Not So Long Ago, Democrats Favored Immigration Curbs – LifeZette
A prominent politician, announcing the results of a commission appointed to study immigration, urged Congress to significantly cut legal migrations to the United States.
The rationale offered was that a flood of lesser-educated, low-skilled immigration drives down wages and hurts employment prospects for Americans with comparable skills and education.
What the commission is concerned about are the unskilled workers in our society in an age in which unskilled workers have far too few opportunities open to them, the politician announced. When immigrants are less well-educated and less-skilled, they may pose economic hardships to the most vulnerable of Americans, particularly those who are unemployed or under-employed.
President Donald Trump? Sens. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) or David Perdue (R-Ga.)?
Try Barbara Jordan, civil rights icon and first black woman elected to Congress from the South.
The nine-member Commission on Immigration Reform that the former Texas congresswoman headed in the 1990s produced a pair of reports one calling for tighter controls on illegal immigration and another calling for cutting back legal immigration to about 550,000 entrants a year.
The specifics look a lot like the RAISE Act, the bill Cotton and Perdue introduced earlier this year to fierce criticism.
The Jordan commission proposed prioritizing skills and education in immigration, while limiting family-based migration to spouses and minor children, unlike the current system, which allows extended relatives to come into the country.
That is similar to the provisions of the RAISE Act, as are Jordan commission recommendations for reducing refugees to 50,000 per year and eliminating the diversity visa lottery, which awards roughly 50,000 green cards annually to applicants chosen randomly from around the world.
"The RAISE Act really is the second coming of the Barbara Jordan commission," said Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies.
Robert Law, government relations director at the Federation for American Immigration Reform, agreed.
"It's literally, word-for-word, how the press release from Cotton and Perdue reads," he said.
What Jordan Recommended Indeed, the Reforming American Immigration for Strong Employment (RAISE) Act bears strong resemblance to the Jordan commission recommendations and to subsequent legislation that it inspired. Although the Jordan commission did not call for a points system like that proposed in the Cotton-Perdue bill, it did place the same priority on high-skilled immigration.
The Jordan commission's proposed reduction to 535,000 is similar to the projections of how many legal immigrants the RAISE Act would allow annually. In the 1990s, that represented a reduction of about a third. Compared to today's system, it could be a cut by as much as half.
Rep. Lamar Smith (R-Texas), who sponsored legislation based on the Jordan commission and has agreed to sponsor a House version of the RAISE Act, also sees the similarity.
"The knee-jerk Democratic opposition to the RAISE Act does suggest how radicalized the mainstream Left has become on immigration."
"Legal immigration in the U.S. under the RAISE Act would remain among the most generous levels in the world; half a million legal immigrants would be admitted annually, which aligns with the figure recommended by the Jordan commission," he wrote in response to questions posed by a reporter from The Atlantic.
David Cross, a spokesman for Oregonians for Immigration Reform, said Jordan recognized that minorities are disproportionately more likely to face competition from immigrants.
"I think about the issue of black unemployment, particularly black youth unemployment," he said. "I certainly think that's something Barbara Jordan would have been mindful of."
To see how much the immigration debate has changed over the past two decades, it is instructive to review the reaction that the Jordan commission received. The bipartisan commission, itself, endorsed the proposals on legal immigration by an 8-1 vote. The lone dissenter was the executive director of the American Immigration Lawyers Association.
While the RAISE Act has been labeled racist by more than one critic particularly after President Donald Trump endorsed it earlier this month the similar proposals by the Jordan commission met with bipartisan praise. Democratic then-President Bill Clinton endorsed it. Then-Rep.Anthony Beilenson (D-Calif.) said he would co-sponsor legislation based on it.
"Consistent with my own views, the commission's recommendations are pro-family, pro-work, pro-naturalization," Clinton said in June 1995.
That's not to say the recommendations did not draw opposition. Pro-immigration groups called it misguided. Pro-business Republicans such as then-House Majority Leader Richard K. "Dick" Armey (R-Texas) feared it would hurt economic growth.
But few questioned the motives of Jordan or other members of the commission, and critics were not so quick to call it bigoted.
