Kamala Harris, Elizabeth Warren, and the 2020 Democrats Medicare mess – Vox.com
One lesson of the past few weeks is that the Medicare-for-all debate has become a minefield for Democrats and its not clear that any candidate has a safe path through it.
Sen. Elizabeth Warren has dropped 14 points since October 8, when she briefly led the Democratic field in the RealClearPolitics polling average. Most attribute her decline to her handling of Medicare-for-all the financing plan she released made her the target of attacks from the moderates, and then the transition plan she released, which envisions a robust public option in the first year of her presidency and only moving to Medicare-for-all in year three, left single-payer advocates unnerved about her commitment to the cause.
Then, on Tuesday, Sen. Kamala Harris dropped out of the race. Medicare-for-all had bedeviled Harriss campaign from the start. She was a co-sponsor of Sen. Bernie Sanderss bill and entered the race in January with a surprisingly full-throated endorsement of abolishing private insurance. Under criticism, Harris walked that back, eventually releasing a Medicare expansion plan with a long transition, dodgy financing, and a reimagined role for private insurers. The combination of policy reversals and botched rollout left Harris pinched between the moderates and the leftists, and undermined faith in her ability to govern on the issue Democrats rate as most important.
Id argue that Warren and Harris made the same mistake: they treated a question of symbolic politics like a problem of policy design. In Democratic Party politics, Medicare has become a which-side-are-you-on test. Are you with Sanders and the left, and against insurance companies, squishy moderates, commodified health care, and a politics of preemptive compromise? Or are you afraid that Sanders and the left are going to scare the country into reelecting Donald Trump and set health care reform back for a generation?
This is a fundamentally political question, and splitting the difference through complex acts of technocracy ends up alienating both sides. And I say that as a technocrat who thinks Warrens transition plan makes sense on its own terms and thought Harris ended up with a more interesting plan than she got credit for essentially inverting the debate by proposing a public health insurance system with a private option. But the reaction to both plans makes clear they missed the point.
The ferocity of this debate is at odds with the legislative reality. Even if a Democrat wins, Medicare-for-all will not pass the House and it will not pass the Senate. Im not a big fan of Medicare for All, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said. When I interviewed the key Senate Democrats who will write the next health reform bill, none of them supported Medicare-for-all or believed it could pass.
The primary itself has been evidence of Medicare-for-alls long odds: A number of the co-sponsors on Sanderss bill, like Harris and Sen. Cory Booker, have made clear they dont actually support it as written. And a number of other senators the bill would need, like Amy Klobuchar and Michael Bennet, have come out in direct opposition to the legislation. Medicare-for-all would be a difficult lift even if the Democratic Party was united; its not going to pass with the party divided.
Democrats are setting themselves up for disillusionment, and possibly disaster. Either they will nominate a candidate who cannot deliver on their central policy promise or they will nominate a candidate whose victory will be a betrayal of liberal activists top policy priority.
So whats the way out?
On one level, I think this positions Sanders as perhaps Democrats best hope as a unity candidate. He is more acceptable to more Democrats than the elite conversation admits as political scientists John Sides and Lynn Vavreck show, a plurality of Biden supporters list Sanders as their second choice.
But Sanders also has a unique level of credibility with the partys more ideological left wing. His commitment to Medicare-for-all is sufficiently steadfast that leftists will believe him if and when he has to convince them that the compromised bill Congress is prepared to pass is the best bill theyre going to get. He wrote the damn bill; he might be the only one who can cut the damn deal. And if Sanders was able to get an ambitious Medicare-for-more plan through Congress and make it look like a compromise, itd be a tremendous legislative coup.
On the other hand, Warrens tumble will add to worries that Medicare-for-all makes Sanders an uncertain bet to win the presidency, and potentially boost former Vice President Joe Biden, who already leads among voters worried about electability.
The attacks on Medicare-for-all in the primary are a shadow of what would come in a general election, when the entire Republican Party, the entire health industry, and much of corporate America will devote billions of dollars to a 24/7 campaign of fearmongering and disinformation that dwarfs the genteel debates among the Democrats.
