Twitter ‘Blue’: Sex workers, censorship and the fight for online visibility – Index on Censorship
In the past couple years, Ive gotten kicked off of PayPal and Venmo, sex worker Maya Morena told me. Ive gotten kicked off Twitter. I had 80,000 followers on Twitter; I had 30,000 followers on Instagram, I had 30,000 on Tumblr. I lost all those platforms.
Morenas experience isnt unusual, though it also isnt well known. When the right talks about censorship, it focuses obsessively on liberals protesting conservative speakers. When the left focuses on censorship, it points to the efforts by red states to criminalise the teaching ofLGBTandBlackstudies. The longstanding, and worsening, policing and censorship of sex workers online is seen by all as either justifiable or unimportant. It is neither though; the censorship of sex workers affects their livelihood, their ability to advocate for themselves, and puts their safety and their very lives at risk.
Thats why when Twitter started promising that Twitter Blue would boost visibility and engagement on the platform, many sex workers signed up. The service hasnt really solved sex workers problems. But the hopes around it, and the backlash to it, demonstrate just how isolated sex workers are, and how much they need solidarity from those who care about free speech.
A Sustained Assault on Sex Worker Speech
Government, gatekeepers and the public have long been very uncomfortable with sexual speech, going all the way back to laws thatcriminalisedthe shipping of sexual material through the mail in the late 1800s.
The early internet gave sex workers the ability to advertise directly to clients and to be visible online in ways that had been previously unimaginable. Sites likeBackpage and Craigslistallowed people to promote erotic services and, importantly, allowed them to vet clients. Homicides of sex workerscrateredin cities where Craigslist opened erotic services websites as sex workers were able to get off the streets and out of danger.
Despite clear evidence that free speech made sex workers safer, policy makers and anti-sex advocates insisted, with little to back them up, that adult services on the internet contributed to trafficking.
The watershed moment for sexual censorship, according to Olivia Snow, a dominatrix and a research fellow at theUCLA Center for Critical Internet Inquiry, came in 2018, with the bipartisan passage of FOSTA/SESTA. These laws made platforms legally responsible for user-generated sexual content. That gave many platforms an incentive, or an excuse, to purge sex workers.
Backpage wasshut downby the government in 2018; Tumblrpurgedmost NSFW content the same year. So didPatreon. Payment processors and banks have beenescalatingalongstanding waron sex workers, preventing them from accessing funds or doing business. Even OnlyFans, which has built its business almost entirely on sex workers, decided to get rid of sexual content, though itreversedits decision after a backlash from creators.
As sex workers have been shut out of most sites, Twitter has become more and more important to the community. Twitter is the only major social media platform that tolerates us, Snow said. It is by default the least shitty of the platforms.
Twitter Is WelcomingBut Not That Welcoming
Arecent studyfound that 97% of sex workers rely on Twitter as their top site for finding followers. Writer and sex workerJessie Sageexplained that while she has accounts on sex worker sites like Eros and Tryst, the people who book me tend to do so because they find me and then they go look at my socials. Clients use twitter to verify that sex workers are who they say they are, and to see if they have shared interests. And, Sage says, Twitter allows sex workers to share information. Being able to connect with other sex workers allows us to create pathways and resources and screening resources for each other that keep us safe.
Sage also says Twitter is vital because it lets sex workers show that theyre not just sex workers. Most of my Twitters just talking about books I like to read and things that Im thinking about, she told me. But theres something very political about that, because Im saying that I am a sex worker, and Im also all of these other things. And when we get shoved off of social media, we lose that and we become dehumanised. And when we become dehumanised, our existence becomes much more ripe for abuse.
While Twitter is somewhat welcoming to sex workers though, its notthatwelcoming. Sex worker accounts are often deprioritized by the algorithm (a process sometimes referred to asshadowbanning). Deprioritisation can mean that accounts dont show up in search results or that they dont show up in followers feeds. That makes it hard to build an audience. It can also make it easy for bad actors to impersonate sex workers and catfish clients. Fake accounts on Twitter are able to get more followers than me, because Im already censored, Morena told me. Its a big problem for all sex workers.