"The knee-jerk Democratic opposition to the RAISE Act does suggest how radicalized the mainstream Left has become on immigration," Law said.
He added: "It seems like it's not the message but the messenger."
Congress did not adopt the Jordan commission's recommendations in whole. Krikorian attributed that, in part, to the former congresswoman's untimely death in 1996 at the age of 59.
"When she died, Clinton was free to do whatever he wanted," he said.
A 'Clever Tactic' to Kill Immigration Reform Then-Sens. Spencer Abraham (R-Mich.) and Ted Kennedy (D-Mass.) maneuvered in the Judiciary Committee to split the proposal into two pieces one on legal immigration and another on illegal immigration.
"It was a clever tactic, quite frankly," Krikorian said.
It helped killed the legal immigration reforms, but even then, the vote on the illegal immigration bill is revealing.
The Illegal Immigration Reform & Immigrant Responsibility Act passed in 1996 with solid Democratic support. In the House, almost as many Democrats 88 voted "yes" as the 92 who voted "no." It divided Senate Democrats, as well, with 22 voting "yes" and 24 voting "no." Liberal stalwarts such as Sens. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif), Tom Daschle (D-S.D.), Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.), and Harry Reid (D-Nev.) supported the bill.
Meanwhile, senators on the floor of the upper chamber voted 80-20 to kill a proposal to reduce immigration by extended relatives of legal residents by at least 10 percent over the ensuing five years. Feinstein offered a similar amendment, but it would have allowed some visas for adult children of legal permanent residents. That failed 74-26.
The House that year killed provisions of the immigration bill that would have cut legal migration by 30 percent after five years and restriction chain migration. The vote was an overwhelming 238 to 183 and included 75 Republicans in the majority. Still, 25 House Democrats sided with the immigration restrictionists.
It seems unlikely that the RAISE Act would attract anywhere close to that level of support from current House Democrats. Law attributed the 1996 vote to the waning vestiges of a Democratic Party primarily concerned with working people in the United States.
"Pretty much since 2013, the Democratic Party totally sold out on immigration," he said. "I would suggest the Democratic Party has been paying lip service to this constituency and taking it for granted."
The Democratic Party of today marches almost in unison in favor of mass immigration and blurs the distinction between legal and illegal migration, Krikorian said. He noted that 2016 Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton and runner-up Bernie Sanders both advocated essentially applying the "wet foot/dry foot" Cold War policy toward Cubans escaping the communist regime to every immigrant anyone who can make it to America can stay (provided he or she does not commit a crime).
That consensus in the party does not appear to have evaporated since the election, although Krikorian pointed to recent articles by progressive writers T.A. Frank in Vanity Fair, Peter Beinart in The Atlantic, and CNN's Fareed Zakaria questioning the party's immigration absolutism.
"Maybe a few people are having second thoughts about the rush to mass immigration," he said.
