The three men who wrote modern Indias history – Livemint
The age in which Sarkar worked was dominated by nationalism, given Indias struggle against the British Raj. But these words also hold substance in our time of hyper-nationalism, as Indians turn against other Indians with history (or imitations of it) as their preferred weapon. Reading T.C.A. Raghavans History Men, one is, in fact, startled that while the specifics might have changed, the broad dynamics remain the same in many ways. Then, as today, history provided raw material for multiple visions of the past, interpreted in different ways to cement conflicting ideas of the Indian nation. Debates on historiography, method and even historians own biases afflicted the writing of history in Sarkars time, and scholars found themselves in the cross hairs of chauvinism, regional and national sentiment, language and culture wars, and even plain old-fashioned clashes of ego, then as today.
Raghavans book is a splendid examination of these issues through the constructive and warm relationship Sarkar enjoyed with two other historians, G.S. Sardesai and Raghubir Sinh. The three men held each other in high regard, which is not to say that they agreed with each other on everything. Sarkar often found Sardesai too sympathetic to Maratha pride in his approach to Maratha history, for example, while Sardesai felt Sarkar did not give enough value to understanding different sides of the same story, and the purpose these served for each partys identity. Sinh, the youngest of the three, and the most unusual, given his royal heritage, was deferential to his seniors, but did not hesitate in his work to nuance arguments and challenge some of their conclusions and deeply held beliefs. It was, in fact, their own internal debates and mutual criticism that nourished the partnership for decades.
The relationship began, as Raghavan relates, when Sarkar approached Sardesai in 1904 with a proposition: He was an expert on Persian documents and could provide inputs to Sardesai, if the latter helped him with Marathi sources pertaining to the Mughal period. It was the launch of a fascinating coalition, lasting till death, but fraught also with the troubles such an alliance caused in other quarters. Sarkarwho in many ways dominates the book as the grandest of the threewas a celebrity of sorts, publishing as he did in the English language universe. His work on Aurangzeb, particularly his attacks on the emperors orthodoxy, marked him as a communal" historian for secular nationalists, even as his less than reverential take on Shivaji (who appears in his books as simply Shiva") upset proud Hindu elements with opposite political leanings, in another part of the country.
Naturally, Sardesai, who emerged in the 1920s after a long career at the court of the maharaja of Baroda, received flak from fellow Maharashtrian historians (specifically, the Poona School) for his closeness to Sarkar. That Sarkar used his influence with the British (whose police at one point had tried to charge him with sedition) to help Sardesai gain access to coveted but sealed archives further upset doyens of the Poona School who were denied this and refused even to acknowledge Sardesai as a proper historian. Language politics also played a role: Sardesai wrote in Marathi for the most part, but Sarkars support highlighted Sardesais work outside Maharashtra, to the angst of his rivals. Sarkar, of course, dismissed their criticism, putting it down to envy and labelling the Poona School a clique" unable to rise above its own pettiness.
Raghavanhaving mined a rich archive of correspondence between these men as well as Sinhs library in Sitamau, Madhya Pradeshdoes an excellent job in the book, in clear language and at a pace that never slackens, in explaining how much networks mattered, along with determination and the traditional skill sets of a historian. Sinhs princely connections, for instance, were of great value in gaining access to royal archives, even if these came with their own problems. For instance, Sarkar would write a history of Jaipur for that princely state, only to see the manuscript gather dust. The issue, evidently, was that the court was not keen to have Jaipurs time under Maratha domination advertised, and it was only in the 1980s that Sarkars book was posthumously published, thanks to Sinhs efforts. Sardesai too tried to help Sarkars book see the light of day: A mother-in-law of the Jaipur ruler was Sardesais student, and he made an attempt to use this connection to persuade the maharaja to publish the manuscript.
Among the strengths of this charming book is the biographical element it contains. Sinhs love for history saw him renounce claims to his princely seat, while the quest for the tale of his own ancestors led him to produce a superbly original revisionist account of Malwas history. Sarkars life witnessed tragedy, with two daughters widowed, a son murdered, and a grandson killed in an accident. Sardesai had to face the ire not only of the Poona School but also of his former employer, the Baroda maharaja, who, upset with him for retiring from service, slashed his hard-earned pension. We also get a glimpse, on a happier note, of Sardesais marriage in an entertaining diary entry by his wife. My husband," wrote a scandalized Mrs Sardesai once, thinks I should wear my sari according to the new fashion without one end tucked up behind my back." The issue led to a quarrel between the author of the 3,800-page Marathi Riyasat and his sartorially conservative spouse.
