Archive for the ‘Erdogan’ Category

Erdogan Exploits Islam For Personal And Political Gain – Huffington Post

This is the third in a series of articles based in part on eyewitness accounts about the rapidly deteriorating socio-political conditions in Turkey and what the future may hold for the country. The first and second articles are available here: First, Second.

Anyone who follows Turkish President Erdogans political career cannot escape the conclusion that he has carefully and systematically crafted policies framed in Islamic clothing. He uses religion to present himself and his political agenda as if it is being sanctioned by a higher authority, surreptitiously uses Islamic symbols to indoctrinate the population with religious precepts, and promotes Islamic studies in schools in order to cultivate a new generation of devout Muslims loyal to him.

To consolidate his powers, he focused on economic development to build a strong constituency consisting of the poorer and less-educated segments of the Turkish population who support him and follow his model of political Islam. He trumpets democracy to pay lip-service to the secular sector of the population to reduce resistance to his attempt to convert Turkey into an Islamic state.

There is nothing wrong in promoting any religion in a democracy, provided there is a clear separation between church and state. In Turkey, though, Erdogan is making religion part and parcel of the states political process. In fact, as early as 1999 Erdogan went to jail for 4 months for religious incitement after he publicly read a nationalist poem including the lines: The mosques are our barracks, the domes our helmets, the minarets our bayonets and the faithful our soldiers. Erdogans notion that Turkey provides a model of Islamic democracy is an empty slogan, as it no longer resonates domestically or among any Arab or Muslim state.

The fact that Turkey has lost any prospect of becoming an EU member was entirely due to Erdogans severe and methodical undermining of the pillars on which democracy rests, including free press and speech, human rights, a fair and impartial judiciary, secular public education, and checks and balances between the three branches of government.

To promote his social-cultural Islamic agenda, Erdogan began to systematically issue directives to gradually transform Turkey into a religiously-observant society. He did so without resorting to legislation in order to avoid public resistance from the larger secular segment of the population. To that end, he began to introduce Islamic teaching and images into the public consciousness, as well as build religious institutions, to indoctrinate the population with religious precepts.

As early as 2011, Erdogan began to foster an Islamic fashion revolution. He lifted the ban on headscarves in universities, and women who work in state offices and policewomen are now able to wear headscarves, along with women who serve in the military. The once-stigmatized veil has become socially acceptable. There is a discernible rise in the number of fashionable Islamic conservative characters in soap operas, and the portrayal of women as housewives is becoming increasingly prevalent.

Moreover, the modern emblem of Turkey today shows the star outside the crescent which has become the symbol of Islam like the cross is to Christianity. The fast-growing number of mosques offers another vivid symbol of where the country is heading. During the past 30 years, the number of mosques in Turkey has grown from 60,000 to more than 85,000. The AKP uses mosques as a physical symbol of the growth of Islamic values of the state and as a political tool to consolidate its power base.

Perhaps the greatest manifestation of this is the newest, largest mosque in Turkey with six minarets, built on amlica Hill in Istanbul, which is the citys highest point reaching about 1,000 feet above sea level. The site overlooks the Bosphorus in clear view of the entire city.

In addition, alcohol cannot be sold between 10pm and 6am, and can no longer be displayed in windows and restaurants that are located near schools or mosques. Alcohol producers cannot advertise or sponsor social events. Furthermore, the government canceled a festival celebrating the national drink, raki, due to complaints from Islamists, which Erdogan more than welcomed.

In recent years, the Turkish government under Erdogans leadership took many new initiatives to push Islam deeper into the countrys secular education to cultivate a new Islamic generation. The plan included the building of 80 new mosques in public universities, and converting one university in Istanbul into a center for Islamic studies. Erdogan further supported the introduction of compulsory religious classes for all primary school children, and added an extra hour of Islamic studies for all high school students.

One of the most notable expansions of Islamic studies is found in the growth of Imam-Hatip religious schools, where since 2010 the number of schools increased by 90%, from 493 to 936, and the number of students enrolled grew from 65,000 in 2002 to nearly a million by 2016.

Batuhan Aydagl, the Director of the Education Reform Initiative at Istanbul Sabanci University, maintains that the Ministry of Education is driving the demand for these schools, not responding to it. The government is limiting the supply of non-religious schools and increasing the supply of religious onesthey are creating a situation where some students will have to go to these schools regardless of their will.

