Some Liberals Are Warming Up To The Idea Of Hindu Rashtra Over Nehruvian Secularism, Whats The Catch? – Swarajya
An article in the Indian Express, written by the Vice-Chancellor of NALSAR University, Hyderabad, Faizan Mustafa states that the Indian minorities are too fed up of the facade of secularism.
Mustafa argues that if Indians are done with the Nehruvian model of secularism (without pointing out its flaws), they should declare the country a Hindu rashtra, giving Hinduism the status of the dominant spiritual heritage.
He is right in saying that the Hindu rashtra will not be entirely different from the current secular state, because it is not in Hinduisms character to do what Pakistan or other Islamic countries do to religious minorities.
We also agree with him that a Hindu rashtra must bring with it genuine liberalism.
However, there is a catch, and those who are not well-prepared, will be left bewildered by Mustafas proposal.
One, its an ultimatum to intellectuals to work hard to save the Left-Islamist marriage
The proposal is a warning to the Left compatriots that unless they get a grip of the narrative and strike the enemy harder, the regressive Left-Islamist marriage is in trouble.
It signals that the Muslims intellectuals are keeping the option open, instead, to negotiate with more benign right-wing elements.
Two, it is a veiled threat imperial forces are too powerful to be pushed out of the game
The message is that we can change things on paper as much as we want, but the functioning of the Christian and Islamic imperial structures in India will remain intact.
The reason simply is that they already function with minimal dependence on other communities or indigenous political, social and economic structures. In a globalised world, they hold an organisational, political and financial clout that the Hindus can hardly match.
It is important to recognise that these imperial forces have a utilitarian approach towards the Left.
Indian Left exists thanks to the the alliance with imperial forces, not the other way around.
Left is quite expendable for the imperialists. Its only utility comes from the hegemony in the intellectual ecosystem.
If that comes under threat, the imperial forces can also directly negotiate with the non-Left forces to come to a new arrangement where they are, as before, left alone to work, just, say, at a higher price.
Even the political parties vilified as saffron have shown eagerness to maintain a functioning partnership with the Christian and Islamic supremacist forces.
The tallest Christian cross coming up in Mizoram, illegal church construction on Sattra land in Majuli, Assam, the Tablighi Jamaat-Covid-19 fiasco, and the (lack of) reaction to the recent mob lynching of two saffron-clad sadhus in the Christian missionary hotbed Palghar, Maharashtra are but a few examples.
Given the ideological straitjacket, even in the case where the right wing becomes the new ally of the imperial forces, the Left can only push the narrative of "Hindu fascism as it does now.
In fact, a Hindu rashtra will offer an unprecedented convenience to imperial forces a complacent right-wing and an ineffective Left.
Three, it assumes right wing cant achieve anything beyond winning a few elections
Mustafa seems to be banking on the assumption that a lot of left-wing intellectuals have that the Indian right wing simply doesnt have a coherent constructive ideology or strategy beyond criticising Congress and the Left. It can change the name, but it has no alternative to Nehruvian secularism in practice.
The Left has always assumed that the emergence of a political Hindu is impossible due to the internal contradictions of the Hindu society.
Not that the Left cant see that there is real anger among Hindus based on genuine grievances, but it is sure that given the lack of intellectual leadership, it will never be channelised into anything concrete.
The Left-wing intellectuals themselves proudly proclaim that there are almost no right wing intellectuals in India. So the best the right-wing can do is win some elections, but in the intellectual domain, it will always remain on the fringe.
That means, while some ad hoc innocuous measures like CAA can crop up here and there, the right-wing wont ever have any real, long term productive power.
It also means that the right-wing movement will be limited to one political party all eggs in one basket; and right-wingers will never amount to anything more than IT cell and bhakts.
Fourth, the surety that a Hindu rashtra will fail and its failure will sound death the knell of the Hindu movement
The proposal also has an underlying sadism if India becomes a Hindu rashtra, it will only end up the way Nazi Germany did beaten, disgraced and untouchable.
The Germans were rescued by their fellow white men but the guilt of a failed Hindu rashtra would be so immense that the Hindus won't dare become political again, and retire to a permanent passiveness.
It would sound the death knell of the Hindu culture and philosophy that survived centuries of persecution.
The same fear is visible in the older generation of the right-wing intellectuals who, as a result, restrained the movement tightly.
The likes of Arun Shourie did a great job exposing the left cabal but always maintained a suspicion of the right-wing politics.
