Why Progressives Shouldn’t Give Up on Meritocracy – The New Yorker
In his nightly monologue this past Monday, Tucker Carlson gave his assessment of what caused the meltdown at Silicon Valley Bank. He began by noting that, after the 2008 financial crash, the Obama Administrations Department of Justice, led by Eric Holder, instituted D.E.I.diversity, equity, and inclusionstandards for the financial sector. According to Carlson, this meant that women and minorities, who, in his estimation, were clearly incompetent, now worked in pivotal positions in the banking industry. Ideologues used the 2008 bank bailout to kill American meritocracy, Carlson concluded. Andy Kessler, an opinion columnist at the Wall Street Journal, published a similar take in that days paper, speculating that the banks leadership may have faltered because it was distracted by diversity demands.
In Carlsons and Kesslers imagining, meritocracy has always been the foundation of American prosperity, and normal peopleread: none of the people who would benefit from diversity-hiring initiatives at a bankare being guilted or even strong-armed into giving up the fruits of their labor. Women, immigrants, the L.G.B.T.Q.+ community, and Black Americans, in this story, are trying to create a rigged system in which people receive jobs, plaudits, and wealth for having marginalized identities.
Carlsons and Kesslers anti-woke interpretations of the bank collapse provoked a predictable outrage cycle online. The usual progressive counter-argument is to point out that the conservative vision is ahistoricalthat the U.S. has never been a meritocracy, and that race- and gender-conscious remediations are the only way to address the countrys legacies of slavery, disenfranchisement, and exclusion. But Ive always been a bit unsettled, or at the very least dissatisfied, by this response, even if I agree with its basic tenets. Its true that the U.S. isnt a country where every person starts at the same spot, and makes their way by some combination of talent and grit. Still, I worry that progressives hesitation to defend meritocracy may actually work against progressive aims. It seems like meritocracy could go the way of free speech, as a bedrock principle that the left allows the right to claim as its own, even if it matters to a great number of Americans. Just as suppressing free speech will never be popularI wrote on Tuesday about Ron DeSantiss doomed crusade to punish teachers and remove books from librariesleaving behind the idea of meritocracy is a losing proposition.
At the very least, the lefts hesitation to defend meritocracy has given conservatives a chance to monopolize the conversation around it, albeit to varying degrees of success. Last month, Vivek Ramaswamy, the Harvard- and Yale-educated entrepreneur who is running for President on the Republican ticket, announced his candidacy with a video that felt, more than anything, like it had been produced by some ambitious entry-level employees at a consulting firm who had been given access to the A.V. room. Were in the middle of a national identity crisis, Ramaswamy narrates in a voice that sounds like Ben Shapiro impersonating Barack Obama. Patriotism, hard work, and family have disappeared. We now embrace one secular religion after another. From COVIDism to climatism, and gender ideology. He goes on to say that the basic tenets of the woke left have created psychological slavery in the United States, which has completely replaced our culture of free speech in America. At first blush, his message doesnt seem all that out of line: he says most Americans agree on the core values of the country, which include basic, if somewhat abstract, freedoms and the promise of meritocracy. In his speeches and social-media posts, Ramaswamy has clarified a bit what all that means for him. He wants to eliminate the United States Department of Education and eliminate affirmative action because of its inherent anti-white & anti-Asian racism.
For the past five years or so, Ive reported on the rightward shift among immigrant voters, which, in many parts of the country, has been influenced by concerns about public safety and educational merit. There have been signs of an emerging conservative Asian American movement that galvanizes around schooling issues, in both big cities and in affluent suburbs with competitive public-school systems. In New York City, majority-Asian precincts shifted twenty-three points to the G.O.P. In San Francisco, the temporary elimination of merit-based admissions at Lowell High Schoola magnet school where more than half of the student body is Asian Americanprompted political mobilization that led to the removal of three members of the citys school board, and spilled over to the recall of Chesa Boudin, the citys progressive district attorney. These fights have resonated with Asian Americans across the countryespecially Chinese Americanswho believe that equity reforms in education, and moves like the elimination of standardized testing, are all engineered to diminish their academic accomplishments and squeeze off their childrens access to class mobility.