What shines ultimately in the bookand this is Raghavans underlying focusis the sheer love for history that united all three men. They worked in a time of slow communications, when India was still forming itself into a single, modern whole. Their work involved plodding through fields, hunting for forgotten monuments, persuading hesitant families to publish their records, fighting court cases and legal threats, not to speak of negotiating a bureaucracy that had its own interests in manufacturing obstacles. Their work was criticized then, and their methods are in many ways outdated now, but these history men" made phenomenal contributions and authored works of striking quality. And while students of history will entirely relate to Sarkars use of the term mouth-watering" in the context of finding new records, Raghavans tribute to the man and his peers is equally delightful, revealing also to the lay reader what investigating the past entails, and the dynamics that shape any mission to understand Indias historya story not just of chronicles but also of the chroniclers.
Manu S. Pillai is the author of The Ivory Throne (2015)and Rebel Sultans (2018).
This story has been published from a wire agency feed without modifications to the text. Only the headline has been changed.
Link:
The three men who wrote modern Indias history - Livemint
- Video: The Culture Wars Have Come for Wikipedia - The New York Times - October 21st, 2025 [October 21st, 2025]
- Safe Space review lively campus comedy wrestles with the culture wars - The Guardian - October 19th, 2025 [October 19th, 2025]
- Meet the NJ Librarian Whos Taking on the Culture Wars - New Jersey Monthly Magazine - October 19th, 2025 [October 19th, 2025]
- The Culture Wars Came for Wikipedia. Jimmy Wales Is Staying the Course. - The New York Times - October 19th, 2025 [October 19th, 2025]
- Matthew dAncona culture: After the Hunt storms into the culture wars - thenewworld.co.uk - October 19th, 2025 [October 19th, 2025]
- Book Review: "Discriminations: Making Peace in the Culture Wars" - TheHumanist.com - October 17th, 2025 [October 17th, 2025]
- The culture wars over the Bay Area's Super Bowl halftime show rage on - SFGATE - October 17th, 2025 [October 17th, 2025]
- Culture Wars Swing Back Hard With Anthemic New Single Bittersweet - XS Noize - October 15th, 2025 [October 15th, 2025]
- Shadow Finance Minister James Paterson discusses his recent speech, warning against adopting a populist agenda and asserting that the Liberal Party... - October 15th, 2025 [October 15th, 2025]
- Libs warned not to give ground on culture wars - senatorpaterson.com.au - October 15th, 2025 [October 15th, 2025]
- Culture Wars Announce First UK Headline Show and Drop New Single Bittersweet - Music and Gigs - October 15th, 2025 [October 15th, 2025]
- English football, right-wing politics, and a new front in the culture wars - The Athletic - The New York Times - October 11th, 2025 [October 11th, 2025]
- Race for Southern school board reflects the culture wars roiling across the country - York Daily Record - October 11th, 2025 [October 11th, 2025]
- Texas A&M chancellor on culture wars and a new era of state-driven reforms in academia - Bryan College Station Eagle - October 9th, 2025 [October 9th, 2025]
- Republican-led Culture Wars show the world should never underestimate the capacity of Americans to hate - Milwaukee Independent - October 9th, 2025 [October 9th, 2025]
- Nick Gibb: The Tories Are Too Focused On Culture Wars - Politics Home - October 9th, 2025 [October 9th, 2025]
- 'We're not the enemy, and drivers aren't the enemy either' - meet the cyclist trying to create calm on the roads and end the culture wars - Cycling... - October 7th, 2025 [October 7th, 2025]
- US Supreme Court girds for culture wars with LGBT, guns and race cases - Reuters - October 7th, 2025 [October 7th, 2025]
- How LGBTQ+ people are stepping up to run for school board seats on the front lines of Americas culture wars - Advocate.com - October 7th, 2025 [October 7th, 2025]