All the four points discussed above pose substantial challenge for the right-wing, and must be taken seriously.
The movement definitely has a long way to go, be it organising and educating the masses in Indic politics, or having a voice loud-enough to penetrate the intellectual ivory towers.
However, at the same time, the recent trends suggest that the days of Hindu movement being defined by the Left are over.
One, a Hindu political being is already here
The Left banking on the internal contradictions of Hindu society for divide and rule hasnt noticed that pan-Hindu unity and a Hindu political being is already on the scene.
Research shows that contrary to the claims that it is an upper-caste party, the BJPs social base is now broad-based and mirrors the Hindu society.
The shift of the poor, rural and lower caste voters to BJP is ideological, and those who identify with BJP arent swayed by short-term considerations.
This shouldnt come as a surprise to intellectuals. It is a logical outcome of the path our political and intellectual leaders took and the choices they made after independence.
Also read: New Research, Old Findings: Rural, Poor And Lower Caste Voters Are Behind Phenomenal Rise Of BJP
Two, Intellectuals can exist outside the ecosystem
Imperialists-financed incentive structure means the Left dominates the knowledge ecosystem, and attracts more career-minded ambitious folks.
But the humanities and social sciences arent such specialised disciplines that the people not trained in them for years cannot penetrate.
.As much expertise the intellectuals like to credit to themselves, its not very hard to master the English language and explain things in it.
The Hindu movement does not have to depend on the mercy of the ecosystem for intellectual leadership.
Three, young right-wingers today are very different from the older generation
The Left incentive structure is controlled by a few oldies at the top. While this means better organisation, it also means lesser intelligence and flexibility to respond to changes on ground.
On the other hand, right-wing isnt as organised, but is filled with and driven by young minds.
These young people born post-liberalisation can imagine a life without a maai-baap state. They dont toe the line that the Left has set for them by marking no go zones with the labels of fascism, bhakt, troll, saffron etc.
The Left has so far managed Indians by fear and intimidation.
But young Indians today think for themselves, fiercely protect their autonomy and dont cow-down to moral shaming.
Unlike the older generation of right-wing intellectuals, they are neither reluctant nor ashamed to assert own existence with full force.
Sure, they are a little rough around the edges, but its a minor problem that can be solved by little guidance.
Four, Hindus arent clueless fanatics. They know what they are fighting, and what is it that they want
The Left threatens Indians into submitting to the imperial forces lest multiple identities regarding caste, language, region pull apart the nation.
Too bad it cannot see that hundreds of right-wing groups with young people from a variety of backgrounds are a continuing experiment of respectful co-existence which is neither marred by Lefts victimology-driven over-sensitivity, nor oppressive caste hierarchy or cowbelt dominance.
Mustafa says Hindutva fanatics will be hugely disappointed to know that the Hindu rashtra will not be entirely different from the current secular state.
Professor Mustafa will be disappointed to know that that the Hindus are no more fooled by a superficial change, like that of the Nehru surname to Gandhi.
What Hindus are demanding is a rigorous evaluation of the past crimes against them, the ideas that propelled it, and breaking the structures that continue to push the same ideas. Fight is not against certain groups, but certain ideas.
For the sake of brevity, we wont go in the details of what Indic thought is, and how the Indic movement is tackling the long-term challenges of caste discrimination, communalism, etc.
Suffice to say that both the diagnoses and solutions are more accurate and effective than the Lefts oppressor-oppressed binary.
Five, the current Hindu movement has same creative power as the Indian National Movement
In the real-world outside Leftist fantasies, the right-wing is not composed of just some street-level clueless fanatics. It is not an aberration of history, a high tide that is destined to go down.
The aberration in Indian history is the hegemony of Left in independent India that, in alliance with global capitalists and imperialists, made the legacy of the freedom movement stand on its head.
Also read: Indian Lefts Fall From Grace: Those Who Criticised Global Capitalism Are Now Taking Orders From Foreign Masters
Its time to bring out Gandhi, Bose, Tagore and others mummified and neatly arranged in the museum of Indian Left; breathe a new life into their ideas, and build upon the foundation laid by them.
The current Indic movement situates itself as a successor of the Indian national movement. Its a river that slowly but steadily cuts its way.
It is the continuation of the fight for the ideals of the freedom fighters, be it Tagores atmasakti; Ghoshs reawakening of Indias ancient spirit ; Vivekanandas idea of service, Ambedkars organise, Tilaks swaraj, Boses India is calling or Gandhis Ram Rajya.