These developments, combined with a similar shift among Latino voters in the past two Presidential elections, and the Democratic Partys failed attempts to reach its imagined coalition of voters of color, has led to a lot of theorizing about a multiracial future for the Republican Party. Ramaswamys strategy, I imagine, is to broadcast a vision of meritocracy that, outside of establishing his culture-war bona fides, also appeals to immigrants who are anxious about their childrens educational and economic prospects. The possibility of a multiracial right that flips states like Virginia, Georgia, and Arizona into Republican strongholds may sit with those voters. Ramaswamy will almost certainly fail in his political ambitions because he cannot tell a story without veering into screeds about wokeness and comically dense monologues about banking law and bureaucratic legal ideas. His conservatism, clearly designed for bankers and tech workers who are worried their kids wont get into the Ivy League, is both weird and off-putting. But that doesnt mean he is wrong to see that the idea of meritocracy resonates with most Americans, that a perceived abandonment of it would make many of those people nervous.
What would it look like for progressives to embrace the idea of American meritocracy? There is an argument to be made that the equity model pushes a vision of merit in which disadvantaged people are finally given a fair chance to compete with the privileged. But its expressionwhether in attempts to scale back standardized testing, diversify corporate boardrooms, or place D.E.I. infrastructure into storied institutionsonly really exists in the same lite, educated spaces where DeSantis and the like have waged their war against wokeness. But the promise of meritocracy can be found elsewhere; it can be found in supporting public schools and community colleges, providing broad economic protections for families, and taxing the super-wealthy. These policies, which are already popular among Democrats, might advance a better story of meritocracyone that could appeal to voters who worry about the overreaches of the equity approach, and one that doesnt abandon an ideal that very few Americans, of any political leaning, would ever leave behind.
More:
Why Progressives Shouldn't Give Up on Meritocracy - The New Yorker
- Eric Holder Predicts Harris Will Get 5 Million More Votes Than Trump - Bloomberg - October 21st, 2024 [October 21st, 2024]
- Eric Holder Predicts Harris Will Get 5 Million More Votes Than Trump | Today News - Mint - October 21st, 2024 [October 21st, 2024]
- Eric Holder on Supreme Court: "I Think That We Need Term Limits, 18 Years" - RealClearPolitics - August 27th, 2024 [August 27th, 2024]
- Here's what Eric Holder who investigated Uber's culture thinks now - Yahoo New Zealand News - May 22nd, 2024 [May 22nd, 2024]
- Peter Navarro 'Could Be in Prison Within Less Than 60 Days' - Mediaite - January 31st, 2024 [January 31st, 2024]
- Gov. Murphy and other New Jersey Democrats call on Sen. Menendez to resign over bribery charges - Yahoo News - September 23rd, 2023 [September 23rd, 2023]
- March on Washington Film Festival tells untold stories of Civil ... - WTOP - September 23rd, 2023 [September 23rd, 2023]
- America wakes up to woke | Government/Opinion - City-sentinel - June 28th, 2023 [June 28th, 2023]
- National advocates call on Wisconsin lawmakers to fund the Office ... - Wisconsin Law Journal - June 28th, 2023 [June 28th, 2023]
- Eric Holder Says It Would Be 'Absurd' For Trump To Serve As President If Convicted - Yahoo News - June 13th, 2023 [June 13th, 2023]
- Keith Ellison to publish George Floyd trial diary Tuesday, with intro ... - Star Tribune - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- Democrat Heather Boyd wins special election, securing Democratic ... - Pennsylvania Capital-Star - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- Let's applaud the bipartisan approach to fentanyl at the state Capitol ... - Minnesota Reformer - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- Issues of the Court: Legal Experts Discuss Affirmative Action ... - westsiderag.com - May 16th, 2023 [May 16th, 2023]
