Opinion | I Was Attacked by Donald Trump and Elon Musk. I Believe … – The New York Times
When I worked at Twitter, I led the team that placed a fact-checking label on one of Donald Trumps tweets for the first time. Following the violence of Jan. 6, I helped make the call to ban his account from Twitter altogether. Nothing prepared me for what would happen next.
Backed by fans on social media, Mr. Trump publicly attacked me. Two years later, following his acquisition of Twitter and after I resigned my role as the companys head of trust and safety, Elon Musk added fuel to the fire. Ive lived with armed guards outside my home and have had to upend my family, go into hiding for months and repeatedly move.
This isnt a story I relish revisiting. But Ive learned that what happened to me wasnt an accident. It wasnt just personal vindictiveness or cancel culture. It was a strategy one that affects not just targeted individuals like me, but all of us, as it is rapidly changing what we see online.
Private individuals from academic researchers to employees of tech companies are increasingly the targets of lawsuits, congressional hearings and vicious online attacks. These efforts, staged largely by the right, are having their desired effect: Universities are cutting back on efforts to quantify abusive and misleading information spreading online. Social media companies are shying away from making the kind of difficult decisions my team did when we intervened against Mr. Trumps lies about the 2020 election. Platforms had finally begun taking these risks seriously only after the 2016 election. Now, faced with the prospect of disproportionate attacks on their employees, companies seem increasingly reluctant to make controversial decisions, letting misinformation and abuse fester in order to avoid provoking public retaliation.
These attacks on internet safety and security come at a moment when the stakes for democracy could not be higher. More than 40 major elections are scheduled to take place in 2024, including in the United States, the European Union, India, Ghana and Mexico. These democracies will most likely face the same risks of government-backed disinformation campaigns and online incitement of violence that have plagued social media for years. We should be worried about what happens next.
My story starts with that fact check. In the spring of 2020, after years of internal debate, my team decided that Twitter should apply a label to a tweet of then-President Trumps that asserted that voting by mail is fraud-prone, and that the coming election would be rigged. Get the facts about mail-in ballots, the label read.
On May 27, the morning after the label went up, the White House senior adviser Kellyanne Conway publicly identified me as the head of Twitters site integrity team. The next day, The New York Post put several of my tweets making fun of Mr. Trump and other Republicans on its cover. I had posted them years earlier, when I was a student and had a tiny social media following of mostly my friends and family. Now, they were front-page news. Later that day, Mr. Trump tweeted that I was a hater.
Legions of Twitter users, most of whom days prior had no idea who I was or what my job entailed, began a campaign of online harassment that lasted months, calling for me to be fired, jailed or killed. The volume of Twitter notifications crashed my phone. Friends I hadnt heard from in years expressed their concern. On Instagram, old vacation photos and pictures of my dog were flooded with threatening comments and insults. (A few commenters, wildly misreading the moment, used the opportunity to try to flirt with me.)
I was embarrassed and scared. Up to that moment, no one outside of a few fairly niche circles had any idea who I was. Academics studying social media call this context collapse: things we post on social media with one audience in mind might end up circulating to a very different audience, with unexpected and destructive results. In practice, it feels like your entire world has collapsed.
The timing of the campaign targeting me and my alleged bias suggested the attacks were part of a well-planned strategy. Academic studies have repeatedly pushed back on claims that Silicon Valley platforms are biased against conservatives. But the success of a strategy aimed at forcing social media companies to reconsider their choices may not require demonstrating actual wrongdoing. As the former Republican Party chair Rich Bond once described, maybe you just need to work the refs: repeatedly pressure companies into thinking twice before taking actions that could provoke a negative reaction. What happened to me was part of a calculated effort to make Twitter reluctant to moderate Mr. Trump in the future and to dissuade other companies from taking similar steps.
It worked. As violence unfolded at the Capitol on Jan. 6, Jack Dorsey, then the C.E.O. of Twitter, overruled Trust and Safetys recommendation that Mr. Trumps account should be banned because of several tweets, including one that attacked Vice President Mike Pence. He was given a 12-hour timeout instead (before being banned on Jan. 8). Within the boundaries of the rules, staff members were encouraged to find solutions to help the company avoid the type of blowback that results in angry press cycles, hearings and employee harassment. The practical result was that Twitter gave offenders greater latitude: Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene was permitted to violate Twitters rules at least five times before one of her accounts was banned in 2022. Other prominent right-leaning figures, such as the culture war account Libs of TikTok, enjoyed similar deference.