Continue reading here:
Some Liberals Are Warming Up To The Idea Of Hindu Rashtra Over Nehruvian Secularism, Whats The Catch? - Swarajya
- Ben Shapiro loves trolling liberals. Republicans are putting that to use. - POLITICO - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- Conservatives and Liberals Are Fighting Over Who Gets Monty Python Better - Cracked.com - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- NDP to have 'tough conversations' about its deal with Liberals at coming retreat: MP - Yahoo News Canada - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- Poor conservatives and wealthy liberals overestimate wealth of their neighborhoods - PsyPost - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- NDP to have 'tough conversations' about its deal with Liberals at coming retreat: MP - CBC News - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- A dark day for Germany is a dark day for Europe: liberals react to far right success in German state election as it happened - The Guardian - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- How BC United (formerly the B.C. Liberals) collapsed and what could happen next - National Post - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- Robert Libman: Poll holds hidden hope for Quebec Liberals if they find the right leader - Montreal Gazette - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- N.S. Liberals say they would make transit free if elected - CityNews Halifax - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- NDP to have 'tough conversations' about its deal with Liberals at coming retreat: MP - CP24 - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- NDP to have tough conversations about its deal with Liberals at coming retreat: MP - Toronto Star - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- The biggest tests are yet to come for NSW Liberals after a shambolic few weeks - ABC News - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- The Liberals are losing and the clock is running out. Its time to pull their goalie - Toronto Star - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- NDP to have 'tough conversations' about its deal with Liberals at coming retreat: MP - CTV News - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- Poilievre urges Singh to pull out of deal with Liberals and trigger fall election - National Post - September 3rd, 2024 [September 3rd, 2024]
- Fred DeLorey: Do the Liberals care about environmental stewardship or just trendy climate issues? The Jasper disaster provides a damning answer - The... - August 9th, 2024 [August 9th, 2024]
- From sunny ways to cloudy days: Canadians have tired of Justin Trudeau - The Washington Post - July 26th, 2024 [July 26th, 2024]
- When Liberal promises meet fiscal reality - The Globe and Mail - July 26th, 2024 [July 26th, 2024]
- Hillbilly Elegy and J.D. Vances art of having it both ways - The Washington Post - July 26th, 2024 [July 26th, 2024]
- Secularists revealed as a unique political force in America, with an intriguing divergence from liberals - PsyPost - July 26th, 2024 [July 26th, 2024]
- Kamala Harris instantly ignited the Democrats. Will a leadership change do the same for the federal Liberals? - Toronto Star - July 26th, 2024 [July 26th, 2024]
- Supreme Court Reform is Code for Putting More Liberals on the Bench - Daily Citizen - July 26th, 2024 [July 26th, 2024]
- With Calls To Expand Supreme Court, Liberals Hope To Skirt the Rules | Opinion - Newsweek - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Opinion: What Liberals and Conservatives can learn from the French and British elections - The Globe and Mail - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Michael Bonner: Defenders of the liberal faith feel the fire - The Hub - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Liberal outlook plus other letters, July 10: For Justin Trudeau, he would do well to remember there is no I in team - The Globe and Mail - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Woke policies fall flat as NY suburban Dems fight to take back party in blow to activist liberals - New York Post - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Conservative Behind Trump Agenda Issues Cryptic Threat to Liberals - The New Republic - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- A Liberal attack line on dental care that has no bite - The Globe and Mail - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Hollywoods Rob Reiner Tweets Biden Should Step Down and Liberals Lose Their Minds - The New York Sun - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- The Formation Of The Anti-Liberal Alliance But Liberal Is Not A Synonym Of Woke - Middle East Media Research Institute - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Colleges robbing liberal students by having their views go unchallenged, says Princeton prof - The Lion - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- LaSallemardVerdun: The Liberals' next test - The Writ - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Liberalism and the Wests Crisis of Meaning - Quillette - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Opinion: When Liberals talk about Poilievre, Trudeau drowns out the sound - The Globe and Mail - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Liberal Media Scream: Welker pushes Meet the Press even further left - Washington Examiner - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Liberals overestimated GDP defence spending projection in 2024 budget: PBO - True North - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Letters to the editor: The Liberals and NDP should swallow their pride and amalgamate. Election lessons from France and Britain, plus other letters to... - July 10th, 2024 [July 10th, 2024]