- Willie Nelson honored with prestigious Texas award: Were here tonight to clap for Willie. - KXAN.com - May 16th, 2023 [May 16th, 2023]
- Today in History: May 13 | | heraldbulletin.com - The Herald Bulletin - May 16th, 2023 [May 16th, 2023]
- Internet-famous for Irish dancing, Mary Papageorge is about to grab ... - Madison.com - May 16th, 2023 [May 16th, 2023]
- Knodl, who attempted to delay certification of 2020 presidental ... - Wisconsin Law Journal - May 16th, 2023 [May 16th, 2023]
- 'We can do this': Big ideas from the Crosscut Ideas Festival - Crosscut - May 10th, 2023 [May 10th, 2023]
- Letter | The 2nd Amendment is for the protection of law-abiding ... - Kdminer - May 10th, 2023 [May 10th, 2023]
- Democrats Charting a New Path Back to the Speaker's Gavel ... - The New York Sun - April 13th, 2023 [April 13th, 2023]
- Letter to the Editor - Maple Lake Messenger - April 13th, 2023 [April 13th, 2023]
- Eric Holder to boost Protasiewicz in Wisconsin Supreme Court race - NBC News - March 28th, 2023 [March 28th, 2023]
- Ex-Cop Suggests LAPD Could Have Ordered Nipsey Hussle's Murder - Purple Sneakers - March 28th, 2023 [March 28th, 2023]
- Right-wing host calls for military to execute Obama if Trump is indicted - Salon - March 23rd, 2023 [March 23rd, 2023]
- LBJ Foundation to honor Willie Nelson with 'LBJ Liberty and Justice for All Award' - KVUE.com - March 23rd, 2023 [March 23rd, 2023]
- As Manhattan DA Bragg Targets Trump, His Rivals Are Teaming Up - Yahoo Finance - March 23rd, 2023 [March 23rd, 2023]
- Ridley-Thomas - Compton Herald - March 23rd, 2023 [March 23rd, 2023]
- Nipsey Hussles Killer, Eric Holder, Gets 60 Years to Life in Prison - February 24th, 2023 [February 24th, 2023]
- Nipsey Hussle's killer Eric Holder Jr. gets 60 years to life in prison ... - February 24th, 2023 [February 24th, 2023]
- Nipsey Hussle's killer sentenced to 60 years in prison - February 24th, 2023 [February 24th, 2023]
- Nipsey Hussle Killer Eric Holder Jr. Sentenced To 60 Years To Life In ... - February 24th, 2023 [February 24th, 2023]
- The Nipsey Hussle Murder Trial: Eric Holder Jr. Guilty of First-Degree ... - February 14th, 2023 [February 14th, 2023]
- 2023 Paul Robeson Conference | A Conversation with Eric Holder ... - February 12th, 2023 [February 12th, 2023]
- Jury finds Eric Holder guilty of Nipsey Hussle's murder - New York Post - February 10th, 2023 [February 10th, 2023]
- Eric Holder Biography - Facts, Childhood, Family Life & Achievements - February 10th, 2023 [February 10th, 2023]
- Nipsey Hussle death: Eric R. Holder Jr. convicted of first-degree ... - October 23rd, 2022 [October 23rd, 2022]
- Eric Holder predicts how Donald Trump will be indicted - October 23rd, 2022 [October 23rd, 2022]
- Eric Holder's Contempt Case Trends Amid Bannon Sentence 'Double Standards' - Newsweek - October 23rd, 2022 [October 23rd, 2022]
- Wells Fargo agrees to third-party racial-equity audit - Banking Dive - September 20th, 2022 [September 20th, 2022]
- Peloton (PTON) has accepted the resignations of John Foley as Executive Chair - StreetInsider.com - September 17th, 2022 [September 17th, 2022]
- Peloton (PTON) Stock: Why It Fell Over 4% Today - Pulse 2.0 - September 13th, 2022 [September 13th, 2022]
- Foreign leaders to be bussed to Queens funeral as private jets and helicopters banned - The Independent - September 13th, 2022 [September 13th, 2022]
- Nipsey Hussles Legacy Honored by Star on Hollywood Walk of Fame - Sacramento Observer - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- Long-awaited Jackie Robinson Museum open to the public - Afro American - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- RIP, Party of Law and Order - VICE - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- Who is Eric Holder? | The Sun - August 22nd, 2022 [August 22nd, 2022]
