Democracy and the Tribal Blame Machine – Justia Verdict
Events since the presidential election of 2020 have led a great many people to fear for the future of democracy in the United States. I share the view that democracy is in trouble, not just here but worldwide, but not because of anything connected to the last presidential election. As I wrote in my last essay, neither the attempted coup inspired and encouraged by former President Trump, the much-ballyhooed polling that purports to show high levels of Republican support for violence to achieve political goals, nor the many restrictions on voting passed primarily in Republican states after the election have had or will have much if any effect on democracy in this country. I fail to see how something can be a threat if it will have no likely impact.
Yet that doesnt mean these events are unimportant. On the contrary, they matter a great deal, though not for the reasons people imagine. They are a consequence and a cause of the sickening tendency in American society to conceive all social problems as existential tribal grievances. As I described before, virtually every attempt at political persuasion and media propaganda in this country sticks to a drearily familiar, three-step script. First, the event is cast as a life-or-death threat to something the listener holds dear. This could be something intangible or symbolic, like freedom, a way of life, or our most sacred values, or it could be something very real, like a job or property values. Next, the danger is traced to the willful misdeeds of an identifiable person or group, who are imagined not as bumbling and incompetent (and therefore safely ignored) but as organized, well-funded, disciplined and relentless. This concentrates the anger and creates a single-minded focus on a particular target. And finally, a simple solution is put forward that, presto-chango, promises to make everything better. Vote Democratic (or Republican). Buy a gun. Prosecute Trump. Send money.
This tribal blame machine is entirely bipartisan. In the denunciation of former President Trump, the attacks come generally from the political left but nobody can match the propaganda machinery of some actors on the political right. Consider, for instance, the attacks aired by the NRA in 2008 during Barack Obamas first presidential campaign. The gun lobby vowed hed be the most anti-gun president in American history who would support a huge new tax on [your] guns and ammo. One ad featured a veteran: I served my country on the battlefield to protect our freedoms. Theres no way Im voting for a president who will take them away. Another featured a Michigan hunter reacting to Obamas remark that some working-class voters cling to guns and religion because they are bitter. Because I believe in traditional American values, go to church, exercise my right to own a firearm, Barack Obama says Im bitter. Well Im not bitter, Im blessed. And every ad ended with the simple solution: Defend Freedom. Defeat Obama. These ads had it all: real and symbolic threats, a single target, and a simple solution.
The blame machine takes a terrible toll, both on the individual and on society. To begin with, it produces enormous stress. Those who spend their days certain that their most cherished values hang no more securely than the Sword of Damocles endure a truly tormented life. Even before the pandemic, a steadily increasing proportion of Americans reported exceedingly high levels of stress, and things have only gotten worse in the last two and a half years. In 2020, more than three in four Americans said that worries about the nations future were a significant source of stress, nearly seven in ten said the same of the current political climate, and more than seven in ten thought this was the lowest point in the nations history that they could remember. And this was before the inflation crisis and the war in Ukraine. In 2022, nearly 90 percent of Americans said it felt as though they had lived through a constant stream of crises without a break over the last two years.
Of course, many would insist that we have lived through one crisis after another, and that the problem is not with the packaging that explains our reality but with the reality itself. I do not for a minute discount the very real problems we have confronted and continue to confront. COVID-19 and inflation, to name only two, are realities of current life. But separating the problem from its packaging is not that straightforward. Social problems do not simply exist; our knowledge of them comes from the ubiquitous tribal blame machine, from which they emerge twisted and misshapen, sometimes bearing only a distant resemblance to reality. Anyone who doubts this need only recall the mask and vaccine wars of the last two years. COVID-19 is very real, but for a great many Americans, the nature of the threat cannot be separated from the tribalism that brings the threat to their ears. And what is true for COVID-19 is true for all our most pressing problems, from rising crime to rising prices. I cannot think of any social problem that exists in public life as an unfiltered reality; if you can think of one, let me know.
And this gets us to the second, equally serious effect of casting everything as an existential tribal grievance: problems are badly misperceived. It is one of the most enduring features of human existence that we tend to be abysmal judges of them. When it comes to democracy, the effect of this distortion can be catastrophic. As a group of political scientists recently described, partisansDemocrats and Republicans aliketend to overestimate the extremism of their political adversaries. This is bad enough, but even more disturbing is the fact that such overestimation is associated with willingness to take, or support, extreme action oneself. Research shows, for instance, that partisans who underestimate their opponents support for democratic principles are more likely to support anti-democratic practices and violations of democratic norms. Similarly, partisans who overestimate rival partisans support for violence report greater willingness to engage in violence.
Building on this literature, other researchers who study what they call the perception gap have found, unsurprisingly, that the partisans on the left and right who attend most closely to media coverage are those who are most egregiously misinformed about their political opposites: People who said they read the news most of the time were nearlythree timesmore distorted in their perceptions than those who said they read the news only now and then. In other words, those who consume the largest diet of news packaged as existential tribal threat are both the most misguided about their opponents and the most willing to support anti-democratic behavior. As the psychologists Joachim Krueger and Theresa DiDonato eloquently put it more than a decade ago, The price of social identity is the loss of a neutral perspective.