Parents and teachers are bitterly complaining that Ankara is controlling the appointment of head-teachers who enjoy substantial influence on the selection of courses. Several thousand public school teachers were replaced by Imam-Hatip trained teachers. Boys and girls are in separate classes, presumably to create an environment conducive to better leaning.

Kamuran Karaca, the president of the left-wing Egitim Sen teachers union, put it succinctly when he said: the [AK Party] is using our children for its own ideology this is a political project for creating a religious generation. They are forcing students to learn Arabic, the Quran and its interpretation in Sunni Islam.

Those who have been imbued with Imam-Hatip learning experiences claim that these schools produce people who are more virtuous, work harder, and excel in their professions. They point to the fact that Erdogan himself was a graduate of an Imam-Hatip school. In a speech to the assembly of AKP youth members in 2012, Erdogan stated that We want to raise pious generations.

Erdogan uses religion to present his political agenda as being sanctioned by a higher authority, his Islamic credentials to intimidate the opposition, and the Gulen movement as a scapegoat to promote his brand of Islamism. Fundamentally, Erdogan sees himself as a religious man, i.e. God created the circumstances for him to purge at will any of his fictitious or real political opponents, convincing himself that he is on the right and true path.

During the Ottoman reign, religion played a critical role in governing (a lesson that does not seem to be lost on Erdogan), as was observed by Baruch Spinoza, who in his Theological-Political Treatise stated that .they [the Turks] consider even controversy impious, and so clog mens minds with dogmatic formulas, that they leave no room for sound reason, not even enough to doubt with.

During the debate in the parliament to amend the constitution, Speaker of the Parliament Ismail Kahraman called for the removal of secularism from the new constitution: For one thing, the new constitution should not have secularism. It needs to discuss religion It should not be irreligious, this new constitution, it should be a religious constitution.

Although Kahramans proposals did not pass, it is clear that no such statement would have been made unless it expressed Erdogans sentiment. Essentially, it is becoming increasingly apparent that Erdogans goal is to become the ultimate leader of his country and the Islamic Sunni world. In a visit to Jakarta in July 2016, Erdogan stated that We have only one concern. It is Islam, Islam and Islam. And in recent visits to Bahrain and Saudi Arabia, he sent a message to the Sunni world to unite and put differences aside to fight violations against the Muslim world.

To become the supreme political and religious leader, Erdogan has relentlessly pushed to amend the constitution to grant him near-absolute power for which he needs popular support, and he uses religion to garner this support to promote his political agenda. In this way, he sanctifies his policies, and placed himself at the highest political and religious pedestal. As Napoleon succinctly put it, Religion is excellent stuff for keeping common people quiet.

Religion is meant to provide a moral and ethical compass to promote amity, compassion, empathy, and love, and create social harmony and peace. To be a true Muslim is to adhere to these tenets of the Quranic scripture and follow the pillars of Islam. Thus, no one should be free to exploit religion for the promotion of ones personal ambition, which, in this case, reduces the sacredness of Islam to the level of the human travails and empties it of its holistic spiritual meanings.

A man of faith does not debase the nobility of Islam to promote a personal political agenda in the name of God. A religious man does not imprison tens of thousands of civil servants and leave their families despairing and desolate. A pious man does not purge thousands of teachers without any evidence of wrongdoing. A true believer does not incarcerate scores of journalists, which stifles freedom of the press and silences dissenting voices. A devout man does not subjugate millions of fellow citizensthe Kurdsand rob them of their basic rights to experience their cultural heritage. A virtuous man does not build a White Palace for hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars while millions of Turks languish in abject poverty. A righteous man does not create a police state and use an iron fist to quell peaceful demonstrations. And finally, a spiritual man does not choke-off the spirit of others, trample on their dignity, and stamp out their pride.

Islam and democracy are not mutually exclusive as long as there is a clear separation between mosque and state. Imams have a role to play in promoting the virtues of Islam, but should have no say on the political processes of the state. For Erdogan to claim that Turkey is a democracy is hypocritical at best, not only because he usurped dictatorial powers but also because he weaved his religious doctrine into the state institutions and intimidated the civil society to join the ranks of his false piety.

