Liberal thinktank submission on class actions labelled ‘an undergraduate essay that would fail’ – The Guardian
A government-ordered inquiry into the funding of legal class actions descended into acrimony on its first day of hearings when the first witness from a Liberal party thinktank was accused of misquoting a federal judge and citing unreliable figures.
James Mathias, the chief of staff at the Menzies Research Centre (MRC) and a former Liberal candidate for federal parliament, sought to defend his submission during tense exchanges with the Labor senator, Deborah ONeill, who described it as an undergraduate essay that would fail on multiple grounds.
Mathias appeared on Monday before a parliamentary committee investigating whether Australias class action industry needs tighter regulation to ensure fair and equitable outcomes for plaintiffs with the government raising concerns about the role of large companies that sometimes fund class actions.
Labor has claimed the inquiry is a sham set up by the Liberals to deny hardworking Australians any chance of defending their rights against large companies and governments with virtually limitless resources.
The first line of the submission from the MRC the Liberal party thinktank quoted the federal court justice Michael Lee as saying in a judgment on 5 June: The phrase access to justice is often misused by litigation funders to justify what at bottom is a commercial endeavour to make money out of the conduct of litigation.
It was purportedly from a judgment on class actions stemming from allegations that the Australian defence department negligently allowed toxic chemicals known as Pfas to escape from defence bases and contaminate local environments.
But Mathias, who was just 21 when he ran as a federal candidate for the Victorian seat of Holt in 2016, confirmed under questioning he had not read the full judgment cited in the submission as judgments are very long some hundreds of pages.
ONeill said the judgment was actually 37 pages long and the words you quote in the very first line of your submission are nowhere, nowhere to be found in his honours judgment.
The NSW senator said the only place that quote could be found was in an article in the legal journal Lawyerly on 9 June, titled A significant inequality of arms: Funding led to better outcomes in PFAS class action, judge says.
Mathias took that question on notice. But when ONeill accused him of misquoting and taking Justice Lee completely out of context in an attempt to convey the false impression that Justice Lee is opposed to litigation funding, Mathias said: I fundamentally reject the premise of that, senator.
In Lees judgment of 5 June, the judge made a more qualified statement that the term access to justice is commonly misused, most often by some funders who fasten upon it as an inapt rhetorical device.
He then cautioned against generalisations. While noting litigation funding is about putting in place a joint commercial enterprise aimed at making money, Lee went on to say that recognising that reality does not diminish the importance of litigation funding in allowing these class members to vindicate their claims against the commonwealth.
Referring to the alleged victims in the Pfas class actions, Lee continued: Without litigation funding, the claims of these group members would not have been litigated in an adversarial way but, rather, they would likely have been placed in the position of being supplicants requesting compensation, in circumstances where they would have been the subject of a significant inequality of arms.
ONeill also challenged Mathias over the claim in his submission that by 2019, the average amount paid to plaintiffs had fallen to just 39% of the settlement proceeds a figure that has since been quoted in several news reports..
He said it was based on a presentation contained within a PowerPoint of analysis by the law firm Herbert Smith Freehills.
In later proceedings, Andrew Saker, the managing director of litigation funder Omni Bridgeway, said he believed the 39% figure was based on incomplete data.
Saker said Herbert Smith Freehills had informed his company that the figure had been included in a PowerPoint slide for continuing legal education, it related only to settlement approvals determined by the courts, and it was not authorised for outside use.
Earlier, Mathias said he was not arguing against class actions, but for reform to ensure they remained a vehicle for justice.
We find ourselves in an environment where damages awarded to plaintiffs who have been most wronged is declining, and if you care about access to justice then you would care about the percentages that have been paid out to these people, he said during a hearing conducted via videolink.
James Paterson, the Liberal chair of the parliamentary joint committee on corporations and financial services, repeatedly asked ONeill not to interrupt or reflect on witnesses with the protection of parliamentary privilege.
ONeill told the chair she was happy to discuss the issue offline but I dont want to be berated as a senator of the Australian public by you in front of the media.
Weve got an undergraduate essay that would fail on plagiarism and [is] incorrect, put to us by the Menzies Research Centre - its just not up to standard, she said.
When Mathias attempted to ask his own question of ONeill, she shot back: When you become another young senator for the Liberal party you might be able ask me questions, but at the moment you dont have that opportunity.
When contacted for a response to the criticism of his submission, Mathias said it was astonishing that the Guardian would be siding with foreign backed, super-profitable litigation funders just because it does not like the politics of the MRC
But the shadow attorney general, Mark Dreyfus, said the Liberal party had been humiliated at the first day of its class actions inquiry.