Twitter Blueto the Rescue, Sort Of
In December, new Twitter owner Elon Muskclaimedthat for $8/month, Twitter Blue users would begin to be prioritised in search and in conversations on Twitter.Many sex workershoped Twitter Blue would give them more visibility.
Sex worker Andres Stones says that in his experience post-Musk Twitter has strangled his engagement and has had a very large and negative impact on his business. Its not clear whether this is because Musk is more aggressive in restricting adult content, or whether the new Twitter simply throttles engagement for everyone who isnt on Twitter Blue. Either way, Stones says, I started subscribing [to Twitter Blue] out of necessity. It hasnt gotten him back to where he was before, but its at least slowed the slide. Its been helpful only insofar as not having it was a death knell for engagement.
Other sex workers report similar experiences. Morena says it hasnt been that helpful, though its given her content an extra push. Sage struggled because Twitter Blue didnt allow her to change her screen name easily, which made it difficult for her to advertise her travel dates.
Block the Blue
Sex workers saw Twitter Blue as a possible way to navigate censorship and deprioritisation on the one important social media platform that warily tolerates their existence. But in the broader cultural conversation, Twitter Blue was portrayed as a service solely for Elon Musk superfans and fascist trolls.
Mashablereported ona Block the Blue campaign, which encouraged Twitter users to adopt a Blocklist targeting all Twitter Blue accounts. It was embraced by NBC News reporter Ben Collins, Alejandra Caballo of the Harvard Law Cyberlaw Clinic andotherlargeprogressive accounts. Twitter comedian and celebrity @dril told Binder, 99% of twitter blue guys are dead-eyed cretins who are usually trying to sell you something stupid and expensive. Blocking them, @dril suggested, was funny and a way to undermine Musks right wing political agenda.
But a small study byTechCrunchfound that the vast majority of Twitter Blue accounts were not right wing harassment accounts. Instead, people used the service because they wanted features like the ability to post longer videos, or two-factor authenticationor because they were, like sex workers, businesspeople trying to boost engagement.
Ashley, a sex worker and researcher of online platform behavior who did her own study of Twitter Blue users, told me that the Block the Blue list is frustratingly counterproductive. The best way to block hateful trolls, she argued, is to block the followers of large right-wing troll accounts.
Im all in favour of users being empowered to block people, she says, but combined with the fact that so many sex workers are using this, [Block the Blue] is really just sharing a sex worker block list. Because theres way more sex workers than hateful people on there.
No Voice
Ashley adds that the majority of Twitter Blue users are probably just random people experimenting with the service. The point though is that sex workers are using the service at high rates, but have had little success in getting their interests, or existence, recognised by progressives who are supposedly fighting for marginalised people. Matt Binder, who wrote the Mashable article about Block the Blue, told me he doesnt believe that sex worker concerns did much to interrupt or slow the Block the Blue campaign which has become somewhat of a meme on the platform, he said. (He added that he thinks more people block individual users than use the block list, and doesnt think theres been much friendly fire.)
Musk and the right are no friends to sex workers; as Snow told me, the right-wing neo-fash, neo-Satanic Panic targeting LGBT people is built on terror and hatred of anything associated with sexuality, which includes sex workers (many of whom are LGBT themselves.) But progressive leaders often dont feel accountable to sex workers either, and mostly ignore sex workers when they say (for example) that blocking everyone using Twitter Blue will further isolate them.
Twitter Blue isnt a solution. But its a reminder that sex workers face extreme and debilitating censorship. More people need to listen to them.
