Facebook Needs to Be More Transparent About Why It Censors Speech – Fortune
Photograph by Chris Ratcliffe Bloomberg/Getty Images
The more Facebook tries to move beyond its original role as a social network for sharing family photos and other ephemera, the more it finds itself in an ethical minefield, torn between its desire to improve the world and its need to curb certain kinds of speech.
The tension between these two forces has never been more obvious than it is now, thanks to two recent examples of when its impulses can go wrong, and the potential damage that can be caused as a result. The first involves a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist whose account was restricted, and the second relates to Facebook's leaked moderation guidelines.
In the first case, investigative reporter Matthew Caruana Galizia had his Facebook account suspended recently after he posted documents related to a story about a politician in Malta.
Caruana Galizia was part of a team that worked with the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists to break the story of the Panama Papers, a massive dump of documents that were leaked from an offshore law firm last year.
The politician, Maltese prime minister Joseph Muscat, was implicated in a scandal as a result of those leaked documents, which referred to shell companies set up by him and two other senior politicians in his administration.
Get Data Sheet , Fortune s technology newsletter.
Facebook not only suspended Caruana Galizia's account, it also removed a number of the documents that he had posted related to the story. It later restored his access to his account after The Guardian and a Maltese news outlet wrote about it, but some of the documents never reappeared.
The social network has rules that are designed to prevent people from posting personal information about other users, but it's not clear whether that's why the account was suspended.
Some of what Caruana Galizia posted contained screenshots of passports and other personal data, but many of these documents have remained available, while others have been removed. He is being sued by Muscat for libel, which has raised concerns about whether Facebook suspended the account because of pressure from officials in Malta.
A spokesman for Facebook told the Guardian that it was working with the reporter "so that he can publish what he needs to, without including unnecessary private details that could present safety risks. If we find that we have made errors, we will correct them."
Caruana Galizia said the incident was enlightening "because I realized how crippling and punitive this block is for a journalist." And they clearly reinforce the risks that journalists and media entities take when they decide to use the social network as a distribution outlet.
If nothing else, these and other similar incidents make it obvious that Facebook needs to do far more when it comes to being transparent about when and why it removes content, especially when that content is of a journalistic nature.
In an unrelated incident, the world got a glimpse into how the social network makes some of its content decisions thanks to a leaked collection of guidelines and manuals for the 4,500 or so moderators it employs, which was posted by the Guardian .
Outlined in the documents are rules about what kinds of statements are considered too offensive to allow, how much violence the site allows in videos including Facebook Live, which has been the subject of significant controversy recentlyand what to do with sexually suggestive imagery.
Much like Twitter, Facebook appears to be trying to find a line between getting rid of offensive behavior while still leaving room for freedom of expression.
In the process, however, it has raised questions about why the giant social network makes some of the choices it does. Statements within the guidelines about violence towards women, for examplesuch as "To snap a bitchs neck, make sure to apply all your pressure to the middle of her throat"are considered okay because they are not specific threats.
Facebook has already come under fire for some of its decisions around what to show on its live-streaming feature. There have been several cases in which people committed suicide and streamed it on Facebook Live, and in at least one case a man killed his child and then himself .
The guidelines say that while videos of violence and even death should be marked as disturbing, in many cases they do not have to be deleted because they can "help create awareness of issues such as mental illness," and because Facebook doesn't want to "censor or punish people in distress."
As a private corporation, Facebook is entitled to make whatever rules it wants about the type of speech that is permitted on its platform because the First Amendment only applies to the actions of governments. But when a single company plays such a huge role in the online behavior of more than a billion people, it's worth asking questions about the impact its rules have.
If Facebook censors certain kinds of speech, then for tens of millions of people it effectively ceases to exist, or becomes significantly less obvious.
The risks of this kind of private control over speech are obvious when it comes to things like filter bubbles or the role that "fake news" plays in political movements. But there's a deeper risk as well, which is that thanks to the inscrutability of Facebook's algorithm, many people won't know what they are missing when information is removed.
Facebook may not want to admit that it is a media entity, but the reality is that it plays a huge role in how billions of people see the world around them. And part of the responsibility that comes with that kind of role is being more transparent about why and how you make decisions about what information people shouldn't be able to see.