- Europe's liberals flip-flop on the far right - POLITICO Europe - June 22nd, 2024 [June 22nd, 2024]
- What would a Reform surge do to Labour and the Liberal Democrats? Two scenarios mapped - The Conversation - June 22nd, 2024 [June 22nd, 2024]
- What does the future hold for the liberals in the European Parliament? - Euronews - June 22nd, 2024 [June 22nd, 2024]
- Liberalism's Natural Disadvantageand How to Overcome It - The New Republic - June 22nd, 2024 [June 22nd, 2024]
- A byelection to watch: What the Toronto-St. Paul's vote means for Justin Trudeau - The Conversation - June 22nd, 2024 [June 22nd, 2024]
- Federal Liberals urgently need to shift terrain with bold ideas - Canada's National Observer - June 22nd, 2024 [June 22nd, 2024]
- Nuclear won't be a voter turn off in cities: Liberals - The New Daily - June 22nd, 2024 [June 22nd, 2024]
- Justin is the perfect leader of the Justin Party Winnipeg Free Press - Winnipeg Free Press - June 22nd, 2024 [June 22nd, 2024]
- Opinion | What Have We Liberals Done to the West Coast? - The New York Times - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- Opinion | Whats Stopping Liberals From Having Kids? - The New York Times - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- Column: Secret audio of Alito isn't the smoking gun liberals think - The Virginian-Pilot - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- Antarctic Jobs Threatened by Liberals' Delivery Failure - Mirage News - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- Commentary: Slinging 'liberal' in 5th District GOP primary - Richmond Times-Dispatch - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- Laura Yuen: It's time for regular Americans (liberals included) to reclaim the US flag - The Pantagraph - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- Liberals Shouldn't Give Up On 'Law and Order' - The Bulwark - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- What went wrong for the EU election-losing Greens and Liberals? - Euronews - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- NOAH FELDMAN: Secret audio of Alito isn't the smoking gun liberals think - Indiana Gazette - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- Opinion: Poilievre wriggles out of the Liberal trap, with a commitment to much broader tax reform - The Globe and Mail - June 16th, 2024 [June 16th, 2024]
- Opinion | The Happiness Gap Between Left and Right Isn't Closing - The New York Times - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Columbia protests: I read the university president's old memoir-manifesto. Yikes. - Slate - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Opinion: Poilievre to business: stop sucking up to Liberals and start sucking up to me - The Globe and Mail - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Grocery giants paid for friendly Liberal, Tory policy with decades of donations The Breach - The Breach - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Opinion: The Liberals' delays on foreign interference carry profound costs - The Globe and Mail - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Gaza is the greatest test liberalism has faced since 1945. And it is failing - Middle East Eye - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- NDP leader slams Liberals for giving nearly $26M to Costco, Loblaw in recent years - Yahoo News Canada - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- NDP leader slams Liberals for giving nearly $26-million to Costco, Loblaw in recent years - The Globe and Mail - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Evening Update: Liberals unveil foreign interference registry - The Globe and Mail - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Columbia crisis: Another massive failure of liberalism - Salon - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- MAGA is obsessed with Viktor Orban; liberals should be, too - - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Opinion | Justin Trudeau May Be No Match for the New World of Polarization - The New York Times - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Only 6% of vaccine injury claimants have been paid as Liberals earmark $36 million for program - True North - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- PC opposition blasts Liberals over handling of mental health and drug crisis - Yahoo News Canada - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Globe editorial: The Liberals' capital-gains tax hike punishes prosperity - The Globe and Mail - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Opinion: For the good of the Liberal party, Trudeau needs to think about his future - The Globe and Mail - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- 'Sopranos' Actress Says People In Hollywood Are Too 'Petrified' To Cross Liberals On Social Issues - The Daily Wire - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Liberals' plan to destroy super will drive up house prices - The New Daily - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Opinion: The foreign interference inquiry features a parade of senior Liberals protesting too much - The Globe and Mail - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- How liberals killed Earth Day - Washington Times - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- The Weekly Wrap: The Liberals lean all the way into class warfare - The Hub - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Liberals Are Trying to Make Trump's Age an Issue. It Won't Work. - The New Republic - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Letter | Liberal tribalism led to downfall of phonics - The Capital Times - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Quebec Liberals will choose new leader during convention in June 2025 - Yahoo News Canada - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]