Trump v. United States Opines On Whether The Vice President Is a Legislative Officer – Reason
In February, 2023, former Vice President Mike Pence invoked the Speech or Debate Clause to challenge a subpoena from the Special Counsel. I explained that, as a matter of text, this argument didn't fly. The Speech or Debate refers to "Senators and Representatives." The Vice President is the President of the Senate, but is not a Senator. However, there are a string of precedents which could support a more functional reading of the Speech of Debate Clause. And, in June 2023, Judge Boasbergfound that Vice President Pence received some protections under the Speech or Debate Clause for his role on January 6. I did not find that decision persuasive as a textual matter, but there is some precedent on point that the court followed.
Part III-B-2 ofTrump v. United Statesreminded me of Pence's case. Here, Chief Justice Roberts discussed whether President Trump's communications with Vice President Pence leading up to, and during, January 6, would be immune from prosecution.
To be sure, the President has an interest in legislation that is being considered in the Senate. And, as President of the Senate, the Vice President plays a unique role in that process. If the Senate is evenly divided, the Vice President can cast a tie-breaking vote. Chief Justice Roberts explains that with respect to legislation, the President has an important role in having communications with the Vice President. These communications would be presumptively immune from any congressional regulations:
[O]ur constitutional system anticipates that the President and Vice President will remain in close contact regarding their official duties over the course of the President's term in office. These two officials are the only ones "elected by the entire Nation." Seila Law; see Art. II, 1. . . . And Article I of course names the Vice President as President of the Senate and gives him a tiebreaking vote. 3, cl. 4. It is thus important for the President to discuss official matters with the Vice President to ensure continuity within the Executive Branch and to advance the President's agenda in Congress and beyond. The Vice President may in practice also serve as one of the President's closest advisers.
I think that argument is correct when discussing legislative sessions. But does it work with regard to the joint session? The Constitution assigns the President of the Senate particular functions during the joint session of Congress. Roberts acknowledges that the President does not have a role in that process:
The question then becomes whether that presumption of immunity is rebutted under the circumstances. When the Vice President presides over the January 6 certification proceeding, he does so in his capacity as President of the Senate. . . . Ibid. Despite the Vice President's expansive role of advising and assisting the President within the Executive Branch, the Vice President's Article I responsibility of "presiding over the Senate" is "not an 'executive branch' function." Memorandum from L. Silberman, Deputy Atty. Gen., to R. Burress, Office of the President, Re: Conflict of Interest Problems Arising Out of the President's Nomination of Nelson A. Rockefeller To Be Vice President Under the Twenty-Fifth Amendment to the Constitution 2 (Aug. 28, 1974). With respect to the certification proceeding in particular, Congress has legislated extensively to define the Vice President's role in the counting of the electoral votes, see, e.g., 3 U. S. C. 15, and the President plays no direct constitutional or statutory role in that process. So the Government may argue that consideration of the President's communications with the Vice President concerning the certification proceeding does not pose "dangers of intrusion on the authority and functions of the Executive Branch." Fitzgerald.
Yet Roberts signals that the President's interest in legislation could still extend to the Vice President's role in the joint session:
At the same time, however, the President may frequently rely on the Vice President in his capacity as President of the Senate to advance the President's agenda in Congress. When the Senate is closely divided, for instance, the Vice President's tiebreaking vote may be crucial for confirming the President's nominees and passing laws that align with the President's policies. Applying a criminal prohibition to the President's conversations discussing such matters with the Vice Presidenteven though they concern his role as President of the Senatemay well hinder the President's ability to perform his constitutional functions.
Justice Sotomayor responds in her dissent:
The majority admits that the Vice President's responsibility "'presiding over the Senate' " is "'not an "executive branch" function,'" and it further admits that the President "plays no direct constitutional or statutory role" in the counting of electoral votes. Yet the majority refuses to conclude that Trump lacks immunity for his alleged attempts to "enlist the Vice President to use his ceremonial role at the January 6 certification proceeding to fraudulently alter the election results." Instead, it worries that a prosecution for this conduct might make it harder for the President to use the Vice President "to advance [his] agenda in Congress." Such a prosecution, according to the majority, "may well hinder the President's ability to perform his constitutional functions." Whether a prosecution for this conduct warrants immunity should have been an easy question, but the majority turns it into a debatable one.
If the District Court is correct about the Vice President's role, with regard to the Speech or Debate Clause, I think it would be harder to make the case that the President's discussions with the Vice President about the joint session would not be immune.