Theres a belief on the left that Medicare-for-all is extremely politically popular, and full-throated support for it is a political winner despite all the attacks that Republicans and industry will throw at it. The primary has been a soft test of that question. Warren and Sanders are the national advocates complete with large bases of support and the ability to command media coverage the policy never had in the past. The criticisms, meanwhile, are coming from other Democrats who at least claim to support Medicare-for-all as a goal, even if they favor a more incremental path on both substantive and political grounds.
The result is that net approval of Medicare-for-all has fallen 24 points among Democrats, and is underwater with both independents and Republicans. Part of the reason, surely, is that the health industry is running ads against the idea in early primary states. But that just underscores the point: Its hard to look at the polling of both Medicare-for-all and its advocates and be confident public support would hold under the kind of assault in the offing.
Adding to the trouble, a recent analysis by political scientist Alan Abramowitz found that Medicare-for-all was a liability for House Democrats who supported it in 2018. Even controlling for factors like the partisan lean of the district, political spending, and incumbency, candidates that backed Medicare-for-all performed significantly worse than those that didnt. Its hard pinning down causality when youre dealing with events as messy as House races, but Abramowitzs work will worry vulnerable congressional Democrats even as a big portion of the liberal base is making Medicare-for-all into the key litmus test.
Where does this leave Democrats? Im not honestly sure. The primary is riven by a deep, substantive disagreement over both the politics and the policy of health care. And theres good evidence that bitter primaries really do hurt parties in the general election. But the candidates whove tried to bridge the divide have suffered for their efforts. The party is likely to have to choose one path or the other, and the choice is going to hurt.
But itd be an awful legacy for the 2020 field if the fight between Medicare-for-all and Medicare-for-more ended up empowering the Republican agenda of Obamacare for none and Medicaid for fewer.
Read more:
Kamala Harris, Elizabeth Warren, and the 2020 Democrats Medicare mess - Vox.com
- A Democrat Won a Supreme Court Election in North Carolina. GOP Justices Are Blocking Her Certification. - Truthout - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- This is personal to me: Louisville Democrat will try again to add exceptions to abortion ban - Kentucky Lantern - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- We need to be in the room: DOGE Caucus Democrat works with GOP to slash spending - NBC News - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Democrat elected speaker of tied Pennsylvania House after GOP candidate bows out - The Associated Press - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Controversial Ex-Democrat Says Trump Team More 'Humane' to Her Than DNC - Newsweek - December 25th, 2024 [December 25th, 2024]
- Who is Lindy Li? Ex-Democrat fundraiser slams party, calls departure 'Leaving a cult' after criticizing B - The Times of India - December 25th, 2024 [December 25th, 2024]
- Democrat Sherrod Brown says US Senate departure won't be the last Ohioans hear from him - CBS News - December 22nd, 2024 [December 22nd, 2024]
- Fairway Finders: Meet the 2024 All-Big Bend golf teams, coach and players of the year - Tallahassee Democrat - December 22nd, 2024 [December 22nd, 2024]
- Joe Average: Transitioning from Democrat to Republican - Sentinel-Tribune - December 22nd, 2024 [December 22nd, 2024]
- Karnes caps off career with another title - River Valley Democrat-Gazette - December 22nd, 2024 [December 22nd, 2024]
- Greenwood QB Archer on full display in title game - River Valley Democrat-Gazette - December 22nd, 2024 [December 22nd, 2024]
- Democrat John Fetterman Admits He 'Never' Believed Campaign Against Trump Was 'About Fascism' Despite Harris Claims - LatinTimes - December 22nd, 2024 [December 22nd, 2024]
