken by the incarceration of Pastor Andrew Brunson in Turkey and the associated U.S. sanctions to bring about his release as well as by the continued absence of progress on issues, which have long divided the two countries, such as Fethullah Gulens stalled extradition, Pentagons engagement with the Syrian Kurdish YPG, and the Halkbank case. Last but not least, Erdogan expected to leverage Turkeys vigorous advocacy for justice in the horrible crime against a journalist on Turkish soil to try to reverse the negative stream of news relating to Turkeys record on press freedom.

The core of the strategy was a daily series of leaks by unnamed officials to correspondents based in Istanbul, especially U.S. journalists, to ensure that the issue remained in headlines while destroying the attempts by Saudi Arabia to deny the murder. On October 23, Erdogan personally escalated the campaign in a speech at the Turkish Grand National Assembly in which he asked Saudi Arabia to lay bare all perpetrators from top to bottom and hold them accountable before the law and for the execution team to be extradited to Turkey. Erdogans broadside was followed on October 31 by a formal indictment issued by an Istanbul prosecutor, which charged after extensive investigations that Khashoggis body was dismembered and destroyed following his death by suffocationin accordance with plans made in advance. The constant pressure from Turkey forced Saudi Arabia to change its admittedly flimsy narrative several times from claiming that Khashoggi had left the consulate alive to suggesting he was killed in a fight, blaming it on a rogue operation and eventually admitting that it was premeditated and indicting 21 officials, including the 15-man hit team.

Despite the apparently irrefutable evidence being released, Erdogan chose to not only refrain from naming MBS as the instigator of the crime but also to maintain contact with Saudi Arabia throughout the month. This included a meeting with Salmans emissary Prince Khalid bin Faisal on October 11during which, according to the New York Times on October 22, citing an unnamed Turkish source close to Erdogan, he reportedly offered financial aid and investment and an end to the Saudi blockade on Qatar in exchange for Turkey dropping the Khashoggi case, an offer that was angrily rejected by Erdogan as a political bribetwo phone conversations between Erdogan and King Salman on October 14 and October 20, followed by one with MBS himself on October 24, as well as fruitless discussions in the context of an agreed Joint Working Group with the Saudi Prosecutor General in Istanbul on October 29-30. It is clear, however, as his expression of deep respect for Salman and emphasis on the importance of the Turkish-Saudi relationship in his October 23 speech showed, Erdogans offensive against MBS relied primarily on trying to persuade Trump to apply pressure on him.

On October 15, Trump publicly indicated his awareness of the vigorous media campaign being waged by Erdogan on this issue by commenting that Turkey was being tough, very tough. He then instructed Secretary of State Mike Pompeo to discuss the case with Erdogan in Istanbul on October 17 on his way back from a meeting with MBS in Riyadh. It is interesting to note that NBC reported on November 15, citing numerous U.S. officials, that Erdogan had used the meeting to once again press Pompeo for Gulens extradition. The two leaders then talked on the phone on October 21 and, according to the White House readout, agreed on the need to clear up the Jamal Khashoggi incident with all its aspects. This was followed by CIA Director Gina Haspels visit to Turkey on October 23, which, unlike that of Pompeo, reportedly included listening to the audio recording covertly obtained by Turkish authorities of the asphyxiation and dismemberment of the hapless journalist.

On November 2, Erdogan tried to increase domestic pressure on Trump through the Washington Post with which Khashoggi was affiliated as a columnist. In an op-ed, he asked: Where is Khashoggis body? Where is the local collaborator to whom Saudi officials claimed to have handed over Khashoggis remains? Who gave the order to kill this kind soul? He continued, Unfortunately, the Saudi authorities have refused to answer those questions . . . We know that the order to kill Khashoggi came from the highest levels of the Saudi government. Some seem to hope this problem will go away in time. But we will keep asking those questions . . . As responsible members of the international community, we must reveal the identities of the puppet masters behind Khashoggis killing and discover those in whom Saudi officialsstill trying to cover up the murderhave placed their trust.

