The European Parliaments wish list on the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) – JD Supra
The Draft Report sets out the Committees proposed amendments to the CBAM Proposal. While the Draft Report states that it welcomes the overall approach of the CBAM Proposal, several of the Committees amendments change some significant aspects of the CBAM Proposal.
In this publication, we will look at some of those interesting amendments and reflect on the impact they may have on the sectors concerned by the CBAM.
Climate change is a global problem that needs global solutions. Because the level of climate ambition varies throughout jurisdictions, a risk of carbon leakage exists. This means that companies based in the EU could move carbon-intensive production abroad, or EU products could be replaced by more carbon-intensive imports. Such carbon leakage can shift emissions outside of the EU and could therefore weaken climate efforts. Although the existing EU Emission Trading System (EU ETS) already provides protection against carbon leakage through free allocation of emission rights, the EUs ambitious Fit-for-55 targets have rendered this protection insufficient to protect sectors at risk. In order to increase protection against carbon leakage, the European Commission (EC) has therefore adopted a carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM). The aim of the CBAM is to equalise the price of carbon between domestic products and imports and ensure that the EUs climate objectives are not vitiated by production relocating to countries with less ambitious climate policies.4
In practice, under CBAM EU importers will need to buy carbon certificates corresponding to the carbon price that would have been paid, had the goods been produced under the EUs carbon pricing rules. Conversely, once a non-EU producer can show that they have already paid a price for the carbon used in the production of the imported goods in a third country, the EU importer will be able to fully deduct the corresponding cost. In short, the CBAM will help reduce the risk of carbon leakage by encouraging producers in non-EU countries to green their production processes.5 However, some difficulties concerning the principles and practical implementation of the CBAM still exist - these are discussed at length in this article on A&Os Countdown to COP26 blog.
CBAMs are already in place in some regions around the world, such as California, where an adjustment is applied to certain imports of electricity. Like the EU, a number of countries such as Canada and Japan are planning similar initiatives.6
Firstly, the Draft Report broadens the scope of the CBAM Proposal to cover organic chemicals, hydrogen and polymers by deleting the proposed Recital 32, which excluded the organic chemicals sector from the CBAM Proposal and adding a reference to hydrogen and polymers into the existing Recital 30 of the CBAM Proposal.7 This means the entire organic chemicals sector would also be subject to the CBAM, which is a significant extension of its scope.
Furthermore, the Committee extends the type of emissions covered by the CBAM Proposal by including indirect emissions (eg emissions generated from electricity used for manufacturing, heating or cooling) in the definition of embedded emissions in article 3, (16) of the CBAM Proposal.
In addition, the amendment not only covers the production processes of the goods themselves, but also those of its upstream products.8 This extension may have a significant knock-on effect, potentially involving additional (non-included) sectors in the proposed CBAM by association. It may also influence the carbon price (ie the amount paid in a third country in the form of a tax or emission allowances under a greenhouse gas emissions trading system, calculated on greenhouse gases covered by such a measure and released during the production of goods) seeing as embedded emissions in products imported into the EU will influence the amount of carbon certificates that will be required to import those products.
Additionally, the Committee notes that the implementation pace currently set out in the CBAM Proposal is too gradual to achieve the ambitious EU 2030 objective (ie the net emission reduction target of greenhouse gases of at least 55% by 2030, compared to 1990 levels)9. Therefore, it proposes to shorten the transitional period by one year, ending on 31 December 2024. The Committee also sets out an incremental phase-in of the CBAM factor as an alternative to the free allowances allocated under the EU ETS, so that it becomes compatible with the EU 2030 climate objective.10
The notable exception to this incremental phase-in is the cement sector, for which the Committee excludes certain categories of cement from this phase-in process entirely, because it considers this sector to be less exposed to carbon leakage. This means that the applicable CBAM factor for the cement sector will be 0% (meaning no CBAM mitigation factor would apply at all) from as early as 1 January 2025.