Nor is it hard to see how this distortion occurs. More than anything, the blame machine makes people angry. For years, scholars have studied how anger influences behavior. Consistent with the lesson of universal experience, researchers have found that angry people are disinclined to make the cognitive effort required to understand complex issues. Instead, anger elicits simpler [mental] processes and reliance on heuristic cues to make snap judgments. Those who are angry tend to engage in motivated reasoning, in which misinformation consistent with prior beliefs is more likely to be accepted, and contradictory information will tend to be rejected. When you are angry, you are more likely to interpret information in a partisan manner and experience reinforcement of prior-held beliefs and affiliations. Angry people are less inclined to compromise and forgive and more inclined to punish and control. And as anyone who has spent five minutes on Twitter can attest, those who are angry are often hostile and rude.
***
No one should misunderstand what I am saying. The January 6 assault on the Capitol was wrong. Its goalto thwart the will of the electorate by violence and intimidationwas obviously anti-democratic. Like any grave moral and legal wrong, it demands an appropriate response. But a mature democracy cannot achieve that response without a fair, sober, even-handed appraisal of the facts, free from hyperbole and pot-banging. Sadly, the tribal blame machine renders that appraisal all but impossible. Instead, it causes personal distress and social distortion that intensifies division and impedes deliberation. And as with the assault on the Capitol, so with each of the many problems we face: we do not inch toward solutions by driving each other apart.
Even in the best of times, democracy is hard. And these are not the best of times. Whether we are prepared to preserve our democracy remains to be seen.
See the original post:
Democracy and the Tribal Blame Machine - Justia Verdict
- Trump vs. Harvard: A battle that tests the strength of American democracy and the price of intellectual f - Times of India - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Shut down the saboteurs of democracy - The Globe and Mail - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- DOJ Is Said to Plan to Contact All 50 States on Voting Systems - Democracy Docket - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- #979: Is too much democracy hamstringing our schools? with Vlad Kogan - The Thomas B. Fordham Institute - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- As Our Democracy Continues to Be Attacked, The John R. Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act Will Help Protect Our Freedom to Vote - League of... - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- The Erosion of Democracy Threatens Our Health - The Progressive - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- David Froomkin Receives the 2025 Leonard D. White Award for Structuring Democracy - - Political Science Now - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Safeguarding Democracy Against Information Manipulation and Hybrid Threats - Visegrad Insight - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- The power of opinion: Why local voices matter in todays democracy - Torrington Telegram - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- American democracy is crashing out and it will be hard to reverse, international rights group warns - Salon.com - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Netanyahu Proposes Annexing Parts of Gaza Strip - Democracy Now! - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Iran is more prepared for democracy than many realize - The Japan Times - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- To Fight Antisemitism and Preserve Democracy, Educators and the Jewish Community Must Partner Closely | Opinion - Newsweek - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Appeals Court Delivers Another Blow to Voting Rights Act - Democracy Docket - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Theme Panel: Democracy and the Populist Critique: Are We Too Concerned about Stability? - - Political Science Now - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Mass Deportation: Analyzing the Trump Administration's Attacks on Immigrants, Democracy, and America - American Immigration Council - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Are 16-year-old voters the key to future-proofing democracy? - RFI - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- The decay within: Why the EU needs to help defend Bulgarias democracy - European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR) - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Council Appoints Juarez to Serve Out Cathy Moores Term, Accusations Fly Over Democracy Voucher Collection - PubliCola - - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- A Call for Realism, Love, Localism, and Democracy: Review of Rory Stewarts Politics on the Edge - providencemag.com - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Democracy is at stake in Harvards lawsuit against Trump - Salon.com - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- California Governor Gavin Newsom calls GOP's push to redraw congressional maps in TX an 'existential crisis to democracy' - ABC13 Houston - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- EPIC Teams Up with EFF, Protect Democracy Project to Support States Bid to Block DHS Access to Medicaid Data - EPIC Electronic Privacy Information... - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Haslag: 3 ideas for starting to dig our democracy out of its current hole | Opinion - Springfield News-Leader - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- The Death of Democracy in America Is Boring - LEVEL Man - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Trump Signs Rescission Bill Clawing Back $9B for Foreign Aid and Public Broadcasting - Democracy Now! - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Catawba College and The Carter Center team up to bolster democracy in North Carolina - wfdd.org - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Constitution House of Tabriz: where Irans struggle for democracy has its roots in - Tehran Times - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Bots, buzzers and AI-driven campaigning distort democracy - East Asia Forum - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Why Is the World Letting It Happen?: U.K. Surgeon, Back from Gaza, on Starving Children - Democracy Now! - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- League of Women Voters event to feature BadAss Grandmas for Democracy - InForum - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- GUEST COMMENTARY: Avoiding your neighbor because of how they voted? Democracy needs you to talk to them instead - thetimestribune.com - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Lowering the vote to 16 can improve democracy, research shows - Australian Broadcasting Corporation - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- China 'clearly' trying