Similar tactics are being deployed around the world to influence platforms trust and safety efforts. In India, the police visited two of our offices in 2021 when we fact-checked posts from a politician from the ruling party, and the police showed up at an employees home after the government asked us to block accounts involved in a series of protests. The harassment again paid off: Twitter executives decided any potentially sensitive actions in India would require top-level approval, a unique level of escalation of otherwise routine decisions.
And when we wanted to disclose a propaganda campaign operated by a branch of the Indian military, our legal team warned us that our India-based employees could be charged with sedition and face the death penalty if convicted. So Twitter only disclosed the campaign over a year later, without fingering the Indian government as the perpetrator.
In 2021, ahead of Russian legislative elections, officials of a state security service went to the home of a top Google executive in Moscow to demand the removal of an app that was used to protest Vladimir Putin. Officers threatened her with imprisonment if the company failed to comply within 24 hours. Both Apple and Google removed the app from their respective stores, restoring it after elections had concluded.
In each of these cases, the targeted staffers lacked the ability to do what was being asked of them by the government officials in charge, as the underlying decisions were made thousands of miles away in California. But because local employees had the misfortune of residing within the jurisdiction of the authorities, they were nevertheless the targets of coercive campaigns, pitting companies sense of duty to their employees against whatever values, principles or policies might cause them to resist local demands. Inspired, India and a number of other countries started passing hostage-taking laws to ensure social-media companies employ locally based staff.
In the United States, weve seen these forms of coercion carried out not by judges and police officers, but by grass-roots organizations, mobs on social media, cable news talking heads and in Twitters case by the companys new owner.
One of the most recent forces in this campaign is the Twitter Files, a large assortment of company documents many of them sent or received by me during my nearly eight years at Twitter turned over at Mr. Musks direction to a handful of selected writers. The files were hyped by Mr. Musk as a groundbreaking form of transparency, purportedly exposing for the first time the way Twitters coastal liberal bias stifles conservative content.
What they delivered was something else entirely. As tech journalist Mike Masnick put it, after all the fanfare surrounding the initial release of the Twitter Files, in the end there was absolutely nothing of interest in the documents, and what little there was had significant factual errors. Even Mr. Musk eventually lost patience with the effort. But, in the process, the effort marked a disturbing new escalation in the harassment of employees of tech firms.
Unlike the documents that would normally emanate from large companies, the earliest releases of the Twitter Files failed to redact the names of even rank-and-file employees. One Twitter employee based in the Philippines was doxxed and severely harassed. Others have become the subjects of conspiracies. Decisions made by teams of dozens in accordance with Twitters written policies were presented as having been made by the capricious whims of individuals, each pictured and called out by name. I was, by far, the most frequent target.
The first installment of the Twitter Files came a month after I left the company, and just days after I published a guest essay in The Times and spoke about my experience working for Mr. Musk. I couldnt help but feel that the companys actions were, on some level, retaliatory. The next week, Mr. Musk went further by taking a paragraph of my Ph.D. dissertation out of context to baselessly claim that I condoned pedophilia a conspiracy trope commonly used by far-right extremists and QAnon adherents to smear L.G.B.T.Q. people.
The response was even more extreme than I experienced after Mr. Trumps tweet about me. You need to swing from an old oak tree for the treason you have committed. Live in fear every day, said one of thousands of threatening tweets and emails. That post, and hundreds of others like it, were violations of the very policies Id worked to develop and enforce. Under new management, Twitter turned a blind eye, and the posts remain on the site today.
On Dec. 6, four days after the first Twitter Files release, I was asked to appear at a congressional hearing focused on the files and Twitters alleged censorship. In that hearing, members of Congress held up oversize posters of my years-old tweets and asked me under oath whether I still held those opinions. (To the extent the carelessly tweeted jokes could be taken as my actual opinions, I dont.) Ms. Greene said on Fox News that I had some very disturbing views about minors and child porn and that I allowed child porn to proliferate on Twitter, warping Mr. Musks lies even further (and also extending their reach). Inundated with threats, and with no real options to push back or protect ourselves, my husband and I had to sell our home and move.
Academia has become the latest target of these campaigns to undermine online safety efforts. Researchers working to understand and address the spread of online misinformation have increasingly become subjects of partisan attacks; the universities theyre affiliated with have become embroiled in lawsuits, burdensome public record requests and congressional proceedings. Facing seven-figure legal bills, even some of the largest and best-funded university labs have said they may have to abandon ship. Others targeted have elected to change their research focus based on the volume of harassment.