Moreover, the Committee considers that a central CBAM authority would be the most efficient, transparent and cost-effective instrument to ensure the proper implementation of the CBAM Proposal as opposed to a decentralised system with 27 competent national authorities. Practically, the Draft Report suggests that appeal against the decisions of the CBAM authority would be possible with an independent Board of Appeal, made up of three members, appointed by the Council, EP and Commission respectively.11 Decisions of the Board of Appeal could then be appealed with the General Court and ultimately, the Court of Justice.12 This begs the question, considering the caseload before the Court of Justice, whether these additional cases will not add significantly to the current processing times.
Interestingly, while the original article 26 of the CBAM Proposal contained a penalty provision in case declarants failed to surrender the required number of CBAM certificates amounting to the excess emissions penalty of article 16 (3) of the ETS Directive13 (ie EUR 100 for each tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent emitted for which the operator has not surrendered allowances), the amended article 26a changes the calculation method of the penalty to three times the average price of CBAM certificates in the previous year for each CBAM certificate that the authorised declarant did not surrender. Therefore, the Committees suggestion for article 26a allows the height of the penalty to fluctuate according to the price of CBAM certificates as opposed to a fixed penalty price depending on the excess amount of carbon dioxide emitted.
Overall, the Committees Draft Report contains some amendments that significantly extend the CBAM by including the organic chemicals sector in its scope, as well as including indirect emissions and emissions from upstream products into the definition of embedded emissions in the CBAM Proposal. These extensions of the CBAMs scope may have a significant knock-on effect on non-included sectors as well as the amount of carbon certificates declarants would be required to surrender.
Furthermore, the Committees indication that the current pace of implementation as set out in the CBAM Proposal is too slow seems characteristic of the EUs overall climate ambition as well as its desire to bring the CBAM in sync with the EU ETS and its free allocation rules. The ultimate objective is to ensure the CBAM becomes a fully developed alternative to the free allowances currently allocated to installations at risk of carbon leakage under the EU ETS. Nevertheless, the notable exception to this rule is the cement industry, which the Committee completely cuts out of these benefits, stating as justification that the cement sector has the lowest trade intensity among goods covered by the CBAM and the risk of carbon leakage is therefore correspondingly low. Indeed, certain categories of cement would not benefit from any CBAM factor from as early as 1 January 2025.
The Committees suggestions to change the approach toward authorisation of import of products into the single market under the CBAM from a Member State approach through competent national authorities to a single EU-level CBAM authority is remarkable as well. Considering that the import of goods happens at Member State level, one may suggest that national authorities could have a better view on the activities on the ground and the practical and logistical adoption of the future CBAM as opposed to a single authority managing the import goods at all entry points into the single market at once. That being said, an argument in favour of legal certainty and consistency while avoiding the risk of uneven implementation of the CBAM and its implementing measures and delegated acts across Member States and potentially, forum shopping, can also be made.
In addition, a potentially uneven implementation at Member State level could also result in trade distortions if certain national authorities would function more efficiently than others. It appears that the Committee has considered the latter view more convincing by introducing the idea of a single CBAM authority. Furthermore, the appeal process of CBAM authority decisions with an independent Board of Appeal and ultimately, the Court of Justice, does raise some questions concerning the current caseload before the Court and whether the development of the CBAM could be hindered by its relatively long processing times.
Finally, the Committee has also changed the CBAM Proposals approach toward the calculation of penalties. Instead of a fixed penalty per tonne of carbon dioxide emitted in excess of carbon certificates surrendered by a declarant, the penalty would now be calculated based on the price of the carbon certificates themselves. Depending on the price of the future carbon certificates, this penalty could be more burdensome than the initial approach set out by the Commission. However, it is still unclear at this point how the carbon certificates will be priced and how heavily those prices may fluctuate in the future.