to interfere in Taiwan's democracy, Taipei says before recall vote - Reuters - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Intervening coalitions request preliminary injunction in Arkansas direct democracy lawsuit - News From The States - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Trumps Attack on Immigrants Is the Tip of the Spear for His Attack on Democracy - American Immigration Council - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Benjamin Garcia-Holgado Receives the 2025 Edward S. Corwin Award for The Judicial Bulwark: Courts and the Populist Erosion of Democracy - Political... - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- The Homelessness Crisis Is a Crisis of Democracy - Jacobin - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- One Meal Every Three Days: Journalist & Aid Worker Back from Gaza on Stark Reality on the Ground - Democracy Now! - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Press Release: Senator Roger Marshall Discusses Obama Administration's Alleged Threat to Democracy on Newsmax - Quiver Quantitative - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Dont give up on democracy: Edgar Lins mission rooted in family and experience - Madison365 - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- 2025 Democracy Service Medal: Honoring the Legacy of Oswaldo Pay - National Endowment for Democracy - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Senator Marshall: The Obama White House Was the True Threat to Democracy - Senator Roger Marshall (.gov) - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- MEDIA ADVISORY: The 13th High-Level Dialogue on Democracy, Human Rights, and Governance: Trends, Challenges, and Prospects, under the theme Justice,... - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Letter to the Editor: Term limits will save democracy and cure cancer! - Main Street Media of Tennessee - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- In Brenda Wineapple's "Keeping the Faith: God, Democracy, and the Trial That Riveted a Nation" readers revisit The Scopes Trial - WAMC - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- With Maine voter ID referendum, democracy is in the details | Opinion - The Portland Press Herald - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- U.K. Police Arrest Another 100 for Supporting Banned Group Palestine Action - Democracy Now! - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Ricig joins Nestor and Dan Rodricks for coffee and democracy chatter at Zekes in Lauraville - baltimorepositive.com - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Editorial: Zelensky just betrayed Ukraine's democracy and everyone fighting for it - The Kyiv Independent - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- How Anti-Affirmative Action Crusaders Are Escalating Their War on Inclusive Democracy - Balls and Strikes - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- PBS and NPR are generally unbiased, independent of government propaganda and provide key benefits to US democracy - The Conversation - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- The Guardian view on votes at 16: democracy belongs to the young too | Editorial - The Guardian - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Terms of Engagement Democracy: The Worst Form of Government Except All the Rest? - Ash Center - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Democracy Vouchers are serving Chinatown-ID; lets renew them - International Examiner - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- New York Citys Ranked Choice Voting: Democracy Thats Accountable to Voters - The Fulcrum - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Opinion | In Georgia, the EUs commitment to democracy is being tested and it may be failing - OC Media - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Democrats Endorse Omar Fateh to Be Next Mayor of Minneapolis - Democracy Now! - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Former EPA Official on Trump Gutting Science Research Office: People Are Not Going to Be Protected - Democracy Now! - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Democracy is pissed and shes raining - Illinois Times - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- OPINION Assault on literacy: Banned books and the destruction of our democracy - Windy City Times - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- How Western democracy died Real change is an illusion - UnHerd - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- The EUs strategic compromises are blinding it to the ongoing fight for democracy in Serbia - ceps.eu - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Democracy in Crisis as Half of Young People Fail to Register to Vote - Byline Times - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Experts Issue Stark New Warning About Nuclear Weapons, 80 Years After Trinity Test - Democracy Now! - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Two Ultra-Orthodox Parties Leave Netanyahus Government Coalition - Democracy Now! - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- The Next Phase in Destroying Israeli Democracy Begins: Ousting the Attorney General - Haaretz - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- The Pollster Who Sensed Democracy Was Faltering - The Atlantic - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Whatever Evers decides, Wisconsin is heading into a high-stakes battle for democracy - Wisconsin Examiner - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Automatic voter registration: a huge step forward for democracy and a chance to bring missing millions into elections - The Conversation - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Opinion | We Need Human Connection to Heal Democracy and Build Shared Prosperity - Common Dreams - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- All the States Where DOJ is Demanding Voting Data - Democracy Docket - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- News - Updating the Arsenal of Democracy: Allies Embrace Co-Production Model - DVIDS - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- A half year of devastation: Trumps first six months shakes American democracy - New York Daily News - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Emerging right-wing politics a threat to democracy - New Age BD - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- This Week in Democracy Week 26: Soft on Child Abuse, Tough on Public Broadcasting - Zeteo - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Opinion | Defunding Public Media Makes Perfect Sense If Destroying Democracy Is the Goal - Common Dreams - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- From military coups to elections: where is African democracy heading? - africanews.com - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Democracy Is Dying But Hey Nice Fireworks Funny 4th Of July T Shirt - roarmag.org - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Noto Democracy and the slow work of civic change - The Japan Times - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]