Bit by bit, hearing by hearing, these campaigns are systematically eroding hard-won improvements in the safety and integrity of online platforms with the individuals doing this work bearing the most direct costs.
Tech platforms are retreating from their efforts to protect election security and slow the spread of online disinformation. Amid a broader climate of belt-tightening, companies have pulled back especially hard on their trust and safety efforts. As they face mounting pressure from a hostile Congress, these choices are as rational as they are dangerous.
We can look abroad to see how this story might end. Where once companies would at least make an effort to resist outside pressure, they now largely capitulate by default. In early 2023, the Indian government asked Twitter to restrict posts critical of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. In years past, the company had pushed back on such requests; this time, Twitter acquiesced. When a journalist noted that such cooperation only incentivizes further proliferation of draconian measures, Mr. Musk shrugged: If we have a choice of either our people go to prison or we comply with the laws, we will comply with the laws.
Its hard to fault Mr. Musk for his decision not to put Twitters employees in India in harms way. But we shouldnt forget where these tactics came from or how they became so widespread. From pushing the Twitter Files to tweeting baseless conspiracies about former employees, Mr. Musks actions have normalized and popularized vigilante accountability, and made ordinary employees of his company into even greater targets. His recent targeting of the Anti-Defamation League has shown that he views personal retaliation as an appropriate consequence for any criticism of him or his business interests. And, as a practical matter, with hate speech on the rise and advertiser revenue in retreat, Mr. Musks efforts seem to have done little to improve Twitters bottom line.
What can be done to turn back this tide?
Making the coercive influences on platform decision making clearer is a critical first step. And regulation that requires companies to be transparent about the choices they make in these cases, and why they make them, could help.
In its absence, companies must push back against attempts to control their work. Some of these decisions are fundamental matters of long-term business strategy, like where to open (or not open) corporate offices. But companies have a duty to their staff, too: Employees shouldnt be left to figure out how to protect themselves after their lives have already been upended by these campaigns. Offering access to privacy-promoting services can help. Many institutions would do well to learn the lesson that few spheres of public life are immune to influence through intimidation.
If social media companies cannot safely operate in a country without exposing their staff to personal risk and company decisions to undue influence, perhaps they should not operate there at all. Like others, I worry that such pullouts would worsen the options left to people who have the greatest need for free and open online expression. But remaining in a compromised way could forestall necessary reckoning with censorial government policies. Refusing to comply with morally unjustifiable demands, and facing blockages as a result, may in the long run provoke the necessary public outrage that can help drive reform.
The broader challenge here and perhaps, the inescapable one is the essential humanness of online trust and safety efforts. It isnt machine learning models and faceless algorithms behind key content moderation decisions: its people. And people can be pressured, intimidated, threatened and extorted. Standing up to injustice, authoritarianism and online harms requires employees who are willing to do that work.
Few people could be expected to take a job doing so if the cost is their life or liberty. We all need to recognize this new reality, and to plan accordingly.
Yoel Roth is a visiting scholar at the University of Pennsylvania and the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, and the former head of trust and safety at Twitter.
The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. Wed like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Here are some tips. And heres our email: letters@nytimes.com.
Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram.
