Jason Aldean controversy: Free speech and censorship collide – Southwest Virginia Today
The music video for Jason Aldeans song Try That in a Small Town stirred controversy in July with the First Amendment at the center of a debate about censorship and free speech.
As the controversy grew, the country music channel CMT announced it would no longer show the music video.
Supporters claimed Aldean was being canceled, and his First Amendment rights were violated. Detractors insinuated that the songs lyrics dont merit First Amendment protection, and some have even petitioned the government to step in to censor Aldean.
A First Amendment analysis of the Jason Aldean controversy
Lets look at the song and some of these claims through a First Amendment lens using a traffic signal framework:
Green light: These words or actions are protected by the First Amendment.
Yellow light: Caution! The First Amendment might not apply.
Red light: No First Amendment protection.
Are Aldeans song and music video free speech?
The songs lyrics compare responses to crime in big cities and small towns. The music video uses footage of carjackings, armed robbery and protests. The footage is interspersed with clips of Aldean singing in front of a Tennessee courthouse where an 18-year-old Black man named Henry Choate was lynched in 1927 and a race riot occurred in 1946.
The songs lyrics, which some say imply violence, plus the image of Aldean singing at a setting of racial violence have some arguing that the song is not protected by the First Amendment.
Green light: Music is protected as free speech. Only 54% of Americans in Freedom Forums 2023 The First Amendment: Where America Stands survey knew this, but 88% agreed music should be protected from government censorship.
Many have claimed that the song is hateful. But, as 6 in 10 survey respondents knew and agreed, hate speech is protected by the First Amendment, unless some other exception applies. None apply here. The lyrics and video lack the necessary immediacy to be incitement to imminent lawless violence, which is not protected by the First Amendment. They are not face-to-face and so cannot be fighting words. And they do not single out any individual as required for a true threat to exist.
Are the actions in the song free speech protected by the First Amendment?
In the song, Aldean refers to actions that would generate a response in a small town, including cuss out a cop, spit in his face, stomp on the flag and light it up.
Yellow light: The First Amendment means we can stand up to authority and arent required to choose our words carefully when we do so. But some of the clips in the music video show protesters shouting right in the faces of police officers, which could be fighting words, a category of speech not protected by the First Amendment. These words are intended not to convey a message but rather to provoke a violent response. And this could also lead to obstruction of justice charges if you impeded an officers job.
Red light: Any physical contact with a police officer is no longer expression. This is likely criminal assault.
STOMP ON THE FLAG AND LIGHT IT UP
Green light: Flag desecration, including stepping on the flag and burning it, is protected by the First Amendment. The Supreme Court has said flag burning is symbolic speech and in many cases is protected as free speech.
Can TV and radio censor the song or venues cancel Aldean shows?
CMT stopped airing the Try That in a Small Town video. Some radio stations arent playing the song. People are calling for boycotts of Aldeans concerts and asking venues to cancel his shows.
Green light: CMT, radio stations and concert venues are all private businesses. The First Amendment doesnt apply here something that three-quarters of Americans dont know. Private businesses can set their own rules about what messages they support and promote. The First Amendment only protects us against government actions that infringe on our rights to religion, speech, press, assembly and petition.
Can people challenge Aldeans controversial statements?
The Jason Aldean controversy largely began after the music video was released, and people added context to Aldeans claims that there isnt a single video clip that isnt real news footage.
Major media outlets and citizen journalists added historical context regarding the courthouse and the video footage, some from protests outside the U.S., which provide context to Aldeans claims.
Green light: The work of professional and citizen journalists is freedom of the press protected by the First Amendment. Statements about a celebrity like Aldean get very strong protection under the First Amendment. Americans have the right to hold public officials and public figures accountable.
Is criticizing Aldean or canceling him free speech?
Aldeans defense of the song has thousands of reactions. Gun control activists and other musicians have called him out. Conservative commentators and a former president of the United States have defended him.
Aldean responded to criticism and accusations of being anti-Black Lives Matter, pro-lynching and insensitive to the impact of gun violence. He described the song as one that refers to the feeling of a community that I had growing up, where we took care of our neighbors, regardless of differences of background or belief.
Green light: Aldean says that he is a victim of cancel culture. Thats a hard term to define. Sometimes what is deemed cancel culture is just people using their own free speech. Often, exercising your freedom of speech has consequences. People contacting government officials are exercising their freedom of petition. And, of course, sometimes their criticism backfires, like when the song in question rises to no. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 charts despite or more likely because of the controversy.
Can government officials use their power to punish Aldean?
Politicians have also weighed in. For instance, Justin Jones, who was expelled from and then reinstated to the Tennessee House of Representatives for leading a protest on the House floor, described the song as a lynching anthem and said we have an obligation to condemn Jason Aldeans heinous song calling for racist violence.