- Katherine Rye Jewell Tunes into Americas Culture Wars in 'Live from the Underground: A History of College Radio' - That Eric Alper - October 7th, 2025 [October 7th, 2025]
- Money Monday: Brands become part of culture wars - WLNS 6 News - October 4th, 2025 [October 4th, 2025]
- Meeks Reacts to Trump and Hegseth Gathering of Military Leaders to Wage Culture Wars - House.gov - October 2nd, 2025 [October 2nd, 2025]
- The Liberal Party cant survive by dodging the culture wars - AFR - October 2nd, 2025 [October 2nd, 2025]
- One Battle After Another review - Paul Thomas Anderson satirises America's culture wars - The Arts Desk | - October 2nd, 2025 [October 2nd, 2025]
- Council to run the Halls after culture wars between theatre and music venue - Eastern Daily Press - October 2nd, 2025 [October 2nd, 2025]
- Culture Wars: All bands should evolve constantly, thats the key to longevity. - V13.net - September 30th, 2025 [September 30th, 2025]
- The Blindfold is off: The Uneven Scales of Justice in Americas Culture Wars - National Right to Life - September 30th, 2025 [September 30th, 2025]
- Bot Networks Are Helping Drag Consumer Brands Into the Culture Wars - The Wall Street Journal - September 28th, 2025 [September 28th, 2025]
- Straight Outta Pierre | Campaign prisons, culture wars, and tangled cords - The Dakota Scout - September 28th, 2025 [September 28th, 2025]
- Tiffany promises to freeze property taxes, fight culture wars in campaign launch for governor - WISN - September 25th, 2025 [September 25th, 2025]
- Local colleges targeted amid growing campus culture wars - WGBH - September 25th, 2025 [September 25th, 2025]
- After Her Photos Were Seized by Police, Sally Man Predicts New Era of Culture Wars - PetaPixel - September 25th, 2025 [September 25th, 2025]
- Photographer Sally Mann warns of 'new era of culture wars' after her art was removed - NPR - September 25th, 2025 [September 25th, 2025]
- What Jimmy Kimmel says in his first show back may not matter. Disney has already been hammered by the culture wars. - MSN - September 25th, 2025 [September 25th, 2025]
- One Battle After Another is an exhilarating story of action, activism, and timeless culture wars - Substack - September 25th, 2025 [September 25th, 2025]
- Youre being played your part in the culture wars - The Shot - September 25th, 2025 [September 25th, 2025]
- Book Shares Teacher Voices From The Culture Wars - Forbes - September 23rd, 2025 [September 23rd, 2025]
- How Charlie Kirks assassination is being exploited to fuel Americas culture wars - 5Pillars - September 23rd, 2025 [September 23rd, 2025]
- How benching Kimmel landed Disneys Iger in the middle of culture wars - MSN - September 23rd, 2025 [September 23rd, 2025]
- Trump and Republicans find themselves on the other side of the cancel culture wars - People's World - September 23rd, 2025 [September 23rd, 2025]
- Commentary: Campus culture wars and the Kirk assassination - Orlando Sentinel - September 23rd, 2025 [September 23rd, 2025]
- Kimmel Embroils Disneys Iger in Culture Wars He Tried to Avoid - MSN - September 23rd, 2025 [September 23rd, 2025]
- David Jolly vows to stop culture wars as Florida governor - Yahoo - September 23rd, 2025 [September 23rd, 2025]
- Culture wars or cost of living? The battle for Virginia's governor - NBC4 Washington - September 21st, 2025 [September 21st, 2025]
- How benching Kimmel landed Disneys Iger in the middle of culture wars - The Washington Post - September 21st, 2025 [September 21st, 2025]
- Our Real Enemy in the Culture Wars Is Nihilism - The Dispatch - September 21st, 2025 [September 21st, 2025]
- HR is now the front line in America's culture wars and they're overwhelmed - Business Insider - September 21st, 2025 [September 21st, 2025]
- Conservatives call youth to cling to their faith to fight the culture wars - Yahoo - September 21st, 2025 [September 21st, 2025]
- Dont let culture wars hijack the Senedd election campaign - Nation.Cymru - September 21st, 2025 [September 21st, 2025]
- Trump and GOP find themselves on other side of cancel culture wars - NBC News - September 19th, 2025 [September 19th, 2025]