- 'Wrong Eric Holder': Former AG trends after Nipsey Hussle's ... - MEAWW - August 22nd, 2022 [August 22nd, 2022]
- Nipsey Hussle's Killer Eric Holder Found Guilty of Murder - TMZ - August 22nd, 2022 [August 22nd, 2022]
- Eric Holder found guilty in death of rapper Nipsey Hussle - CBS News - August 22nd, 2022 [August 22nd, 2022]
- Liz Cheney Was Defeated By the Extremist Movement She Helped to Empower Mother Jones - Mother Jones - August 22nd, 2022 [August 22nd, 2022]
- Why Bill Maher Thinks Republicans Are 'Gonna Steal The Issue' Of Marijuana Legalization From Democrats - Benzinga - August 22nd, 2022 [August 22nd, 2022]
- Politics ruins everything, including your memory - Big Think - July 29th, 2022 [July 29th, 2022]
- Chilmark: The best new thing - Martha's Vineyard Times - July 29th, 2022 [July 29th, 2022]
- Jan. 6 hearing witnesses prove Trump's criminal intent - MSNBC - July 29th, 2022 [July 29th, 2022]
- Eric Holder Trial Reveals Gruesome Details About Nipsey Hussle's Passing - July 4th, 2022 [July 4th, 2022]
- Eric Holder warns of 'apartheid system' in US as conservative 'minority ... - July 4th, 2022 [July 4th, 2022]
- Eric Holder, man accused of murdering Nipsey Hussle, beat up in jail: report - New York Post - July 4th, 2022 [July 4th, 2022]
- Witnesses reluctant to come forward at trial of Nipsey Hussle's accused shooter: "I don't know nothing" - CBS News - June 28th, 2022 [June 28th, 2022]
- The Democratic Party is a major threat to America - Washington Examiner - June 28th, 2022 [June 28th, 2022]
- Today in History - The Boston Globe - June 28th, 2022 [June 28th, 2022]
- Who is Eric Holder and why did he kill Nipsey Hussle? - The Sun - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- Who is Eric Holder and why did he kill Nipsey Hussle? - The US Sun - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- Nipsey Hussle Murder Trial: What to Know - The New York Times - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- Bill Maher Thinks Republicans Will 'Steal' Pot Legalization - High Times - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- Sticks, stones and worse | Cal Thomas - The Morning Journal - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- Letter to the editor: 'Red flag' laws a bad idea - Washington Times - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- Tucker Carlson: Peter Navarro's arrest is a huge step toward the politics of the third world - Fox News - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- EDITORIAL: Federal law enforcement the real threat to our republic - Washington Times - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- A Tale of Two 'Incitements' - The Stream - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- Nancy Mace Or Chuck Schumer: Whose Cannabis Reform Bill Are Big Weed Companies Supporting? - The Fresh Toast - June 13th, 2022 [June 13th, 2022]
- Transcript: The 11th Hour with Stephanie Ruhle, 5/25/22 - MSNBC - May 29th, 2022 [May 29th, 2022]
- Americas Redistricting Process Is Breaking Democracy - The New Yorker - May 29th, 2022 [May 29th, 2022]
- We should show images of the dead - TheGrio - May 29th, 2022 [May 29th, 2022]
- Hours after Texas tragedy, hearing over ATF head begins - NewsNation Now - May 29th, 2022 [May 29th, 2022]
- Documentary by Nipsey Hussle Released Before the Opening of The Marathon (Collective), THC and CBD Retail Stor - Black Enterprise - May 23rd, 2022 [May 23rd, 2022]
- SCOTT DREYER: Trial Regarding Trump-Russia Collusion Hoax Began This Week - The Roanoke Star - May 23rd, 2022 [May 23rd, 2022]
- Common, Eric Holder, Alexis McGill Johnson, Wanda Sykes and More to Join When We All Vote's Inaugural Culture of Democracy Summit in June - Yahoo... - May 20th, 2022 [May 20th, 2022]
- The Buffalo supermarket massacre is the latest mass shooting authorities say was motivated by hate - WBAL TV Baltimore - May 20th, 2022 [May 20th, 2022]
- Michelle Obama worries overturning Roe v. Wade will strip 'womxn' of their right to health care - Fox News - May 20th, 2022 [May 20th, 2022]