Read this article:
Not So Long Ago, Democrats Favored Immigration Curbs - LifeZette
- Immigration reform urgently needed to support migrant nurses and prevent exodus, Royal College of Nursing says - Electronic Immigration Network - August 27th, 2024 [August 27th, 2024]
- Former Atty. General John Ashcroft weighs in on immigration reform - The Sentinel - August 27th, 2024 [August 27th, 2024]
- Southern Az Rep. Ciscomani says comprehensive immigration reform not likely in Washington - TucsonSentinel.com - August 27th, 2024 [August 27th, 2024]
- Texas judge suspends Biden immigration reform policy - Avery Journal Times - August 27th, 2024 [August 27th, 2024]
- Century-old U.S. nativism keep immigration reform elusive. We have to stop it - NorthJersey.com - August 20th, 2024 [August 20th, 2024]
- Latino evangelicals push for immigration reform ahead of election - Baptist News Global - August 20th, 2024 [August 20th, 2024]
- Sen. Baldwin talks rural issues, immigration reform at Merrill Dairy Farm - WJFW-TV - August 16th, 2024 [August 16th, 2024]
- Latino Evangelicals Push for Immigration Reform Ahead of Election - The Roys Report - August 16th, 2024 [August 16th, 2024]
- PANEL: Impact of U.S. Immigration Policy on Black Americans - Immigration Blog - July 6th, 2024 [July 6th, 2024]
- Elizabeth Warren talks immigration reform at Kam Man Food in Quincy - AOL - June 8th, 2024 [June 8th, 2024]
- Migrants wait in vain for progress on comprehensive immigration reform Florida Phoenix - Florida Phoenix - June 8th, 2024 [June 8th, 2024]
- Don't expect immigration reform before November, Catholic expert says - Crux Now - June 8th, 2024 [June 8th, 2024]
- A Century of Immigration-Control Failure The Future of Freedom Foundation - The Future of Freedom Foundation - June 8th, 2024 [June 8th, 2024]
- Bipartisan Struggle: The Stalled US Immigration Reform | National World News | bhpioneer.com - Black Hills Pioneer - June 8th, 2024 [June 8th, 2024]
- I navigated a complex immigration system: Pramila Jayapal - The American Bazaar - May 31st, 2024 [May 31st, 2024]
- Byron York: The effect of immigration reform on American workers - Washington Examiner - May 31st, 2024 [May 31st, 2024]
- Rep. Veronica Escobar Approaches Immigration Reform With Hope, Promise, and Unity - AOL - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- WILLIAMS: Secure Our Borders First Before Immigration Reform - NH Journal - March 26th, 2024 [March 26th, 2024]
- Hollywood actress Diane Guerrero advocates for immigration reform - The Daily Titan - March 26th, 2024 [March 26th, 2024]
- Immigration Parole: The Executive Branch's Shadow Immigration System | FAIRUS.org - Federation for American Immigration Reform - March 26th, 2024 [March 26th, 2024]
- FAIR: While Congress Dithers, February Border Encounter Numbers Soar | FAIRUS.org - Federation for American Immigration Reform - March 26th, 2024 [March 26th, 2024]
- BuildForce Canada report gives associations a 'leg to stand on' for immigration reform - Daily Commercial News - March 16th, 2024 [March 16th, 2024]
- Our view: Immigration reform don't bet on it - East Oregonian - March 16th, 2024 [March 16th, 2024]
- How does immigration impact the U.S. economy? - The Fulcrum - March 16th, 2024 [March 16th, 2024]
- Fiasco of Linking Immigration Reform and Foreign Aid Signals Need for Leadership in the Congress - The New York Sun - February 23rd, 2024 [February 23rd, 2024]
- After leading trip to southern border, Central Washington's Dan Newhouse says immigration reform can't wait - The Spokesman Review - February 23rd, 2024 [February 23rd, 2024]
- Immigration reform for Dreamers: The roulette game with DACA needs to end - The Ledger - February 23rd, 2024 [February 23rd, 2024]
- For Biden and Democrats, immigration reform is a wicked policy problem - Berkshire Eagle - February 23rd, 2024 [February 23rd, 2024]
- When It Comes to Immigration Reform, Don't Forget Black Voters - Newsweek - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Video: Opinion | Things Fall Apart: How the Middle Ground on Immigration Collapsed - The New York Times - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Johnson: Now is not the time for comprehensive immigration reform - The Hill - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Immigration reform keeps millions of mixed-status families together - FWD.us - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Sherrill Pushes for Improved Border Security and Comprehensive Immigration Reform, Urges House Speaker to Take ... - Mikie Sherrill - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- U.S. Supreme Court says Texas can't block federal agents from the border - The Texas Tribune - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Immigration reform strikes out with House Republicans - The Week - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Opinion | Making Changes to U.S. Immigration Policy - The New York Times - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Growing Michigan Together's report highlights licensing and immigration reform - Mackinac Center for Public Policy - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Johnston, Bennet and Hickenlooper urge immigration reform | Colorado In DC - coloradopolitics.com - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Polis, 8 other Dem governors call on Biden, Congress to act on immigration - RealVail - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Vocal advocate for immigration reform Bishop Mario E. Dorsonville of Houma-Thibodaux dies unexpectedly at 63 - The Dialog - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Senators Tell House Republicans To Take It or Leave It on Immigration Reform and Border Security - The New York Sun - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Outgoing Silicon Valley lawmaker says big tech needs immigration reform - POLITICO - December 27th, 2023 [December 27th, 2023]