In conclusion, although it is not certain that the Committees amendments will make it into the final CBAM Regulation, it is nevertheless interesting to see how the Committees vision differs on some significant points to that of the Commission. Seeing as the CBAM Proposal has been submitted under the ordinary legislative procedure, the amendments will be debated in the EP plenary, after which the EP will vote on the amended CBAM Proposal. If the EP adopts the (amended) CBAM Proposal, it will subsequently be sent to the Council, which can accept the EPs position (and thus, adopt the legislative act) or amend the EPs position and then send it back to the EP for a second reading. The vast majority of proposals are adopted during the first reading.14
If the CBAM Proposal fails to be adopted during the second reading by both the EP and the Council, a Conciliation Committee made up of members of the EP and Council representatives will attempt to reach an agreement on a joint text. If this is the case, the agreed text is sent around to the EP and the Council for a third reading. If both the EP and the Council approve the joint text, the CBAM Proposal will be adopted. If not, the CBAM Proposal will not enter into force and the procedure is ended. The average time for an EC proposal to be adopted on the first reading was just below 18 months in the 2014-2019 legislative period.15 Furthermore, certain Member States (eg France, which holds the presidency of the Council of the European Union since 1 January 2022 until 30 June 2022 and has flagged the adoption of the CBAM as a priority topic) are pushing towards its swift adoption, which may accelerate the legislative process. One thing is certain: this is not the last word on the CBAM Proposal.
1European Parliament, Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety, Draft Report on the proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a carbon border adjustment mechanism, 21 December 2021, available here (the Draft Report).
2Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a carbon border adjustment mechanism, 14 July 2021, available here (the CBAM Proposal).
3A&Os Countdown to COP26 blog already features a deep-dive analysis of the functioning of the CBAM, contributed by Arthur Sauzay. The full article is available here.
4European Commission, Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism Q&A, 14 July 2021, see here.
5European Commission, Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism Q&A, 14 July 2021, see here.
6European Commission, Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism Q&A, 14 July 2021, see here.
7Draft Report, Amendment 13.
8Draft Report, Amendment 33.
9This target was adopted under the EU Climate Law. More information is available here.
10Draft Report, Amendment 105.
11Draft Report, Amendment 94.
12Draft Report, Amendment 96.
13Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 October 2003 establishing a system for greenhouse gas allowance trading within the Union and amending Directive 96/61/EC, available here.
14Source: see here.
15Source: here.
Read more:
The European Parliaments wish list on the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) - JD Supra
- The European Union just issued a dire warning to its 450 million citizens: Stockpile supplies and prepare for disaster - Fortune - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- The European Union is preparing for war and is calling for emergency reserves in every home - CiberCuba - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- The European Union rejected Russias demand for a ceasefire in exchange for lifting sanctions - - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- Exclusive | European Union to slap Meta with fine up to $1B or more for breaching strict antitrust rules: sources - New York Post - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- Peter Rough sat down with Kaja Kallas, European Union high representative for foreign affairs and security policy and European Commission vice... - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- Court of Justice of the European Union: Member states representatives appoint thirteen judges to the General Court - consilium.europa.eu - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- When the European Union wants to get back to basics - Marketscreener.com - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- The European Union urges citizens to stockpile supplies to last 3 days in case of crisis - Goshen News - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- The European Union urges citizens to stockpile supplies to last 3 days in case of crisis - Oil City Derrick - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- European Union's Transmission Shafts and Cranks Market Expected to Slightly Increase with a CAGR of +0.3% over the Next Decade - IndexBox, Inc. - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- New European Union Plan To Boost Local Arms Production Would Freeze U.S. Out Of Billions - The War Zone - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- European Union's Roasted Coffee Market to See Continued Growth with +0.6% CAGR by 2035 - IndexBox, Inc. - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- EU Penalizes RPM And Other Vertical Conduct Violations - Cartels, Monopolies - European Union - Mondaq News Alerts - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- European Union's Toilet Paper Market to Reach $27.1B by 2035 with +0.5% CAGR - IndexBox, Inc. - March 26th, 2025 [March 26th, 2025]