Whereas Erdogan insists that Islam offers a purer way of life and creates social cohesiveness that brings prosperity and happiness, he is in fact raising social tension in Turkey by his relentless promulgation of his own brand of Islam to buttress his political agenda. The country has become increasingly polarized between the secular and the religious, which places Turkey on a dangerous path and robs it of its potential to become a true Islamic democracy.

Continued here:
Erdogan Exploits Islam For Personal And Political Gain - Huffington Post

Erdogan: Occupied Karabakh conflict cannot be ignored – Anadolu Agency

By Bahattin Gonultas

ISLAMABAD, Pakistan

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan Wednesday brought up the situation of occupied Karabakh two days after an Azerbaijani soldier was martyred in a border clash with Armenian forces.

Speaking at the Economic Cooperation Organisations (ECO) 13th summit in Islamabad, Pakistan, Erdogan said 20 years of negotiations between Azerbaijan and Armenia had not resulted in a solution to the conflict.

"We, particularly, cannot ignore the Upper Karabakh issue," Erdogan said.

Erdogan also said that the international mediation group -- the Minsk Group -- had failed to find a peaceful solution to the Karabakh conflict.OThe Minsk Group, created in 1992, leads the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE)'s efforts to find a solution to the dispute between Azerbaijan and Armenia.

The president urged ECO countries and the Organization of Islamic Cooperation to work together to find a solution to the conflict, stressing that Armenia's "occupant attitude" should be addressed at each international meeting.

"We, both as ECO and Organization of Islamic Cooperation, should pay attention [to the situation]," he said.

An Azerbaijani soldier was martyred on Monday in a border clash, the country's Defense Ministry said. On Feb. 24, five soldiers were similarly martyred.

Last week's incident nearly coincided with the 20th anniversary of the Khojaly Massacre of Feb. 25-26, 1992, in which Armenian forces killed 613 Azerbaijanis in Karabakh.

Clashes in the occupied Karabakh region, which pro-Armenian militia took over in 1993, are nothing new.

In April 2016, more than 270 military personnel lost their lives in the worst-ever breach of a 1994 treaty between the sides, according to the Azerbaijani Defense Ministry.

Armenia and Azerbaijan fought a six-year war over occupied Karabakh in the early 1980s until the 1994 cease-fire.

Three UN Security Council Resolutions (853, 874 and 884), and United Nations General Assembly Resolutions 19/13 and 57/298 refer to Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan. The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe refers to the region as being occupied by Armenian forces.

Turkey's president on Wednesday also urged the need for resolutions of political disputes between the members of ECO and called for joint efforts to tackle terrorism.

We need to take matters into our own hands," he said.

Link:
Erdogan: Occupied Karabakh conflict cannot be ignored - Anadolu Agency

Erdogan says paper to pay ‘price’ over controversial report – New Vision

Istanbul prosecutors launched an investigation into the Hurriyet front page story on Saturday which suggested that the army was not satisfied with the recent actions by the government.

President Recep Tayyip Erdogan

President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Tuesday warned that a Turkish newspaper would pay a "price" after a contentious report over alleged tensions between his government and the army.

Istanbul prosecutors launched an investigation into the Hurriyet front page story on Saturday which suggested that the army was not satisfied with the recent actions by the government.

The story listed seven grievances including the lifting of a historic ban on female officers wearing the Islamic headscarf in the officially secular country.

"Let me put it very clearly, what's done here, the headline they have used is insolent," Erdogan told reporters at an Istanbul airport before leaving for Pakistan on an official visit.

Erdogan said nobody had the right to set the army against the government and warned: "Whoever tries to set us against one another will pay a price."

"No offence but I don't find such an approach forgivable at a time when we need unity, fraternity and solidarity more than ever," he added.

Erdogan said he discussed the issue with Chief of Staff General Hulusi Akar on Monday.

The government increased control over the armed forces in the wake of an attempted coup in July last year blamed on followers of preacher Fethullah Gulen.

The Hurriyet newspaper, the flagship daily of Dogan Media Group -- the Turkish media giant which owns television channels Kanal D and CNN-Turk -- is a mainstream daily but houses pro-government columnists as well.

'Coup mongering'

The story headlined "the army headquarters are uneasy", based on military sources, carried the byline of Hurriyet's Ankara bureau chief Hande Firat.