Read the original:
Opinion | I Was Attacked by Donald Trump and Elon Musk. I Believe ... - The New York Times
- Donald Trump Supporters Are Waking Up To The Reality Of Their Ballot Choices, And The Stories Are A Loooooot - Yahoo - February 20th, 2025 [February 20th, 2025]
- It took Donald Trump less than a decade to turn the US toward Putins Russia - CNN - February 20th, 2025 [February 20th, 2025]
- Are We Still Friends?: How Donald Trump Is Unraveling the Western Alliance - Vanity Fair - February 20th, 2025 [February 20th, 2025]
- Prediction: President Donald Trump Will Break His Social Security Promise and Propose Cuts -- Just Not in the Way You Might Think - The Motley Fool - February 16th, 2025 [February 16th, 2025]
- It Pays to Be a Friend of Donald Trump - The FP - February 16th, 2025 [February 16th, 2025]
- Donald Trump's 'Drastic' Funding Cuts Face Republican Opposition - Newsweek - February 16th, 2025 [February 16th, 2025]
- President Donald Trump Hangs His Framed Mugshot Outside the Oval Office - E! Online - E! NEWS - February 16th, 2025 [February 16th, 2025]
- Donald Trump wants states and cities to do as they are told - The Economist - February 16th, 2025 [February 16th, 2025]
- Donald Trump Wants Reciprocity in Trade: Heres a Closer Look - Council on Foreign Relations - February 16th, 2025 [February 16th, 2025]
- Interview with President Donald Trump airing ahead of Super Bowl 59: How to watch - USA TODAY - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Donald Trump set to make history at the Super Bowl. Heres why hell hate kick-off. - MLive.com - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Donald Trump golfs with Tiger Woods ahead of expected Super Bowl LIX visit - New York Post - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- The Observer view: Vengeful and reckless, Donald Trump must not go unchallenged | Observer editorial - The Guardian - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Donald Trump will be at Super Bowl LIX, and he is not happy with the rules - PennLive - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Why Chip Roy is one of Donald Trump's biggest threats - POLITICO - January 24th, 2025 [January 24th, 2025]
- What did Donald Trump throw to his inauguration crowd? Find out in the news quiz - NPR - January 24th, 2025 [January 24th, 2025]
- We tracked California's lawsuits against Donald Trump. Here's where the state won and lost - CalMatters - January 24th, 2025 [January 24th, 2025]
- Contempt is a dangerous way to lead a country: here is the sermon that enraged Donald Trump | Mariann Edgar Budde - The Guardian - January 24th, 2025 [January 24th, 2025]
- Donald Trump finds new ways to flex presidential power after returning to the White House - The Associated Press - January 24th, 2025 [January 24th, 2025]
- What to know about President Donald Trump's order targeting the rights of transgender people - The Associated Press - January 24th, 2025 [January 24th, 2025]
- Donald Trump Jr. arrives in Greenland with a message from his dad: 'Were going to treat you well' - The Associated Press - January 7th, 2025 [January 7th, 2025]
- Donald Trump Jr. arrives in Greenland after his father said the U.S. should own the Arctic territory - ABC News - January 7th, 2025 [January 7th, 2025]
- Live updates: Carter casket arrives at Capitol; Donald Trump comments on Greenland, Gulf of Mexico - The Hill - January 7th, 2025 [January 7th, 2025]
- Donald Trump Jr arrives in Greenland as his father says Denmark give it up - Fox News - January 7th, 2025 [January 7th, 2025]
- Donald Trump fumes over flag flying at half-staff to honor Jimmy Carter during inauguration - Yahoo! Voices - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Donald Trump Will Be Sentenced on 34 Felony Convictions Before Inauguration - PEOPLE - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- How Donald Trump reacted to Mike Johnson winning the House speaker vote - CBS News - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Letters to the Editor: A wokoso on the reasons more Latinos voted for Donald Trump - Los Angeles Times - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Mike Johnson reelected as House speaker with support from President-elect Donald Trump - USA TODAY - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Donald Trump Muddies the Waters in New Orleans - Vanity Fair - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Donald Trump to Be Sentenced Days Before Swearing In as President - Newsweek - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- How anti-woke spin did the business for Donald Trump - The Guardian US - December 2nd, 2024 [December 2nd, 2024]
- Sen. Alex Padilla says Donald Trump has "made it no secret that he has it in for California - CBS News - December 2nd, 2024 [December 2nd, 2024]
- Donald Trump tests the system of checks and balances just weeks after election - USA TODAY - December 2nd, 2024 [December 2nd, 2024]
- Donald Trump threatens BRICS countries that move away from dollar - Semafor - December 2nd, 2024 [December 2nd, 2024]
- 2 Changes Donald Trump Wants to Make to Social Security: Will 2026 Be the Year They Become Reality? - Yahoo Finance - December 2nd, 2024 [December 2nd, 2024]
- Donald Trump reveals exclusively to The Post what he and Biden spoke about at DC meeting - New York Post - November 14th, 2024 [November 14th, 2024]
- Republicans win 218 US House seats, giving Donald Trump and the party control of government - The Associated Press - November 14th, 2024 [November 14th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Tells House Republicans He Won't Seek a Third Term Unless They 'Figure' Out a Way to Allow It - PEOPLE - November 14th, 2024 [November 14th, 2024]