When setting up the inquiry in May, the attorney general, Christian Porter, cited growing concern that the lack of regulation governing the booming litigation funding industry is leading to poor justice outcomes for those who join class actions, expecting to get fair compensation for an injury or loss.
Originally posted here:
Liberal thinktank submission on class actions labelled 'an undergraduate essay that would fail' - The Guardian
- Opinion | How liberals in red states are working around conservative politicians - The Washington Post - October 11th, 2024 [October 11th, 2024]
- Liberals, Conservatives trade accusations of political gamesmanship on Oct. 7 anniversary - The Globe and Mail - October 11th, 2024 [October 11th, 2024]
- EDITORIAL: Liberals and their carbon tax follies - Toronto Sun - October 11th, 2024 [October 11th, 2024]
- GUNTER: Liberals blind to failure of their lax bail and parole reforms - Toronto Sun - October 11th, 2024 [October 11th, 2024]
- Liberals refusal, oppositions demands over documents for spending scandal has created a government backlog - The Globe and Mail - October 11th, 2024 [October 11th, 2024]
- 'I hope so': Marc Garneau on whether there's room for Blue Liberals like him - CTV News - October 11th, 2024 [October 11th, 2024]
- FIRST READING: Could the Liberals unintentionally vote down their own government? - National Post - October 4th, 2024 [October 4th, 2024]
- Opinion: Are the federal Liberals facing an extinction event? - TVO Today - October 4th, 2024 [October 4th, 2024]
- The Breakdown | Liberals reject the Blocs ultimatum. What now? - CBC.ca - October 4th, 2024 [October 4th, 2024]
- Liberals surge as Grassroots loses Presidency for the first time in five years: 2024 SRC Election wrap up - Honi Soit - October 4th, 2024 [October 4th, 2024]
- The Numbers: Are the Liberals now in third place? - The Writ - October 4th, 2024 [October 4th, 2024]
- Will Liberals boost payments to seniors, as Bloc demands, or risk an early election? - CBC.ca - October 4th, 2024 [October 4th, 2024]
- Election wins have been elusive for the Canberra Liberals but Elizabeth Lee hopes to succeed with big ticket items - ABC News - October 4th, 2024 [October 4th, 2024]
- 'Dream scenario' for Poilievre as Conservatives open up 20-point lead with NDP, Liberals tied - CTV News - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- The Liberals keep misfiring on gun control - The Globe and Mail - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Bloc gives Liberals 'a few days' to avoid early election by increasing OAS for all seniors - National Post - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Trump Rages at Fox News for Constantly Inviting Unfair Liberals On Air - The Daily Beast - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Letter to the editor: How Adams became liberals target - Washington Times - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Kinzinger Coming to Campus: a Liberals Thoughts - The Decaturian - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Opinion: The Blocs ransom demands are terrible. The Liberals should tell them to kick rocks - The Globe and Mail - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- PCs, Liberals are only parties to run full slate of election candidates - CBC.ca - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Liberals tap Mark Carney to ring fundraising bell for partys next election campaign - The Globe and Mail - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Deeming-Pesutto defamation trial hears another secret recording of meeting with senior Liberals - ABC News - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Opinion: Brighter signs on affordability just as Liberals run out of time - The Globe and Mail - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Liberals poised to vote against Bloc motion to increase old age pension payments for all seniors - MSN - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Belgian liberals give Francis a tough day at the office - Catholic Herald Online - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Adam Zivo: Liberals and NDP have no time for your daughter's tragic opioid story - National Post - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Taxes, forestry on the agenda for Liberals and Greens on Friday - CBC.ca - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Justin Ling: I cant help it if politicians are weak: How the Liberals fumbled Canadas most effective climate plan - Toronto Star - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- GUNTER: There's no limit to Trudeau Liberals' sanctimony - Toronto Sun - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Liberals survive first confidence vote after the end of governance agreement with NDP - CBC News - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- By the numbers: Here's what it would take to bring down the Liberals in a confidence vote - CBC News - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- John Ivison: They're desperate, but Liberals would still be fools to obey the Bloc - National Post - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Opinion: Everyone is running against Trudeau except Liberals who are running away - The Globe and Mail - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Canberra Liberals endure week of unwelcome distractions with candidates current and former causing headaches for Elizabeth Lee - ABC News - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Conservatives and liberals have different brain structures heres how - New York Post - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- CAQ's identity politics have created a disaster in English universities, Liberals say - Montreal Gazette - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Conservatives and liberals have slightly different brain structures, scientists discover - Study Finds - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Geoff Russ: The Liberals are being consumed by the diaspora politics they nurtured - National Post - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- This party is spent: The Hub Roundtable on the sagging Liberals, surging Conservatives, and new mortgage rules - The Hub - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Quebec Liberals already have candidate for Terrebonne byelection - Montreal Gazette - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Momentum at Ontario Liberals' meeting in London can help the party gain traction, analysts say - CBC.ca - September 21st, 2024 [September 21st, 2024]