See more here:
Twitter 'Blue': Sex workers, censorship and the fight for online visibility - Index on Censorship
- Censorship accusations loom over Big Tech hearing on election threats - The Verge - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Brooklyn Public Library leads charge against book censorship with events and national day of action - Brooklyn Paper - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Ending Censorship, Forever Wars, and Chronic Disease: A Transcript of Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.s August 23, 2024 Speech Endorsing Former President Donald... - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Examining whether a U.S. ban on TikTok would be censorship - KUOW News and Information - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Banned book give-away planned in central Iowa this weekend - Radio Iowa - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Censorship everywhere in America - Elon Musk - News.Az - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Lifeline, Cash-Grab, Tool for Censorship: Three Incarcerated Readers on eBooks in Prison - Literary Hub - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- TVUSD Board Presiding Officer Wiersma fights censorship from board members and staff over parental rights policy - Valley News - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Who holds the pen on scrutinising the most powerful? - Index on Censorship - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Swedish Professor: Disinformation Label Used To Limit Free Speech - The European Conservative - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- This Technology Was Supposed to Help People in Prison. Its Backfiring in a Big Way. - Slate - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- New data reveals exactly when the Chinese government blocked ChatGPT and other AI sites - Rest of World - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Hillary Clinton, queen of disinformation, issues two-faced call for censorship - New York Post - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Black authors speak ahead of Banned Book Week - Afro American Newspaper - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- American Library Association to Host Historic Intellectual Freedom Summit at the Library of Congress - ala.org - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Why Im So Desperate for the Return of Microsoft Word to Our Prison Library - Slate - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Iranian filmmakers pull it out of the bag - Index on Censorship - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Opinion | Bureaucrat Who Threatened To Censor X Announces Resignation on X - The Wall Street Journal - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- RFK Jr., Tulsi Gabbard blast Dems as 'warmongers,' 'party of censorship' while stumping for Trump in Arizona - New York Post - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Queens, Brooklyn and New York Public Libraries To Mark Banned Books Week September 22 to 28 with Talks, Exhibitions and More - City Life Org - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- With A Spiking Crisis of School Book Bans, PEN America Draws Writers, Readers and Advocates Together to Champion the Freedom to Read; Events in Cities... - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Private Wires These companies are profiting off of censoring speech online - Big Brother Watch - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Government censorship is a greater threat than disinformation - New York Post - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- EXCLUSIVE America First Legal Obtains New Internal CDC Documents Revealing Foreign Collusion in Biden-Harris Government Censorship Regime - America... - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- We Called on the Oversight Board to Stop Censoring From the River to the Sea And They Listened - EFF - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Russia Invests $660 Million to Boost Internet Censorship and Block VPNs - CircleID - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- NCLA Suit Demands End to Govt Censorship of Support Groups for Victims of Covid Vaccine Injuries - GlobeNewswire - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Banned Books Week educates about threat of censorship - Mid Florida Newspapers - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Media in Exile is Defeating Censorship in Cuba, Nicaragua, and Venezuela - Confidencial - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- EXCLUSIVE: Open letter to Brazilian Congress demands an ended to censorship amid ongoing X ban - AOL - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- 'We wanted 13PG': Zapiro shares the story behind the censorship battle of 'The Showerhead' - News24 - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Russia is willing to spend some $660 million to bolster internet censorship - TechSpot - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- EXCLUSIVE: Open letter to Brazilian Congress demands an end to censorship amid ongoing X ban - Fox News - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- Tracie D. Hall, the librarian speaking out against censorship and book bans that threaten learning and access to information - University of... - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- Biden administration and Kamala Harris increase funding for digital censorship - Zenit.org - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- Stand with the Banned Read-Out Promotes Awareness of Censorship - Town Topics - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- America First Legal Launches Investigation into the Biden-Harris Administrations Knowledge of Social Media Censorship by Brazils Leftist Government -... - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- The White House calls on Amazon and Google to help defeat online censors in these countries - Fast Company - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- Up Late With The Apprentice Director Ali Abbasi: Censorship, Toothless Hollywood and Donald Trump | Exclusive - TheWrap - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- Trump Proposes Anti-Censorship Order, Change to 25th Amendment at Wisconsin Rally - NTD - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- Original Cowboy Bebop Gets One-of-a-Kind Inquiry Into '90s Network Censorship & More in New Release - CBR - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- Key Takeaways from Zuckerbergs Tell-All - Daily Citizen - September 12th, 2024 [September 12th, 2024]
