Robert Mounts: The scourge of misinformation playing to our fears – The Ledger
A few weeks ago, I was confronted with an extreme point of view that left me shaking in disbelief. In casual conversation with a fellow civic club member, whom I considered to be one of the kindest, most considerate and thoughtful men I knew, he disclosed his belief that America would be fully justified in barring all Muslims from our country as the United States was a Christian country.
He then repeated the often-debunked assertion that certain Muslim groups had already established Sharia law in two small communities in Michigan. He pointed to a recently reported decision by Denmark to stop accepting Muslim immigrants and send them home.
As a devout Christian myself, I countered that the United States was actually established as a secular country by law that separates church and state and protects freedom of religion, citing the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. I said that this is exactly the kind of line being put out by Trumps immigration policy advisor, Stephen Miller, and white supremacist groups.
He angrily replied, Dont preach to me. I was stunned.
My background in law and political science, as well as my years of government service, taught me that no U.S. state constitution, and no state attorney general, would ever sanction the imposition of Sharia law in one of its municipalities. It just wouldnt happen.
My friends successful background as a conservative businessman and investor apparently didnt tell him that, nor did it teach him to be skeptical of such reporting. Im not sure if he has ever read the First Amendment:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances (emphasis added).
A little internet research on Snopes.com, a well-known fact-checking source, quickly told me that according to an Aug. 8, 2018 report from The Last Line of Defense website, it was now illegal to serve pork and for women to appear in public without wearing burqas (Islamic head coverings) in the 109th congressional district of Michigan:
Following the recent decision by Michigans 109th Congressional district to adopt adherence to Sharia Law as well as traditional Wypipo Law, County Commissioner Art Tubolls took to the podium to announce further plans: A full-scale ban on bacon within the district, and compulsory wearing of a burka by all females in public.
Indeed, as expected, this news proved controversial. Dearborns 200 billion-dollar Allah Justavanosh Mosque was surrounded by protesters, and the phone lines were jammed with angry potato pancakes. County Pastor Johnathan Regarp tried to calm the crowd down.
Of course, according to Snopes, Michigan doesnt have a 109th congressional district (it has 14 congressional districts, total). Nor does it have a so-called Allah Justavanosh Mosque in Dearborn, or a county commissioner named Art Tubolls (both are obviously made-up names, the latter an anagram of the equally faux Busta Troll).
The Snopes fact-checkers say these false details reveal not only that the story is a fabrication, but also that it was generated by the same online trolling operation responsible for cranking out scores of so-called satirical articles.
This example plays on the fears of those who are convinced that Islam is a threat to Western Civilization and intent on destroying America. Dearborn, Michigan, has often (and falsely) been cited as an example of a U.S. city taken over by Muslims.
What this tells me is that my otherwise goodhearted friend had become enraged by false online reporting that played to his fears that Muslims were planning to take over the country. Normally kind, thoughtful and mild-mannered, he became uncharacteristically angry and defensive when challenged, thereby cutting off further discussion. That is unfortunate. We needed to be able to talk.
Im not sure if my friend supports Trump. However, I do know that when folks ask why Trumps supporters are so devoted to him, as Gregory McGann so thoughtfully addressed in a column published Dec. 1, this kind of misinformation provides a clue. He appeals to their prejudices and fears. President Franklin D. Roosevelt famously said the only thing we have to fear is, fear itself.
If we truly believe in the First Amendment, the equality of all people and the rule of law, we should not fear living in a multicultural society, we should embrace it.
Robert Mounts lives in Gainesville.
Read this article:
Robert Mounts: The scourge of misinformation playing to our fears - The Ledger