- Opinion: The Liberals would do better if they replace their dead man walking - The Globe and Mail - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Braid: Byelection losses show Trudeau and the Liberals are courting extinction in general election - Calgary Herald - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Time to Give Idaho Liberals the Paddling They Need - News Radio 1310 KLIX - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Why old-school liberals like Bill Maher are often at odds with the Democratic Party - Deseret News - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- FIRST READING: Some numbers on just how badly the Liberals did in Monday's byelections - National Post - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- The Liberals can't win a general election if they keep losing safe seats - CBC News - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Opinion: Its beginning to look a lot like 2011 for the Liberals - The Globe and Mail - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Draghis report is a wake-up call for the EU the Liberals say - European Interest - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Opinion: Immigration holds up the clearest sign yet that the Liberals have all but given up on governing - The Globe and Mail - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- EDITORIAL: Liberals out of gas and out of ideas - Toronto Sun - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- By-election tests: The NDP passed. The Liberals failed. - The Globe and Mail - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- John Ivison: Liberals are already acting like the unofficial opposition to Pierre Poilievre - National Post - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Chief Justice John Roberts Is Not The Man Liberals Want Him To Be - Above the Law - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Justin Trudeau pledges to forge ahead after Liberals lose another fortress riding - The Globe and Mail - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Trudeau says Liberals have 'a lot of work to do' after his party loses another byelection - CBC News - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Opinion: By-election win confirms the Blocs staying power as the Liberals implode in Quebec - The Globe and Mail - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Liberals Are Finding New Ways To Undermine The Right To Strike - The Maple - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Weekly Writ 9/18: Bad byelections for the Liberals, again - The Writ - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Opinion: With the Liberals losing once-safe seats, an election cant be far off - The Globe and Mail - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Canberra Liberals release housing plan ahead of ACT election, with proposal to develop Kowen Forest into thousands of homes - ABC News - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Matt Gurney: Byelection results dont just signal the Liberals will lose the next election. They signal a wipeout - Toronto Star - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- LILLEY UNLEASHED: Trudeau Liberals are fighting with Elon Muskfor some reason - Toronto Sun - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Vance says big difference between conservatives and liberals is that no one has tried to kill Kamala Harris - MSN - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Terry Newman: There are no more safe spaces for Trudeaus Liberals Montreal byelection loss proves it - National Post - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Liberals face race against the clock to pass dozens of bills as Parliament returns - The Globe and Mail - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Framing Climate Action as Patriotic and Status-Quo Friendly Increases Liberals and Conservatives Belief in Climate Change - NYU - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Opinion: Its not just Trudeau: The Liberals days as the natural governing party are done - The Globe and Mail - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Voter wants to remind people that liberals can also be patriots - The Keystone - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- The hard truth the Trudeau Liberals need to hear from Mark Carney - The Globe and Mail - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Althia Raj: Justin Trudeau unleashed is the Liberals new weapon in their battle with Pierre Poilievre - Toronto Star - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Cabinet minister tells Liberals to 'change their attitude' as MPs return to Commons - MSN - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Im not going anywhere: Justin Trudeau says he wont resign if Liberals lose Montreal byelection - Toronto Star - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Opinion: After the deal: the NDP is exposed and the Liberals are stuck - The Globe and Mail - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- 'Deceitful' Liberals dodging Carney ethics oversight with party appointment, Conservatives say - National Post - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- How safe are the Liberals in LaSalleEmardVerdun? Voters weigh in ahead of Monday vote - CTV News Montreal - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- GUNTER: Alberta shouldn't have to bear the burden of Liberals failed immigration policy - Edmonton Sun - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- Leading business groups ask Liberals to send Air Canada pilot dispute to binding arbitration - CBC News - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]
- LILLEY: Trudeau's Liberals the only ones left defending CBC - Toronto Sun - September 14th, 2024 [September 14th, 2024]