- Media Pretend That Systematic Government Censorship Is a Nothingburger - National Review - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Jack Dorsey Backs Bitcoin And Nostr To Cut Censorship With Free Speech - Forbes - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Half-Breed and Brown Sugar Vanished: Why Classic Artists Are Censoring Themselves - Rolling Stone - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- We are in the middle of Europe, and we are under censorship, anti-Putin filmmaker says - Semafor - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Protecting Floridas children in the fight against censorship and the erosion of rights - Tallahassee Democrat - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Brazil's top judge gives X until Thursday evening to comply with order or face nationwide ban - Axios - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Durov, Musk, and Zuckerberg: Tech Oligarchs Cry Censorship and What It All Means - Just Security - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Zuckerberg regrets bowing to government pressure on Covid-19 censorship - ZAWYA - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Mark Zuckerbergs empty censorship apology: Letters to the Editor Aug. 30, 2024 - New York Post - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- IC 814 controversy: Kangana Ranaut slams OTT platforms over censorship bias amid stalled release of her 'E - The Economic Times - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Meta CEO Zuckerberg admits he was part of the Biden-Harris censorship scheme. You've been warned, America - Fox News - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Opinion | European Censorship, Elon Musk and the Telegram Arrest - The Wall Street Journal - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Zuckerberg says Biden officials pressured Meta to censor content: What to know - The Hill - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Alex Berenson to amend suit against Biden, Pfizer after Zuckerberg admitted government pushed censorship - Fox News - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Zuckerberg's Biden-Harris censorship bombshell could be pivotal in First Amendment suit and more top headlines - Fox News - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Telegram And Youtube Censorship Show Bitcoin And Nostr Are Critical - Forbes - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Former Parler CEO reacts to news that Biden White House pressured Meta to censor Americans: 'Not surprising' - Fox Business - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Mark Zuckerberg Says Biden Administration Pressured Meta To Censor Covid Content, In Gift To House Republicans - Deadline - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Zuckerberg admits Biden admin pressured Facebook to censor COVID content, says it was wrong to suppress The Posts Hunter laptop coverage - New York... - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Yes, Mark Zuckerberg coming clean on Facebook censorship truly matters, as it cuts down Harris-Walz, experts claiming to fight misinformation - New... - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Tulsi Gabbard blasts champion of freedom Kamala Harris for her administrations record of censorship - Washington Examiner - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- In case you were wondering if the U.S. Government engages in censorship by proxy, read Zuckerberg's letter - Gript - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Mark Zuckerberg says he regrets bowing to COVID-19 censorship pressure - Cointelegraph - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Tornado Cash Is One Step Away from Full Censorship (and a Solution) - hackernoon.com - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Mark Zuckerberg: Covid censorship was wrong and I wish Id fought it - The Telegraph - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Mark Zuckerberg exposes extent of the Biden censorship campaign to control social media - Washington Times - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Mark Zuckerberg needs to spill all on how FBI censored Americans - New York Post - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- Zoya Akhtar on Censorship: 'Women Were Sexually Assaulted on Screen, But You Couldn't See a Kiss...' - News18 - August 29th, 2024 [August 29th, 2024]
- The science of Russian Internet censorship and surveillance - Meduza - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- RFK Jr. cleared to take on Biden censorship after Supreme Court punted issue - Washington Examiner - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- Bitter San Francisco Officials "Joyful" That X is Leaving City: Without Censorship, It's Just Not the Same! - WebProNews - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- Slap in the face Israel Censors News of Damage from Hezbollah Attacks - Palestine Chronicle - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- Leave It to Beaver Went to War with Network Censors to Show a Toilet on TV - Cracked.com - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- RFK Jr.: '16 Months of Censorship' Led to Suspending Race - Newsmax - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- Judge rules RFK Jr. can sue Biden administration over alleged censorship of charity that questions vaccines - MSN - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- Why Project 2025 is a threat to a free media - Index on Censorship - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- Are You Registered to Vote?: Book Censorship News, August 23, 2024 - Book Riot - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- Censoring the Internet Wont Protect Kids - Reason - August 22nd, 2024 [August 22nd, 2024]