Firat, one of Turkey's most prominent journalists, was fiercely condemned by pro-government media for "coup mongering".

Ironically, Firat played a crucial role in defeating the July 15 coup when she spoke to Erdogan live on her CNN-Turk show by FaceTime on the night of the putsch.

Erdogan used the interview to rally his supporters, calling them into the streets to resist the attempted power-grab.

An Istanbul prosecutor's office on Monday launched an investigation into whether there was a pro-coup faction within the military that was trying to block the government's actions, the state-run Anadolu news agency reported.

The army on Tuesday dismissed "baseless and intentional criticism" in the Hurriyet story, which it said was a "distortion" aimed at harming the armed forces at a time when it is fighting terror at home and in Syria.

Appearing on CNN-Turk, Firat said the critics had not read her story properly, adding that Hurriyet had sought comment from the military chief of staff.

"We, as Hurriyet newspaper and Dogan Group, will continue to defend democracy," she said.

Erdogan defended the lifting of the headscarf ban in the army and said women would enjoy their freedom.

"In the following process our victimised, oppressed sisters will take their place in all institutions" from the judiciary to the education sector, he said.

Link:
Erdogan says paper to pay 'price' over controversial report - New Vision

Merkel Risks Tension With Erdogan Over Turkish Reporter’s Arrest – Bloomberg

Chancellor Angela Merkel condemned the arrest of a German reporter in Turkey as excessively harsh, risking tension with President Reccep Tayyip Erdogan as she counts on him to stem refugee flows to Europe.

The most important business stories of the day.

Get Bloomberg's daily newsletter.

Merkels comments on the arrest of Deniz Yucel, a correspondent for German newspaper Die Welt, brings her previously muted criticism of Turkeys record on media freedom and human rights out into the open. As she runs for a fourth term as German chancellor, Merkel is under pressure to take a stand on Turkey while depending on a European Union refugee accord with Turkey thats cut the influx of asylum seekers from the Middle East.

This measure is disproportionately harsh, Merkel said of Yucels arrest in a statement issued in Berlin late Monday. Its bitter and disappointing, particularly since the reporter turned himself in to Turkish police, she said.

Yucel, 43, was detained on Feb. 14 for reporting on e-mails published by the Redhack hacking group from the account of Erdogans son-in-law Berat Albayrak,Turkeys energy minister. Authorities have now placed him under arrest on charges of spreading terrorist propaganda, Turkish media group P24 reported.

While German politicians have regularly raised concern about Erdogans crackdown following a quashed coup last year and human rights groups have pressed Merkel to raise the matter with Erdogan, the arrest of the German-Turkish citizen provoked outrage.

This doesnt lead one to expect fair proceedings governed by the rule of law, Deputy Finance Minister Jens Spahn, a member of Merkels Christian Democratic Union, said in a ZDF television interview Tuesday. We have to criticize this -- precisely because Turkey is a partner, including in NATO.

Axel Springer SE Chief Executive Office Mathias Doepfner, whose company publishes Die Welt, criticized Erdogan in a column in the newspaper headlined We are Deniz, saying the Turkish presidents practices are part of a global campaign of intimidation against intellectual freedoms. He also cited governments in Russia, China, Hungary, Poland and U.S. President Donald Trump.

Some of the e-mails cited by Yucel concerned the control of Turkish media groups and efforts to influence public opinion through fake users on Twitter Inc.s messaging platform.According to Die Welt, the e-mails have been accessible on WikiLeaks since early December. Under Turkeys state of emergency, suspects can be detained for up to 14 days without appearing before a judge.

A resurgent Social Democratic Party under Martin Schulz and a public backlash against the biggest influx of refugees since World War II are key threats to Merkels re-election. An estimated 280,000 asylum seekers entered Germany last year, compared with 890,000 in 2015. Merkels government credits the EU-Turkey accord last March, which includes as much as 6 billion euros ($6.4 billion) in European aid for Turkey, with helping slash the influx.

Read more:
Merkel Risks Tension With Erdogan Over Turkish Reporter's Arrest - Bloomberg

Erdogan Critics Beware: Turkey Is Watching – Algemeiner

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoan. Photo: Wikipedia.

For some Americans, concerns about Russian spying and interference in ourelections are growing, with new reports emerging nearly every day. But in Europe, officials are fighting off an even greater incursion from another country: Turkey.