- House Democrat on spending drama: Im just gonna sit back and sip my tea - The Hill - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- House Democrat on spending drama: Im just gonna sit back and sip my tea - The Hill - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- Ocasio-Cortez Loses Vote to Be the Top Democrat on the Oversight Panel - The New York Times - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- Ocasio-Cortez Loses Vote to Be the Top Democrat on the Oversight Panel - The New York Times - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- Connolly wins vote to be top Oversight Democrat - POLITICO - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- Democrat Jeffries says 'lines of communication' reopened with Johnson - ForexLive - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- Democrat Jeffries says 'lines of communication' reopened with Johnson - ForexLive - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- AOC loses bid to be top Democrat on powerful House Oversight Committee - Fox News - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- AOC loses bid to be top Democrat on powerful House Oversight Committee - Fox News - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- New Liberal Democrat members of the House of Lords - Liberal Democrats - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- Democrat Sherrod Brown says US Senate departure won't be the last Ohioans hear from him - The Associated Press - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- House Republicans Have a New Spending Plan. The Top House Democrat Says Its Laughable. - NOTUS - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- We need to reinvent how we campaign, Democrat Susan Wild reflects on 2024 loss - Pennsylvania Capital-Star - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- Angie Craig wins approval of panel to serve as ranking Democrat on House Agriculture Committee - Star Tribune - December 20th, 2024 [December 20th, 2024]
- Democrat Goldman: Wray should have forced Trump to fire him - The Hill - December 12th, 2024 [December 12th, 2024]
- OPINION | TED TALLEY: Where spirits and spirituality intersect - Northwest Arkansas Democrat-Gazette - December 12th, 2024 [December 12th, 2024]
- A California labor union helped oust a Democrat from the state Capitol. His replacement wants to curb union power. - Los Angeles Times - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Trump could get deal of the year if he gets ByteDance to sell TikTok: top Democrat on China cmte. - NBC News - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Florida lawmaker abruptly switches to GOP shortly after winning election as Democrat - Salon - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Webb County Judge Tano Tijerina switches from Democrat to Republican - Laredo Morning Times - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Florida Democrat switches to Republican: Tired of being the party of protesting - Washington Times - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Maryland Democrat Ben Cardin delivers his farewell speech to the Senate - WUSA9.com - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- What world do you live in?: Hawley blasts Democrat plot for mass amnesty - NewsTalk KZRG - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Did UC Merced Students Tip the US House Election for Democrat Adam Gray? - GV Wire - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Longtime Democrat switches to the GOP because of a glaring reason - Daily Mail - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Democrat State Rep Switches to Republican Party Months After Winning Reelection - The Floridian - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Ocasio-Cortez bids to become top Democrat on key House committee - The Guardian US - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- Democrat governors spotlight they're the 'last line of defense' against Trump - Fox News - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- The Democrat Who Was Tired of Waiting His Turn - POLITICO - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- Press Secretary Reveals the Top Democrat Who Was Behind Bidens Pardon - The Daily Beast - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- Democrat senator calls on Biden to pardon Trump over NY case - MSN - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- Why a Florida Democrat joined the DOGE caucus that's looking to cut federal spending - NPR - December 5th, 2024 [December 5th, 2024]
- Top US House Democrat calls on Biden to pardon working-class Americans - Reuters - December 5th, 2024 [December 5th, 2024]
- California Democrat Flips Seat in the Last House Race to Be Called - The New York Times - December 5th, 2024 [December 5th, 2024]
- AOC "interested" in run to be top Democrat on House Oversight Committee - Axios - December 5th, 2024 [December 5th, 2024]
- Detroit Mayor Duggan, a longtime Democrat, will run for Michigan governor in 2026 as independent - The Associated Press - December 5th, 2024 [December 5th, 2024]