- Kimmel Embroils Disneys Iger in Culture Wars He Tried to Avoid - Bloomberg.com - September 19th, 2025 [September 19th, 2025]
- Jimmy Kimmels suspension is an alarming new low for the ongoing culture wars | Jesse Hassenger - The Guardian - September 19th, 2025 [September 19th, 2025]
- Cleveland author aims to rescue Jewish Confederate artist from culture wars - Ideastream - September 19th, 2025 [September 19th, 2025]
- From George Floyd to Iryna Zarutska: Rapper steps outside the culture wars - MSN - September 19th, 2025 [September 19th, 2025]
- This Week in Canada: We Are Fighting Americas Culture Wars - The Free Press - September 17th, 2025 [September 17th, 2025]
- I'm an Aggie. The culture wars are hurting Texas A&M. - Houston Chronicle - September 13th, 2025 [September 13th, 2025]
- Donald Trump And Tom Hanks: The Culture Wars Come to West Point - Forbes - September 13th, 2025 [September 13th, 2025]
- Public Policy and Administration to Deal with the Culture Wars - PA TIMES Online - September 11th, 2025 [September 11th, 2025]
- Businesses trying to drum up attention are finding themselves in the middle of culture wars - Business Insider - September 9th, 2025 [September 9th, 2025]
- How joy, beauty and affirmation disrupted the culture wars in Seattle - The Seattle Times - September 9th, 2025 [September 9th, 2025]
- Wake-up call for the Metropolitan police on culture wars | Brief letters - The Guardian - September 6th, 2025 [September 6th, 2025]
- The FTCs Investigation Into Gender-Affirming Care Exemplifies Its Impressment Into the Culture Wars - promarket.org - September 6th, 2025 [September 6th, 2025]
- Met chief backs officers over Graham Linehan arrest row, but says they shouldnt police toxic culture wars - the-independent.com - September 5th, 2025 [September 5th, 2025]
- Met chief backs officers over Graham Linehan arrest row, but says they shouldnt police toxic culture wars - The Independent - September 3rd, 2025 [September 3rd, 2025]
- Michael Paul Williams: Our culture wars hit the bottom of the (Cracker) barrel - The Daily Progress - September 3rd, 2025 [September 3rd, 2025]
- Can live ideas cut through culture wars? Thinkable thinks so - Mediaweek - September 3rd, 2025 [September 3rd, 2025]
- Met chief backs officers over Graham Linehan arrest row, but says they shouldnt police toxic culture wars - MSN - September 3rd, 2025 [September 3rd, 2025]
- Williams: Our culture wars hit the bottom of the (Cracker) barrel - Richmond Times-Dispatch - September 1st, 2025 [September 1st, 2025]
- Opinion: What we learned from Cracker Barrel and the raging corporate culture wars - The Globe and Mail - September 1st, 2025 [September 1st, 2025]
- What the Hell Is Going on With the Crosswalk Culture Wars? - Autostraddle - August 29th, 2025 [August 29th, 2025]
- How the rebrand became part of the culture wars - Marketing Brew - August 29th, 2025 [August 29th, 2025]
- Sydney Sweeney, Cracker Barrel, and the Last Gasp of the Culture Wars - The Walrus - August 29th, 2025 [August 29th, 2025]
- Americas culture wars as theater of the absurd - Asia Times - August 29th, 2025 [August 29th, 2025]
- Cracker Barrel crackup: How the culture wars are upending corporate branding - The Week - August 24th, 2025 [August 24th, 2025]
- James Dobson ignited the culture wars and changed US politics - Salon.com - August 24th, 2025 [August 24th, 2025]
- 'The Hunting Wives' dominated Netflix with a take on culture wars - Fortune - August 22nd, 2025 [August 22nd, 2025]
- Chetanyahu?: NBA star sucked into Gaza culture wars over workout video - The Forward - August 22nd, 2025 [August 22nd, 2025]
- Cancel culture and culture wars in the social imagination: transnational, diachronic, and interdisciplinary perspectives (MSH Paris) - Fabula, la... - August 20th, 2025 [August 20th, 2025]
- Doctor Who producer reveals why casting Ncuti Gatwa and Jodie Whittaker was not "some bold step in the culture wars" - Radio Times - August 20th, 2025 [August 20th, 2025]
- The Haves and Have-Yachts. Dispatches on the Ultrarich: How Trump exploited mass-manipulation to stoke culture wars - The Irish Times - August 20th, 2025 [August 20th, 2025]