Read more from the original source:
Facebook Needs to Be More Transparent About Why It Censors Speech - Fortune
- DeepSeek is giving the world a window into Chinese censorship and information control - CNN International - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Executive Order to the State Department Sideswipes Freedom Tools, Threatens Censorship Resistance, Privacy, and Anonymity of Millions - EFF - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- ADF presses five major universities for records on government censorship - ADF Media - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Why We Should Fear Trump Silencing Science and What We Can Do About It - U.S. News & World Report - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Researchers are terrified of Trumps freeze on science. The rest of us should be, too. - Vox.com - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Conservative law firm launches probe into five major universities for alleged 'censorship regime' - Fox News - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Some of the most ingenious ways people are bypassing DeepSeeks censorship: Using emojis might work - AS USA - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Comment | Censorship in the US is rearing its ugly head againbut the art world isn't taking it lying down - Art Newspaper - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Seizure of Sally Mann photographs in Texas revives old debates about obscenity, free expression - Free Speech Center - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Chinese films dodging censors have no place to go. Can they crack into Taiwan? - Los Angeles Times - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Meta back in the tent after agreeing to settle Trumps $25M censorship lawsuit - SiliconANGLE News - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- We tried out DeepSeek. It worked well, until we asked it about Tiananmen Square and Taiwan - The Guardian - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Library Director Rachel Winner speaks on the role of libraries, Censorship. - Sullivan Daily Times - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- Day 3: USC Conference on Censorship in the Sciences - Why Evolution Is True - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- DeepSeek Starts to Explain Tiananmen Square Massacre, Then Gets Caught by Built-In Censorship System - Futurism - February 1st, 2025 [February 1st, 2025]
- A White House order claims to end 'censorship.' What does that mean? - NPR - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- DeepSeek is the hottest new AI chatbotbut it comes with Chinese censorship built in - Fortune - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Opinion | Conservatives Have No Interest in Censorship - The Wall Street Journal - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Donald Trump and Elon Musk appear in Ben & Jerry's censorship lawsuit against Unilever, its parent company. Here's why. - Business Insider - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Disinformation experts blast Trumps executive order on government censorship as direct assault on reality - CNN - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Ben & Jerry's is accusing its parent company of censorship because it allegedly blocked a post that mentioned Donald Trump - Fortune - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- 'This is censorship': Trump freeze on communications forces medical journal to pull HHS authors' article - STAT - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Analysis | Trumps anti-censorship order has a blind spot - The Washington Post - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- The TikTok Ban: Foreign Influence Through Censorship, Propaganda, and Espionage - Independent Women's Forum - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- DeepSeek: This is what live censorship looks like in the Chinese AI chatbot - Trending Topics SEE - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Why President Donald Trump signed an executive order banning government 'censorship' - USA TODAY - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Government Officials Who Engaged In Censorship Must Be Held Accountable - The Daily Wire - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Statement from the Kids Right to Read Project on the U.S. Department of Educations Dismissal of Book Bans as a "Hoax" - Blogging Censorship - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- JD Vance says big tech firms still very much on notice for censoring conservatives: Face the consequences - New York Post - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Trump talks free speech while moving to muzzle those he disagrees with - Los Angeles Times - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Trump targets government censorship with new executive order - WXLV - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- What's behind a White House order ending 'federal censorship' - KUOW News and Information - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Trump Takes Aim at Social Media 'Censorship' With Executive Order - CNET - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- EU doubles down on social media censorship that will not be confined to Europe following concerns about Musks free speech policy on X - ADF... - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Is TikTok Turning Into a Censorship Machine? Users Witness New Restrictions After Trump's Order - Benzinga - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- FIRE to University of Texas at Dallas: Stop censoring the student press - Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Students concerned over censorship, career instability in wake of TikTok ban - Daily Free Press - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- TikTok Users Now On RedNote Are Starting To See One Very Big Problem With the App - Mic - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Tweeting the truth: Should social media companies have the right to censor content? - berkeleyhighjacket.com - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Kiehl's won't beat around the bush following ad censorship - Marketing Interactive - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- Press freedom in Turkey declined further in 2024 amid censorship, arrests and intimidation: report - Stockholm Center for Freedom - January 27th, 2025 [January 27th, 2025]