- Tesla is not the only winner under Donald Trump - The Economist - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Jr. Opts Out of White House to Join 1789 Capital - Bloomberg - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- Opinion | Americans ordered up Donald Trump. The world will foot the bill. - The Washington Post - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- Opinion: Reflections from across The Pond on Donald Trump's re-election - Palm Beach Post - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- How could Donald Trump target the LGBTQ+ community? Project 2025 is a ready blueprint for discrimination - The Conversation - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- Donald Trump has sweeping plans for a second administration. Heres what hes proposed - The Associated Press - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- UK minister grilled over tweet branding Donald Trump a self-confessed groper - POLITICO Europe - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- South Korean president practising golf to prepare for future meetings with Donald Trump - The Guardian - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- Kamala Harris and Donald Trump hold dueling rallies in swing-state Michigan as it happened - The Guardian US - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- I visited a small, struggling, climate-ravaged town in Louisiana. Why is Donald Trump certain to win here? - The Guardian US - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- Donald Trump, Not at All Worried About Losing the Election, Demands Kamala Harris Be Forced Off the Campaign - Vanity Fair - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Just Insulted Every Autoworker in Michigan - The Nation - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- Donald Trump doesnt sound too excited about asking Nikki Haley for help - Semafor - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Says Hell Ask Rupert Murdoch to Direct Fox News to Halt Negative Ads Against Him - Hollywood Reporter - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Says On Fox & Friends That Hes Meeting With Rupert Murdoch To Tell Him To Pull Negative Ads And Ban Horrible Democratic Critics -... - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Exhausted and Refusing Interviews: Report - The Daily Beast - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Shares Candid Thoughts on Harvey Weinstein: 'He Got Schlonged' - Newsweek - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- Donald Trump says Apple boss Tim Cook called him with EU concerns - BBC.com - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- A failed mic leaves Donald Trump pacing the stage in silence for nearly 20 minutes - Yahoo! Voices - October 18th, 2024 [October 18th, 2024]
- Why is Donald Trump campaigning in California, a state hes almost certain to lose? - The Associated Press - October 12th, 2024 [October 12th, 2024]
- Sebastian Stan on Losing Sleep Over Not Resembling Donald Trump, That Scene From The Apprentice and Fing Hard Action Movies: Tom Cruise Is Not a... - October 12th, 2024 [October 12th, 2024]
- That Sure Is One Way to Convince Young Men Not to Vote for Donald Trump - Slate - October 12th, 2024 [October 12th, 2024]
- The View co-hosts come out swinging at Donald Trump a day after he insulted them - The Associated Press - October 12th, 2024 [October 12th, 2024]
- Opinion | Yes, this is what Donald Trump really sounds like. No, you cannot ignore it. - The Washington Post - October 12th, 2024 [October 12th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Bemoans His Team Using Wrong Picture at Rally: 'So Stupid' - Newsweek - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- Disaster politics: Donald Trump and Kamala Harris are the latest to deal with fallout - USA TODAY - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- Donald Trump makes a theatrical return to Butler, scene of assassination attempt - The Guardian US - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- Opinion | JD Vance Is Smoother but No Better Than Donald Trump - The New York Times - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- Mike Johnson refuses to say Donald Trump lost the 2020 election to Joe Biden - USA TODAY - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- Melania Trump says Donald Trump 'knew my position and my beliefs' on abortion 'since the day we met' - NBC News - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- How Donald Trump Jr. Became the Crown Prince of MAGA World - The Wall Street Journal - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- Donald Trump in Bulter: Time stood still at site of assassination attempt, he says - BBC.com - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- Noticias Univision Townhall with Former President Donald Trump Moved to Wednesday, Oct. 16 Due to Hurricane Milton - Univision Communications - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- Donald Trump returns to scene of rally shooting in Butler - BBC.com - October 7th, 2024 [October 7th, 2024]
- Joe: Vance clearly said he was going to continue the lies of Donald Trump - MSNBC - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- JD Vance again refuses to say Donald Trump lost the 2020 presidential election - The Associated Press - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Donald Trump Claims Kim Jong Un Is Trying to Kill Me, Rants About Water-Free Bathrooms During Incoherent-Even-for-Him Remarks - Vanity Fair - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Donald Trump Mocked Jimmy Carter on the Former President's 100th Birthday - Newsweek - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Make Them Riot: Newly Unsealed Filing Gives New Details Of Federal Election Conspiracy Case Against Donald Trump - Deadline - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Donald Trump Gets October Boost as Flurry of Polls Give Him the Edge - Newsweek - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Opinion | The Dangers of Donald Trump, From Those Who Know Him - The New York Times - September 26th, 2024 [September 26th, 2024]