Yellow/red light: Government officials like Jones have First Amendment rights, too, especially when speaking outside their official duties. They have every right to express their opinions.
But they cross a line when they use their position and power to punish. It would violate the First Amendment to condemn Aldean in an official resolution that carried some penalty. And if any lawmakers tried to pressure stations or venues to stop playing or hosting Aldean, this would infringe his First Amendment rights by punishing him based on the content of his song.
The Jason Aldean controversy unpacked
The Jason Aldean controversy isnt the first debate about music, censorship and free speech. Such controversies cut across political divides and span musical genres. History is full of examples of controversial rock, punk, heavy metal and, particularly in recent years, rap and hip hop songs.
This is why it is so important that we all protect the free expression rights not only of those who write and perform songs but also of those who criticize and defend those artists.
Kevin Goldberg is First Amendment specialist for the Freedom Forum. He can be reached at kgoldberg@freedomforum.org.
Get local news delivered to your inbox!
More here:
Jason Aldean controversy: Free speech and censorship collide - Southwest Virginia Today
- Russia has also declared war on literature. Look at whats happening and be warned | Anna Aslanyan - The Guardian - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- South Park's Trey Parker and Matt Stone Stopped Comedy Central from Censoring Trump's Genitals - Consequence of Sound - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Visa and Mastercard are getting overwhelmed by gamer fury over censorship - Polygon - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Mastercard and Visa face backlash after hundreds of adult games removed from online stores Steam and Itch.io - The Guardian - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Renowned Contemporary Artist Amy Sherald Cancels Major Exhibition at the Smithsonian, Citing Censorship - bet.com - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Op-Ed | This Is What Censorship Looks Like In A National Park - National Parks Traveler - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Trust and safety workers on why they're not speaking out - Platformer - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- From Big Brother to Brave New Algorithm: The Rise of Sovereign AI and the New Age of Censorship - Modern Diplomacy - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Letter to the Editor: Who in America isn't letting them live in peace? - Amarillo Globe-News - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- The Art World Confronts a New Era of Censorship in the U.S. - observer.com - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Citing censorship concerns, Georgia-born artist cancels show at Smithsonian - AJC.com - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Artist to withdraw exhibit from National Portrait Gallery over censorship concerns - Politico - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Columbia genocide scholar may quit school over censorship on Israel, antisemitism - The Times of Israel - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Amy Sherald cancels Smithsonian exhibition over censorship - ArtReview - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Amy Sherald Called Off Her Smithsonian Show Over Censorship - The Cut - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Amy Sherald cancels Smithsonian art show over censorship of trans-themed painting - TheGrio - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- The week in free expression: 19 25 July 2025 - Index on Censorship - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Trump's order to block 'woke' AI in government encourages tech giants to censor their chatbots - AP News - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Amy Sherald Cancels Major Smithsonian Show Over Censorship Concerns - hypebeast.com - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Michelle Obama Artist Pulls Show Over Trump Censorship Threats - The Daily Beast - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Columbus native Amy Sherald cancels art show, citing culture of censorship - Columbus Ledger-Enquirer - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Harvard Journal Abruptly Cancels Issue on Palestine, Sparking Accusations of Censorship - The Harvard Crimson - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- A Refuge From Censorship: Why Independent Bookstores Will Save Us - Literary Hub - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Freelancing to fill information gaps left by global censorship - Freedom of the Press Foundation - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Russian lawmakers pass a bill punishing online searches for information deemed to be 'extremist' - AP News - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Amy Sherald Withdraws Exhibition From Smithsonian Amid Concerns Over Censorship - BroadwayWorld.com - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- AG Bontas Censorship of Pro-Life Speech Challenged in the 9th Circuit - Thomas More Society - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Itch Has Now Been Censored By Payment Processors Too We're Slipping Down The Censorship Slope - TheGamer - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Efforts to restrict or protect libraries both grew this year - Stateline - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- After The Party Free Speech At San Diego Comic-Con With The CBLDF - Bleeding Cool News - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- A Century After the Scopes Trial, Censoring Spirit on Evolution Still Thrives - Evolution News - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- New Lollipop Chainsaw game and anime adaptation in the works. Publisher promises lots of dark humor and no censorship - AUTOMATON - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- News in India is being erased from the internet - Index on Censorship - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Turkish police arrested magazine staff over Muhammad cartoon, but it doesnt actually depict the prophet - FIRE | Foundation for Individual Rights and... - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Are You Laughing Yet? - The Atlantic - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- In Letter, Artists and Scholars Call for Reinstatement of Whitney ISP Leader Ousted Amid Censorship Controversy - ARTnews.com - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Yoko Taro