- European Union Delays Retaliatory Tariffs On U.S. ProductsIncluding Whiskey - Forbes - March 20th, 2025 [March 20th, 2025]
- ICC President visits Brussels, urges European Union to take immediate action to protect the Court - the International Criminal Court - March 20th, 2025 [March 20th, 2025]
- The European Sting is Your democratic, independent and top quality political newspaper specialized in European Union News. Unique Features: iSting... - March 20th, 2025 [March 20th, 2025]
- The Prime Minister of Slovakia supported Ukraine's integration into the European Union - Eurasia Daily - March 20th, 2025 [March 20th, 2025]
- Trump reacts to European Union slapping tariffs on U.S. goods - CBS News - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- Rxulti approved in the European Union for adolescent schizophrenia - PharmaTimes - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- European Union Responds With Tariffs on Soybeans, Other Ag Exports - DTN The Progressive Farmer - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- European Union retaliates with tariffs on $28 billion U.S. products - RFD-TV - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- Donald Trump threatens European Union with 200% tariffs on specific goods if they dont remove nasty tax - UNILAD - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- Canada and the European Union announce retaliatory tariffs against the United States - KREM.com - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- Commission decides to refer SPAIN to the Court of Justice of the European Union due to discriminatory tax treatment of non-resident taxpayers - The... - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- European Union hits back with counter tariffs on US goods - USA TODAY - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- Trade Wars: European Union Retaliates Against U.S. Tariffs on Steel and Aluminum - TipRanks - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- Commission hosts event to gather input and expertise on upcoming European Water Resilience Strategy - European Union - March 7th, 2025 [March 7th, 2025]
- UNESCO and the European Union Promote Training in Creative Tourism in the Caribbean - UNESCO - March 7th, 2025 [March 7th, 2025]
- The Interests of the European Union and the United States Are Diverging - Modern Diplomacy - March 7th, 2025 [March 7th, 2025]
- Tunisia: Call for the European Union to send international observers to the so-called "conspiracy" trial - FIDH - March 7th, 2025 [March 7th, 2025]
- European Union Blasts Trump Tariff Threats as Starmer Visits White House - Newsweek - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- Trump vows to slap 25% tariffs on the European Union - FRANCE 24 English - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- Trump vows to impose 25% tariffs on imports from the European Union - The Associated Press - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- Trump says tariff level will be 25% on European Union products - Le Monde - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- EU reaffirms unwavering support to Ukraine on anniversary of invasion - European Union - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- The European Union is financing a project to strengthen social protection for women in ten local communities in Bosnia and Herzegovina - EEAS - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- Trump's reciprocal tariffs would hit these European Union products that Americans buy the hardest - CNBC - February 14th, 2025 [February 14th, 2025]
- European Union Says It Will Respond "Firmly, Immediately" To Trump's Tariffs - NDTV - February 14th, 2025 [February 14th, 2025]
- How the European Union could counter US tariffs - ING Think - February 14th, 2025 [February 14th, 2025]
- (Nemolizumab) Approved in the European Union for Moderate-to-Severe Atopic Dermatitis and Prurigo Nodularis - Business Wire - February 14th, 2025 [February 14th, 2025]
- European Union could ban the number 1 Catholic app in the world: Hallow - ZENIT - English - February 14th, 2025 [February 14th, 2025]
- Political contagion in Europe: can the European Union survive Trumpism? - Bruegel - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Bolstering the cybersecurity of the healthcare sector - European Union - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Medidatas Patient Experience Recognized as Sustainability Solution by the European Union, Paving the Way for Greener Clinical Trials - Dassault... - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- European Union Special Representative for the Great Lakes Region, Johan Borgstam, makes first official visit to Tanzania - EEAS - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Indicating the way forward for sustainable European aviation - European Union - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- UNHCR and the European Union join forces to provide lasting solutions for Afghan refugees and returnees - EEAS - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Irregular migration into the European Union fell sharply last year, border agency says - The Associated Press - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Poland Assumes the Presidency of the Council of the European Union - Kyiv Post - January 6th, 2025 [January 6th, 2025]