- Immigration Reform: An Awakening Or Political Reality? - InsiderNJ - December 27th, 2023 [December 27th, 2023]
- Gavin Newsom Wants Fox News Viewers to Hear Him Out - The New York Times - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- It will take a Republican to solve America's immigration issues ... - Baltimore Sun - November 26th, 2023 [November 26th, 2023]
- Why pairing border security in place of aid for Ukraine isn't so easy - KGUN 9 Tucson News - November 26th, 2023 [November 26th, 2023]
- To Beat Trump, Nikki Haley Is Trying to Speak to All Sides of a ... - The New York Times - November 26th, 2023 [November 26th, 2023]
- Shutdown Averted but Congress Leaves the Border in Chaos ... - Federation for American Immigration Reform - November 26th, 2023 [November 26th, 2023]
- ICYMI: Sen. Cramer Op-Ed: Immigration Reform Promotes a Healthy ... - Kevin Cramer - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- Will Border Security Issues Force Congress To Take Action On ... - AgFax - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- French Senate Toughens Immigration Bill The European Conservative - The European Conservative - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- UPDATE: UC needs more time to study potential hiring of ... - EdSource - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- Biden Admin. Admits Its 'Asylum Officer Rule' Will Further Impoverish ... - Immigration Blog - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- FAIR: Congress Prepares to Fund the Border Crisis Into 2024 While ... - PR Newswire - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- OPINION: To solve teacher shortages, lets open pathways for ... - The Hechinger Report - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- Hochul says NY will not give state work permits to migrants: 'I'm ... - New York Daily News - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- FBI Director Wray says border gotaways a source of 'great concern' for agency - Yahoo News - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- John Lewis: Courage, Activism, and the Pursuit of Equality - InDepthNH.org - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand to vote in favor of stopgap funding bill to ... - The Daily Gazette - November 17th, 2023 [November 17th, 2023]
- Vasquez unveils package of border security and immigration reform ... - Santa Fe New Mexican - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Utah advocacy group rallies for immigration reform - KSL.com - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Israel war, border security are top 2 threats facing the US - WPTV News Channel 5 West Palm - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- The History of the U.S.-Mexico Border Wall | TIME - TIME - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Migrant crisis stresses services in South Coast - The New Bedford Light - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Letters editor must have fun | Letters to the Editor | chronicleonline.com - Citrus County Chronicle - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Capito says additional funding on immigration issues needs to focus ... - West Virginia MetroNews - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Sisters of Charity, BVM Celebrates 190 Years From Dublin to ... - Global Sisters Report - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Americans Concerned Mideast Terrorism Could Spill into the United ... - Immigration Blog - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Why right-wingers think a uniparty controls Congress - Vox.com - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Capito: Election of New House Speaker 'Welcome News' - Wheeling Intelligencer - November 1st, 2023 [November 1st, 2023]
- Examining The State of Immigration Reform and the Nation's Asylum ... - InsiderNJ - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]
- Opinion | The Cost of Inaction on Immigration - The New York Times - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]
- Why Can't We Stop Unauthorized Immigration? Because It Works. - The New York Times - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]
- Confessions of a birthright citizen - Wisconsin Examiner - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]
- Schumer, Jeffries are laying low on the migrant crisis. Here's why. - POLITICO - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]
- Op-ed: Biden should give immigrants the dignity of a work permit - Chicago Tribune - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]
- Growing Haitian immigrant community in Springfield faces ... - Dayton Daily News - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]
- Republicans should impeach the migrant crisis, not the president - The Michigan Daily - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]
- LEE HAMILTON: Why even popular legislation gets hung up in ... - Crow River Media - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]
- Reps. Glenn 'GT' Thompson and Dan Meuser voted to keep ... - Lock Haven Express - October 11th, 2023 [October 11th, 2023]