Read more here:
Trump v. United States Opines On Whether The Vice President Is a Legislative Officer - Reason
- Mike Pence Reacts to Donald Trump's Decisive Election Win - Newsweek - November 10th, 2024 [November 10th, 2024]
- Mike Pence reacts to Donald Trumps election win after declining to endorse him - KCBD - November 10th, 2024 [November 10th, 2024]
- Jack Smith immunity appendix reveals highlighted pages of Mike Pence book that Jan. 6 prosecutors want to use against Trump - Law & Crime - October 21st, 2024 [October 21st, 2024]
- Mike Pence Is Haunting This Election - The Atlantic - October 21st, 2024 [October 21st, 2024]
- Did Mike Pence endorse Kamala Harris for president? Here's the truth - The Economic Times - October 21st, 2024 [October 21st, 2024]
- So what: Trumps alleged reaction to news that Mike Pence was in danger on Jan 6 - The Independent - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Why former Indiana governor, VP Mike Pence came up in the debate between Walz and Vance - IndyStar - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Days before Trump rioters tried to hang him, Mike Pence was warned he would be in danger - NJ.com - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Trump 'resorted to crimes,' bullied VP Mike Pence in Jan. 6 election interference plot: newly unsealed filing - New York Daily News - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Mike Pence quietly lays the groundwork for a post-Trump future - Semafor - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Mike Pence Delivers Blow To Trump Weeks Ahead of Election - MSN - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Fox contributor Kellyanne Conway attempts to minimize the divide between Donald Trump and Mike Pence - Media Matters for America - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Mike Pence takes extraordinary swipe at Trump in sign that he wants to return to politics - Daily Mail - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Mike Pence Offers Advice to JD Vance - Newsweek - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Mike Pence Offers Advice to JD Vance - MSN - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Shame: National Review Slams Trump-Vance Ticket for Doubling Down on Election Denialism and Slandering Mike Pence - Mediaite - September 19th, 2024 [September 19th, 2024]
- Trump Wants to Hide His Attempt to Assassinate Mike Pence from Voters - Emptywheel - August 31st, 2024 [August 31st, 2024]
- Mike Pence Group Issues Warning to Donald Trump Over RFK. Jr.'Loony Ideas' - Newsweek - August 31st, 2024 [August 31st, 2024]
- 'We're Gonna Pray Right Now': Mike Pence Reveals Immediate Reaction to Learning of Trump Assassination Attempt - CBN.com - August 18th, 2024 [August 18th, 2024]
- Former VP Mike Pence to address Long Island Association business group in October - Newsday - August 16th, 2024 [August 16th, 2024]
- Were Gonna Pray Right Now: Mike Pence Reveals Immediate Reaction to Learning of Trump Assassination Attempt - Faithwire - August 16th, 2024 [August 16th, 2024]
- Buttigieg compares JD Vance to Mike Pence in rebuke of Trump VP pick - The Hill - July 24th, 2024 [July 24th, 2024]
- Mike Pence thanks Biden for stepping out of presidential race: 'The right decision' - KOMO News - July 24th, 2024 [July 24th, 2024]
- The most important story about Trumps VP is why he needs a new one - Media Matters for America - July 12th, 2024 [July 12th, 2024]
- Former Pence adviser blasts Trump trying to distance himself from Project 2025: Ludicrous - Washington Examiner - July 12th, 2024 [July 12th, 2024]
- Pence slams RNC platform changes on abortion - Washington Examiner - July 12th, 2024 [July 12th, 2024]
- Mike Pence warns against pro-life 'surrender' in revised RNC platform - Washington Times - July 12th, 2024 [July 12th, 2024]
- Opinion | Mike Pence: Donald Trump Has Betrayed the Pro-Life Movement - The New York Times - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Mike Pence: Russian aggression poses 'serious threat' to Europe - Euronews - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Mike Pence: US will continue to support Ukraine - Euronews - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Mike Johnson, Like Pence, Does What Passes for Brave in Todays GOP: His Job - The New York Times - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Brian Howey: Trumps Hoosiers passing on a second term - Daily Journal - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Former Trump officials are among the most vocal opponents of returning him to the White House - Yoursun.com - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Ex-Trump lawyer and former law school dean who suggested Mike Pence interfere in the election should lose his ... - Fortune - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- On The New Abnormal, Matt Gertz explains why the Pence story got swept under the rug: Fox News is a "Trumpian ... - Media Matters for America - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Trump Told Pence Certifying Election Would Be 'Career Killer,' Valet Testified - The New York Times - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Fox News Buried Its Own Mike Pence Story to Benefit Trump - The Daily Beast - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Republican Group's Ad Taunts Donald Trump By Noting Mike Pence Put 'Country Over Party' - Yahoo Singapore News - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Pence cannot in good conscience back Trump but Capito can - The Dominion Post - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Ex-Pence Aide Recalls Trump-Haley Oval Office Moment That Left Her 'In Shock' - Yahoo News - January 25th, 2024 [January 25th, 2024]