Tried to Warn Us About Payment Processors' Censorship in 2024 - 80 Level - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Summer 2025 Teen Advocacy Institute: Power to the Readers - National Coalition Against Censorship - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Crying Censorship, US Pressures Foreign Officials in Bid to Counter Tech Regulations - Tech Policy Press - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Some Implications of Censorship of Equality and Equity in Policy and Public Administration Courses - PA TIMES Online - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Political turmoil and military tensions see 24 internet restrictions imposed so far in 2025 - Tom's Guide - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Australian anti-porn group claims responsibility for Steam's new censorship rules in victory against 'porn sick brain rotted pedo gamer fetishists',... - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Why is self-censoring tape appearing all over Tokyos host club ads?Photos - SoraNews24 - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Steam Users Rally Behind Anti-Censorship Petition - OpenCritic - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Stephen Colbert and I: The Tightening of Right-Wing Censorship - Informed Comment - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Artists speak out on attempted censorship of views on Gaza - Music Ally - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Raging Trump Desperately Tried to Censor Epstein Expos - Yahoo Home - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Steams Adult Games Under Threat in Financial Censorship Move That Cuts The Smut - Insider Gaming - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Turkey becomes the First to Censor Musks AI Chatbot Grok - Informed Comment - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Russia's new censorship push - Kremlin eyes control over WhatsApp and Telegram - RBC-Ukraine - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Revealed: The secret code words being used to beat online censorship - The Telegraph - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- New Russian law criminalizes online searches for controversial content - The Washington Post - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Censoring All Men Are Created Equal cost U. Oregon $724K will other universities learn? - The College Fix - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Pixar Censorship Report Addressed By Director Of Studios Next Movie: The Movie Will Morph With Or Without You - Screen Rant - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Advertising Standards Authority Bans Viva!s Dairy is Scary Ad, Sparking Controversy Over Censorship - vegconomist - the vegan business magazine - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- This VTuber Just Raised Over $780 for the ACLU. After Steam's New Content Policies? Her Anti-Censorship Message Is Urgent - VICE - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Desperate Royals Tried to Censor Leaked Kings Funeral Plans - The Daily Beast - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Ready or Not Shows Signs of Recovery After Censorship Controversy - Game Rant - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- When Superman takes a side: Gaza, censorship, and the criminalisation of empathy in America - India Today - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Northeastern research breaches The Great Firewall to look at Chinese censorship - Northeastern Global News - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Ready Or Not Modder Retcons 'Censorship' Changes Within An Hour Of New Patch Going Live - IGN Southeast Asia - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Foreign journalists in the U.S. are self-censoring to protect themselves from the Trump administration - Poynter - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Turkey becomes the first to censor AI chatbot Grok - Global Voices - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- How Iran and Israel control information - Index on Censorship - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- "I've Been Dying To Play This Game For Years": With Ready Or Not Launching On Console Tomorrow, It Looks Like The Censorship Has Already... - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Spotify could pull out of Trkiye in row over censorship pressure - Music Ally - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Indian film board criticised for cutting overly sensual Superman kisses - The Guardian - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Superman's Big Kiss Was Cut By The Censors In India - Kotaku - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Russia and Belarus unveil censored 'patriotic AI' to rival the West - Ynetnews - July 14th, 2025 [July 14th, 2025]
- I Would Quit Before They Made Me Do That | Feedback - School Library Journal - July 14th, 2025 [July 14th, 2025]
- Reporter's Notebook - July 13th, 2025: An MCTS financial fiasco, Milwaukee arts winners and losers, book censorship in Wisconsin prisons - WTMJ - July 14th, 2025 [July 14th, 2025]
- Internet fumes at censorship of kissing scene in James Gunns Superman: They don't have a problem with Housefull 5 | Bollywood - Hindustan Times -... - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Listen to the Trump-Referencing Clipse Track Universal Music Allegedly Tried to Censor - Mother Jones - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- The EUs Censorship Codes Are Coming for the First Amendment - National Review - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Guest column | Book bans dont work. As a kid, I proved it. - The Washington Post - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Ira Wells, who literally wrote the book on book bans, shares his thoughts on the politics of censorship - The Globe and Mail - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Fans SLAM censorship of 33-second kissing scene in James Gunns Superman: 'They don't have a problem with - Times of India - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- After the Bombings, Iran Tightened Its Censorship. Iranians Arent Standing For It. - Council on Foreign Relations - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- All that glitters is not gold: A brief history of efforts to rebrand social media censorship - FIRE | Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Zelensky, Zuckerberg, prolifers, a trans journalist, and a gay person with a Bible. How Russia is censoring the Axios/HBO documentary - Mediazona - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]