- America Is No Longer the Home of the Free Internet - The Atlantic - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Call for censorship culture to end as Unity Mitfords German diary is revealed - The Guardian - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Banning TikTok enables online censorship - Freedom of the Press Foundation - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Zuckerbergs conservative pivot fogs our understanding of censorship - Kansas Reflector - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- The TikTok ban isnt about national security its censorship and government control - The Hill - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- How the Trump administration threatens internet freedoms - Al Jazeera English - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Censorship or common sense? - Editor And Publisher Magazine - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- TikTok refugees flock to another (heavily censored) Chinese app - The Washington Post - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Bill Burr on Adapting His Ahole Vibe, Wanting a Hostile Crowd for New Hulu Special and How a Rabbi Changed His Perspective on Censorship (EXCLUSIVE) -... - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- In Russia, Reading Can Be Harmful To Your Health - Air Mail - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- The Media Is Giving Away Its Rights Even Before Trump Tries to Take Them - The Nation - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- How Trumps Return Is Pushing the Media to Self-Censor - Mother Jones - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- From Russia to the EU: The high stakes of Metas content moderation shift - Global Voices - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Meta is getting rid of fact checkers. Zuckerberg acknowledged more harmful content will appear on the platforms now - CNN International - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Mark Zuckerbergs excuse for ending fact-checking program is a hoax, say experts: It is a lie that we are censors - EL PAS USA - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Legislative Efforts Heat Up on Book, Curricular Censorship Attempts | Censorship News - School Library Journal - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Ok, Zuck: So You Say You're Going To Stop Censoring Conservatives; Call Me Skeptical | Tomi Lahren - Outkick - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Meta follows Musks lead on censorship but ad industry keeps its distance from panic - Digiday - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- How games might be the key to avoiding digital censorship - EurekAlert - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- The tyranny of woke censorship is finally over and its all thanks to Donald Trump - The Telegraph - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- If Supreme Court upholds TikTok ban, U.S. will see first-of-its-kind act of censorship | Opinion - Sacramento Bee - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Disney under pressure from conservative shareholders to disavow ad censorship - Washington Times - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Meta is Getting Rid of Fact-Checkers to Reduce Censorship on Facebook and Instagram - PetaPixel - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Mark Zuckerberg's Meta is moving moderators from California to Texas to combat concerns about bias and censorship - Business Insider - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Zuckerberg says Facebook will stop censoring and allow more political free speech: X effect - Must Read Alaska - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Students in every country have the right to free speech! Oppose the censorship of the Sri Lankan IYSSE! - WSWS - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Is the end of the Big Tech industrial censorship upon us? - The Spectator World - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Dont let Facebook off the hook for its pro-censorship past so easily - New York Post - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Mark Zuckerberg rolls back Meta censorship ahead of Donald Trump's return to White House - Washington Times - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Grounds of Getty Museum in LA Catch Fire, The Washington Posts Cartoonist Quits Over Censorship: Morning Links for January 8, 2025 - ARTnews - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Is this the end of the Big Tech censorship industrial complex? - The Spectator - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Comedian ended her 'Stockholm Syndrome' with the left, says it's become 'party of censorship' - Fox8tv - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Facebook Reverses Course On Censorship, Plus Is The Left Driven By Empathy Or Hate? with Dr. Gad Saad | Will Cain Show - Fox News - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Combating The Rising Threat Of Censorship In 2025 - The Daily Wire - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- Social Media Companies Face Global Tug-of-War Over Free Speech - The New York Times - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- Elon Musk accused of censoring right-wing X accounts who disagree with him on immigration - Sky News - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- Conservatives continue to accuse Musk of censorship amid row over immigration - Anadolu Agency | English - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- Conservatives Score Major Victory Against D.C. Censorship Cartel - AMAC Official Website - Join and Explore the Benefits - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- Deepseek's V3 is the latest example of state-controlled censorship in Chinese LLMs - THE DECODER - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]