- Sure They Wanted to Hang Mike Pence, But It'll Be Different for Me! - The Bulwark - January 25th, 2024 [January 25th, 2024]
- Rep. Greg Pence: Chaos in Congress a factor in retirement - Daily Journal - January 25th, 2024 [January 25th, 2024]
- Mike Pence's Brother Joins Republicans Retiring From Congress - The Daily Beast - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Pence says he believes the FBI didn't contribute to Jan. 6 riot - POLITICO - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Former US VP Mike Pence to Israel: 'The American people are with you' - The Jerusalem Post - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Real Photograph of Mike Pence Signing an Artillery Shell in Israel? - Snopes.com - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Greg Pence hangs it up after six years in Congress - The Times of Northwest Indiana - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- U.S. Rep. Greg Pence announces he won't seek reelection - The Daily News - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Pence decides not to file again for Congress - 101.5 WKKG - 101.5 WKKG - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Mike Pence heckled by man claiming they are both gay - PinkNews - October 15th, 2023 [October 15th, 2023]
- Mike Pence Heckled by Man Claiming to Be His Lover - Yahoo News - October 15th, 2023 [October 15th, 2023]
- Mike Pence Claims the Reagan Mantle. So Far, It Isn't Helping Him. - Reason - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- No, Mike Pence, We Should Not Make It Easier To Execute Mass ... - Reason - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- Trump Was Privately Chanting for Mike Pence's Hanging on January ... - Vanity Fair - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- Vivek Ramaswamy Is Attacked Over China, Ukraine and TikTok - The New York Times - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- Opinion | Since When Is Populism the Enemy of Conservatism? - POLITICO - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- In Iowa, Pence Preaches Old-School Conservatism to a Dwindling Flock - The New York Times - September 2nd, 2023 [September 2nd, 2023]
- 'Where did that guy come from?' Pence nets post-debate fundraising bump - POLITICO - September 2nd, 2023 [September 2nd, 2023]
- Pence 'Day 1' plan includes a telework rollback, spending freeze ... - GovExec.com - September 2nd, 2023 [September 2nd, 2023]
- Mike Pence and Nikki Haley Clash Over Abortion at GOP Debate - The New York Times - August 24th, 2023 [August 24th, 2023]
- A Chaotic Display of Conservatism at the First Republican Debate - The New Yorker - August 24th, 2023 [August 24th, 2023]
- GOP candidates debate in Milwaukee. Here are the moments that ... - NPR - August 24th, 2023 [August 24th, 2023]
- The Key Moments From the First Republican Presidential Debate - WTTW News - August 24th, 2023 [August 24th, 2023]
- Former Vice President Mike Pence expected to run for president in ... - NPR - June 4th, 2023 [June 4th, 2023]
- Has Mike Pence announced his campaign yet? No. But he will soon. - POLITICO - June 4th, 2023 [June 4th, 2023]
- Former VP Mike Pence speaks in Grand Rapids ahead of campaign ... - FOX 17 West Michigan News - June 4th, 2023 [June 4th, 2023]
- Mike Pence calls Dodgers inclusion of Sisters in Pride night deeply offensive - The Athletic - June 4th, 2023 [June 4th, 2023]
- Pence Looks Toward 2024 Run, Using Reagan's Playbook, Not Trump's - The New York Times - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Mike Pence rejects Trump's call to let U.S. default as he hints at 2024 White House bid - CNBC - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Ron DeSantis and Mike Pence Are Running Scared - The New Republic - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Sen. Joni Ernst announces Mike Pence, Nikki Haley will join her Roast and Ride fundraiser - KCCI Des Moines - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Mike Pence calls for national abortion restrictions in 'Conversation with the Candidate' - WMUR Manchester - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Former VP Mike Pence will attend 2023 Roast and Ride event in Des Moines - KGAN TV - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Ex-Trump Official Slams His Mockery of Jan. 6: We Were Just Inches Away From a Massacre - Mediaite - May 14th, 2023 [May 14th, 2023]
- Pence praises James Comer report on alleged Biden family business deals - Washington Examiner - May 14th, 2023 [May 14th, 2023]
- Trump Doubles Down On His Jan. 6 Lies, Wont Apologize To Pence At CNN Town Hall - HuffPost - May 14th, 2023 [May 14th, 2023]
- Opinion: Protecting Social Security is key for candidates in Iowa - Des Moines Register - May 14th, 2023 [May 14th, 2023]
- DeSantis takes anti-woke show to Illinois - POLITICO - May 14th, 2023 [May 14th, 2023]
- Trump rages after sexual abuse verdict but legal woes have only just begun - The Guardian US - May 14th, 2023 [May 14th, 2023]
- Mike Pence doesnt think voters will care about Trump sex abuse verdict - NBC News - May 12th, 2023 [May 12th, 2023]