Recent investigations and leaks in Germany, Austria and the Netherlands confirm ongoing efforts by Turkeys government to intimidate European-Turkish citizens suspected of having ties to Fethullah Gulen, President Recep Tayyip Erdogans one-time ally, whom he now blames for the failed coup against him last July.

Imams in Germany connected to the Turkish state, for instance, haveadmitted to spyingon teachers in German state-run schools. Teachers and parents have also been asked to spy on classes, andreport in any criticismof Erdogan or his government. In Austria, parliamentarian Peter Pilz has said there isa global spying network, with Turkish-Islamic groupssending reportson Gulen-tied organizations back to Ankara. Targets have included educational institutions, cultural centers and various NGOs. In the Netherlands, the Turkish consulate in Rotterdam hasrevoked the passportsof several Dutch-Turks thought to support Gulen. (Turkey maintains consular offices in several Dutch cities; to date, reports of passports being revoked are limited to the Rotterdam office.)

February 28, 2017 6:06 pm

Erdogans involvement in European affairs beyond Turkeys borders is nothing new. In 2008, while speaking at a rally in Cologne, Germany, he encouraged all European Turks toresist assimilation, which he called a crime against humanity. In 2013, heinterferedin a child abuse case against a Dutch-Turkish mother, when the child was given over to lesbian foster parents. And last year, he called on German Chancellor Angela Merkel toprosecute a German comedianwho had written a song critical of him.

But the latest efforts indicate an even greater bravado, says Elise Steilberg, a Dutch columnist who frequently writes on Turkish politics. The clearer it has become that Erdogan aims at a one-man-rule, and that in working toward his goal of constitutional change he wont hesitate to use unconventional means, the more obvious it has also become that he will do anything to get as many European Turks behind him as possible, she said in a recent email. Erdogan is now openly using all available channels to increase his influence within Europe.

The Dutch passport situation is a salient example of this effort. Both dual Dutch-Turkish citizens and Turkish citizens with residency permits have reported that their passports were confiscated at the Rotterdam office. In each case, they were said to have ties to Gulen, to Kurdish groups, or to journalists and others critical of the Turkish government.

For dual citizens, this is bad enough, but those with only Turkish citizenship are rendered stateless by such a move.Some have arguedthat this action represents a flagrant violation of United Nations conventions, but Turkey is not a signatory to those conventions.

There is, however, an option offered to those whose passports are revoked, reports Dutch newspaperTrouw, which first broke the story. To obtain a replacement, they must travelto Turkey. On arrival, they areheld in custody, effectively imprisoned, until they can plead their case in court a process that can take six months. In one particularly disturbing case described inTrouw, a Turkish woman was forced to relinquish her passport because her husband is a Gulenist. She is not.

But Ankara has not stopped at the door of its consulates. With Dutch elections set forMarch 15, Turkey isallegedly paying imamsin the Netherlands to urge Dutch-Turks to vote for the anti-integration Denk (Think) party, led by Tunahan Kuzu and Seluk Ozturk, both of whom are Turkish-born. Among Denks objectives: a culture of acceptance rather than integration, the creation of a racism register, and the formation of a racism police. Inan interviewwithElsevier,Dutch Turkish Council Director Sefa Yurukel described the vote Denk messages distributed by the imams as containing the typical arguments of Islamists. Further, he said that Denk likely enjoys support from the Diyanet, a Turkish government body that oversees religious affairs in Turkey and among the Turkish people worldwide.

It is just that sort of effort to monitor and manipulate the behavior of Turkish citizens, even those who do not live in Turkey, that has Steilberg most concerned. While of course all countries spy on one another, she says, the idea of civilians spying on civilians is especially chilling.

Already the Dutch have experienced some of the worst of this, as when Twitter users in the Netherlandsreported the anti-Erdogan tweetsof Dutch-Turkish columnist Ebru Umar. Umar, who was in Turkey at the time, was immediately arrested, and was not permitted to return to the Netherlands for several weeks. She was eventually released only thanks to the intervention of Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte.

As such government intervention becomes increasingly intertwined with religious manipulation and intrigue, the reaches of Turkeys growing theocracy into European culture seems an imminent, and ever-expanding, threat.

More:
Erdogan Critics Beware: Turkey Is Watching - Algemeiner