However, despite the evidence presented by Ankara and its sustained media effort, the Trump administration did not break with MBS as Erdogan had hoped. Pompeo stated on November 1 that the United States had important commercial relationships, important strategic relationships, national security relationships with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, and we intend to make sure that those relationships remain intact. Following the Saudi public prosecutors announcement that he would seek the death penalty for 5 of the 11 charged with Khashoggi murdera move described by most outsiders as a cover upthe State Department immediately announced symbolic sanctions on November 15 against 17 Saudis for their alleged roles. After his meetings with national security adviser John Bolton and Pompeo in Washington on November 20, where the Khashoggi case was discussed, Turkish foreign minister Mevlut Cavusoglu voiced public disappointment with the U.S. position. He said: Many countries do not want to harm their relations with Saudi Arabia because of the Khashoggi murder. Neither do we. However, the murder must be uncovered.

Even after it was reported on November 16 by the Washington Post that the CIA had independently concluded that MBS had ordered the assassination, a White House statement bearing Trumps inimitable style reaffirmed on November 20 that the United States would continue to stand behind MBS. It said King Salman and Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman vigorously deny any knowledge of the planning or execution of the murder of Mr. Khashoggi. Our intelligence agencies continue to assess all information, but it could very well be that the Crown Prince had knowledge of this tragic eventmaybe he did and maybe he didnt! That being said, we may never know all of the facts surrounding the murder of Mr. Jamal Khashoggi. In any case, our relationship is with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. They have been a great ally in our very important fight against Iran. The United States intends to remain a steadfast partner of Saudi Arabia to ensure the interests of our country, Israel and all other partners in the region.

On November 22, Trump specifically downplayed the CIA report by saying, I do not know if anyone is going to be able to conclude the crown prince did it. But whether he did or whether he did not, he denies it vehemently. The CIA does not say they did it, they do point out certain things and in pointing out those things that you can conclude that maybe he did or maybe he did not. Cavusoglu, who had just returned to Turkey, responded directly to the comments on November 23 by saying, Trumps statements amount to him saying Ill turn a blind eye no matter what. This is not a correct approach. Money is not everything. We must not move away from human values.

Trumps continuing disinclination to act was confirmed by the secretary of defense Jim Mattis and Pompeo at a closed Senate hearing on November 28. Afterward, Pompeo warned that degrading ties with Saudi Arabia would be a grave mistake for U.S. national security, and that of our allies. The Kingdom is a powerful force for stability in an otherwise fraught Middle East. Mattis added, I must note we are seldom free to work with unblemished partners . . . Saudi Arabia, due to geography and the Iranian threat, is fundamental to maintaining regional and Israeli security and to our interest in Mideast stability. Pompeo further underlined the administrations position in a TV interview on December 1 by saying, I have read every piece of intelligence that is in the possession of the United States government . . . There is no direct evidence linking him [MBS] to the murder of Jamal Khashoggi . . . They are a relationship that has mattered for 70 years across Republican and Democrat administrations alike. It remains an important relationship, and were aiming to keep that relationship.

Haspel, who reportedly was not allowed by the White House to join the November 28 briefing, provided a separate special briefing to the Senate on December 4, which prompted a number of the limited group of participants to declare afterwards that it had confirmed MBSs direct involvement as well as their inclination to support possible congressional action. Haspel may have also been instrumental in facilitating an unannounced unusual visit to the Senate on December 7 by her Turkish counterpart Hakan Fidan, one of Erdogans closest aides, which, according to a Reuters report on the same day citing five sources, included a reiteration of the Turkish case on the Khashoggi murder.

However, there would be no change in Trumps position. On December 10, Trumps son-in-law and senior adviser, Jared Kushner, long-identified as MBSs closest contact in the U.S. government, said that the focus of the administration had shifted away from the Khashoggi case. He said, We are focused now on the broader region, which is hopefully figuring out how to bring a deal together between the Israelis and the Palestinians. When asked whether standing by Saudi Arabia meant standing by MBS on December 11, Trump said, Well, at this moment, it certainly does. He's the leader of Saudi Arabia. They've been a very good ally. He added "I really hope that people aren't going to suggest that we should not take hundreds of billions of dollars that they're going to siphon off to Russia and to China, primarily those two, instead of giving it to us. You're talking about hundreds of thousands of jobs. You're talking about huge military and other contracts.