- Far From Ignorant: The European Union, Arms Exports and Israel - CounterPunch - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Major changes in the European Union - summary of 2024: everything you need to know in 2025 - Visit Ukraine - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Hungary's controversial presidency of the Council of the European Union comes to an end - Euronews - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- 30 years together: Austria, Finland and Sweden in the EU - European Union - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- AI and Employee Data Protection in the European Union: 8 Key Takeaways for Multinational Businesses - JD Supra - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- Pro-European Union Protests in Georgia Continue into New Years Eve - AL24 News - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- 2025, between the reformist drive and the structural challenges of the European Union - The Diplomat in Spain - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- Statement on behalf of the European Union and its Member States by H.E. Ambassador Stavros Lambrinidis, Delegation of the European Union to the United... - December 30th, 2024 [December 30th, 2024]
- European Union to resume Association Council meetings with Israel - The Times of Israel - December 18th, 2024 [December 18th, 2024]
- Its time for the European Union to rethink personal social networking - Bruegel - December 18th, 2024 [December 18th, 2024]
- Mistral 3 project to receive 60 million from European Union - MBDA - December 18th, 2024 [December 18th, 2024]
- The European Union and Palestinian Authority convene Investment Platform and announce EUR 28.3 million of investments for the Palestine Financial... - December 18th, 2024 [December 18th, 2024]
- The EVERY Company Further Expands its IP Estate with European Union Patent for Recombinant Ovalbumin - Business Wire - December 18th, 2024 [December 18th, 2024]
- European Union sanctions 26 individuals and two entities in Belarus - euneighbourseast.eu - December 18th, 2024 [December 18th, 2024]
- European Union: What do CG&R companies need to know about the European Accessibility Act? - GlobalComplianceNews - December 18th, 2024 [December 18th, 2024]
- New EU norms to reduce environmental impact of smitheries and foundries - European Union - December 14th, 2024 [December 14th, 2024]
- Syria: Statement by the High Representative on behalf of the European Union on the fall of the Assad regime - consilium.europa.eu - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- European Union and the Gates Foundation to co-host Gavi 6.0 High Level Pledging Summit - Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- European Union orders TikTok to preserve data related to Romanian election - The Associated Press - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- European Union - United Republic of Tanzania: Joint Communique of the 2024 Partnership Dialogue - EEAS - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Human Rights Day: Statement by the High Representative on behalf of the European Union - consilium.europa.eu - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- We are waiting to return home - helping refugees in Sudan - European Union - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Revised Regulation on Classification, Labelling and Packaging of Chemicals enters into force - European Union - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- CCS legal framework for the development of carbon capture and storage technologies in Poland and the European Union - Dentons - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- Mercosur and the European Union sign trade agreement - Fresh Fruit Portal - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- European Union To Spend Over $4 Million And 3 Years To Create Report On European Animation Industry - Cartoon Brew - December 4th, 2024 [December 4th, 2024]
- Speech by President von der Leyen at the European Parliament Plenary on the new College of Commissioners and its programme - European Union - December 4th, 2024 [December 4th, 2024]
- ASSEMBLY | EU bishops reflect on Europes future and challenges of the new institutional cycle - The Catholic Church in the European Union - December 4th, 2024 [December 4th, 2024]
- Georgia suspends talks on joining the European Union and accuses the bloc of blackmail - The Associated Press - November 30th, 2024 [November 30th, 2024]
- An update on political advertising in the European Union - The Keyword - November 30th, 2024 [November 30th, 2024]