- Senate Democrat: Multiple Republicans are waiting for the right moment to say no to Hegseth - The Hill - December 5th, 2024 [December 5th, 2024]
- The worst vertigo of my life: People across North Bay report their experience of the earthquake - The Santa Rosa Press Democrat - December 5th, 2024 [December 5th, 2024]
- Democrat Cottie Petrie-Norris reelected to 73rd Assembly District seat - New University - December 5th, 2024 [December 5th, 2024]
- Is This the End of the White Working-Class Democrat? - The New York Times - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- Column: Shes won twice in Trump country. What can this Democrat teach her party? - Los Angeles Times - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- Democrat Derek Tran's lead over GOP's Michelle Steel grows to 102 votes in the 45th House District - LAist - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- The Democrat Picking a Fight With His Party Over Transgender Rights - The New York Times - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- Opinion | How a progressive Democrat won in a swing state that went for Trump - The Washington Post - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- I Grew Up a Democrat. It Didn't Stop My Family From Being Othered - Newsweek - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- Schumer now pleads for bi-partisanship having promised to railroad Democrat agenda through - Fox News - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- Rantz: Washington Democrat pushes bill that makes being homeless a civil right - MyNorthwest - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- Opinion | A Democrat shows how to deal with Musk beyond reflexive criticism - The Washington Post - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- Key Democrat says the ethics report on Matt Gaetz should be made public - NBC News - November 19th, 2024 [November 19th, 2024]
- Democrat Jim Costa projected to win reelection in California's 21st Congressional District - KFSN-TV - November 16th, 2024 [November 16th, 2024]
- How a Democrat Turned Back the Trump Tide on Long Island - The New York Times - November 16th, 2024 [November 16th, 2024]
- Democrat Tim Ryan open to 2026 election run; whos battling for Ohio House speaker - Signal Cleveland - November 16th, 2024 [November 16th, 2024]
- The three mountains in the way of any Democrat comeback - Fox News - November 16th, 2024 [November 16th, 2024]
- Even Democrat voters rejected leftist policies and politicians in the most surprising places - Fox News - November 16th, 2024 [November 16th, 2024]
- Democrat 'Excited' and Wary of RFK Jr. Nod as Trump Health Chief - Newsweek - November 16th, 2024 [November 16th, 2024]
- For SC voters who split their ticket, its not about Democrat or Republican - South Carolina Daily Gazette - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- Meet the 20-year-old Democrat running a multimillion-dollar PAC targeting Gen Z - NBC News - October 31st, 2024 [October 31st, 2024]
- Harriss Coattails in New Hampshire May Be Helping Democrat in Governors Race - The New York Times - October 31st, 2024 [October 31st, 2024]
- Local activist who connected Latino communities to the outdoors remembered for huge heart - The Santa Rosa Press Democrat - October 31st, 2024 [October 31st, 2024]
- NY Democrat Mondaire Jones' comeback bid threatened by Israel tensions and GOP "stealth operation" - Salon - October 31st, 2024 [October 31st, 2024]
- Column: This Democrat pulled off one of the countrys biggest upsets. Can she win again in Trump country? - Los Angeles Times - October 31st, 2024 [October 31st, 2024]
- Will it rain on trick-or-treaters? Heres the Halloween weather forecast for the North Bay - The Santa Rosa Press Democrat - October 31st, 2024 [October 31st, 2024]
- Suspect in Arizona Democrat Office Shootings Had Over 120 Guns: Officials - Newsweek - October 24th, 2024 [October 24th, 2024]
- 'Vindictive': Democrat in tight Senate race blasted by GOP rival for swipe at McDonald's after Trump visit - Fox News - October 24th, 2024 [October 24th, 2024]
- Prominent Muslim Democrat Demands Answers After Being Kicked Out of Harris Rally in Michigan - Democracy Now! - October 24th, 2024 [October 24th, 2024]
- Democrat Lucas Kunce injured reporter while shooting. Gun safety experts had these concerns - Kansas City Star - October 24th, 2024 [October 24th, 2024]
- Beyonc, whose Freedom is Harris campaign anthem, is expected at Democrat's Texas rally on Friday - The Associated Press - October 24th, 2024 [October 24th, 2024]
- Democrat Running to Replace Mark Robinson Joked About Bleaching His Office - Newsweek - October 12th, 2024 [October 12th, 2024]