There is little doubt that Trumps desire to continue to rely on MBS in pursuing the long-shot goal of implementing the from the outside in Middle East peace plan Kushner has reportedly been developing for almost two years; maintaining high Saudi production in order to keep oil prices low especially as Iranian oil is being sanctioned by the U.S. and confronting Iran across the entire region, along with the projected arms sales by the U.S. to Saudi Arabiathe value of which has been invariably exaggerated by Trump in all of his statements on Khashoggihave stymied Erdogans goal of driving a wedge between the two countries. Feeling emboldened by the Trump administrations support, Saudi Arabia rejected Turkeys extradition request for those involved Khashoggis murder on December 10. This led Turkish justice minister Abdulhamit Gul along with Cavusoglu to reiterate Erdogans threat that Turkey would continue pursuing the case through the UN, a prospect which is unlikely to have any effect on MBS, whose position, much to the disappointment of Erdogan, seems to be secure for the moment despite the inevitable damage to his reputation.

As the Khashoggi murder fades from the front pages, it is also ceding its prominent position on the agenda of the U.S.-Turkish bilateral relationship. While it is difficult to ascertain with any degree of accuracy the impact on relations, it is safe to say that Erdogans disappointment in Trumps stubborn reluctance to act against MBS is matched by Trumps reciprocal disappointment in Erdogan for pursuing an issue he never wanted to handle with such determination. To be sure, Turkey enjoyed the unusually positive press coverage it received in the U.S. as it defended the need to take action against the instigator as well as the perpetrators of the Khashoggi murder. However, as the interest of the U.S. media inevitably drifts elsewherenot least to Trumps growing legal problemsattention shifts back to all the other seemingly intractable issues on the U.S.-Turkish agenda.

Bulent Aliriza is a senior associate and director of the Turkey Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Washington, D.C

Commentary is produced by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), a private, tax-exempt institution focusing on international public policy issues. Its research is nonpartisan and nonproprietary. CSIS does not take specific policy positions. Accordingly, all views, positions, and conclusions expressed in this publication should be understood to be solely those of the author(s).

2018 by the Center for Strategic and International Studies. All rights reserved.

See the rest here:
Erdogan, Trump, and the Khashoggi Murder | Center for ...

Turkish lira slides as Erdogan rejects U.S. calls, threatens …

The Turkish lira on Tuesday fell sharply against the U.S. dollar as well, as the euro, as tensions between Turkey and the U.S. over military involvement in Syria took a negative turn.

The lira USDTRY, +0.8361% EURTRY, +0.5569% dropped nearly 2% against the U.S. dollar and more than 1.5% against the euro. The greenback last bought 5.4925 lira, up from 5.3848 lira late Monday in New York, while one euro fetched 6.2827 lira, down 1.67. It was the worst-performing currency of the day in Tuesday trading.

A stronger U.S. dollar DXY, +0.12% against most of its rivals exacerbated weakening for the Turkish currency.

One condition President Donald Trump placed on a much-publicized plan to withdraw U.S. troops from Syria was an assurance of safety of Syrian Kurdish allies. Kurdish forces had fought alongside the U.S. against Islamic State, but are viewed as a terrorist group by the Turkish government.

Turkeys Kurdish minority many of whom of live in the countrys southeast, bordering Syria, Iraq and Iran has long laid claim to becoming an independent nation.

Read: Bolton says U.S. wont leave Syria until Islamic State is defeated, Kurds are safe

White House national-security adviser John Bolton was in Ankara on Tuesday to compel Turkey not to target Kurdish fighters.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip instead warned in an address to the Turkish parliament that Ankara, which has stationed troops along the border, stood ready to launch an offensive into northern Syria, describing it as a necessary lesson to the Kurdish fighters.

John Bolton made a serious mistake, Erdogan said in front of parliament. Those who share the same view are also deeply wrong.

Erdogan refused to meet with Bolton.

Relations between Washington and Ankara were already frayed, largely due to U.S. pastor Andrew Brunson, who was detained in Turkey. Brunson was released in October 2018. The worsening diplomatic ties, paired with weak economic fundamentals in Turkey and threats of trade tariffs from the U.S., have spooked investors.

Turkeys economy has been struggling with high, double-digit consumer-price inflation, an ailing currency and rising interest rates in the U.S., which have made Ankaras dollar-denominated debt burden more expensive in local currency terms.

In 2018, the dollar rallied 39.4% against the lira, reflecting the economic and political struggles, as well as currency crisis that Turkey struggled with throughout 2018.

Want news about Europe delivered to your inbox? Subscribe to MarketWatch's free Europe Daily newsletter. Sign up here.

See the rest here:
Turkish lira slides as Erdogan rejects U.S. calls, threatens ...