Trump Rejected Military’s ISIS Strategy Because It Was Too Similar to Obama’s – New York Magazine

Obamas third term? Photo: Jim Watson/AFP/Getty Images

In one of his first acts as commander-in-chief, Donald Trump ordered his top military advisers to conduct a 30-day review of Americas strategy for defeating ISIS.

Given that precise timeline and Trumps past promises that he actually had a secret plan for defeating the terrorist group ready to go one might have expected the White House to unveil its vision for combating ISIS in late February or early March.

But one would have been wrong. Five months passed before the president even indicated that a new strategy was imminent: On May 21, Trump announced that he would detail his administrations plan for defeating ISIS in about two weeks.

A little over two weeks later, the president revealed that his long-awaited plan was finally, truly almost ready and he would outline it at a news conference in two weeks.

Nearly a month later, were still waiting for that news conference.

One can imagine a whole host of reasons for Trumps procrastination. Perhaps, the administration has been distracted by the alarming developments in North Korea (and/or the special prosecutors office). Or maybe gaming out a plan for defeating as singular an enemy as the Islamic State simply takes a lot of time. Or, perhaps, the president just has little interest in telling the public what his military plans are, and says thats coming in two weeks to literally any policy proposal hes ever asked about.

But the Daily Beast suggests an alternative answer. The outlet notes that U.S. forces have removed 50 top ISIS leaders from the battlefield since Trump took office down from 80, in the last six months of Obamas tenure. Further, the militants killed on Trumps watch have generally been lower-ranking than those targeted by the previous administration.

These facts dont reflect the inferiority of the Trump administrations anti-ISIS strategy so much as the sufficiency of the strategy it inherited: The military is simply running out of high-value ISIS targets to kill. Under Obama, the U.S. military was effectively wiping out ISISs leadership.

Now, you cant kill a violent, anti-American ideology by dropping American bombs in the Middle East. And you cant prevent disaffected, psychologically damaged young men from seeking meaning in acts of spectacular violence. So lone-wolf terrorists provided Trump with plenty to demagogue about in 2016. But to the extent that sheer force can solve a problem like ISIS, the Obama administrations approach was working just fine:

Trumps changes to the campaign [against ISIS] so far have been tacticalnamely, giving the military more autonomy to strike, including special operators. But the effectiveness of the current Obama-era strategy of attacking ISIS via local forces together with allies calls into question whether theres a need for more dramatic revision.

Thats presented a dilemma for those working on the Trump anti-ISIS strategy and slowed its public unveiling, U.S. officials tell The Daily Beast. The White House has asked defense officials to come up with new ideas to help brand the Trump campaign as different from its predecessor, according to two U.S. officials and one senior administration official. They spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss the sensitive debates.

To review, the Trump administrations vision for fighting ISIS differs from its predecessors in two key ways:

1) This White House believes in giving greater autonomy to its military commanders, thereby enabling them to make the best tactical decisions, unencumbered by petty political concerns.

2) It also believes in asking its generals to alter their strategic plans, not because the administration doubts their military efficacy, but solely because it finds them difficult to brand.

Cant you just feel America being made safe again?

Some California legislators represent about 300 times as many people as some New Hampshire legislators. Does that violate the U.S. Constitution?

At an emergency meeting at the U.N., Nikki Haley said the U.S. will use military force if we must.

The White House reportedly asked the military for a new anti-ISIS plan because its first one was hard to brand as a break from Obama.

The government reportedly promised the White House cheering crowds for Trumps speech, and this is how it will deliver.

It was apparently buried by the owner of the old Danceteria nightclub in the 1980s.

Ending the Medicaid expansion will eliminate an estimated 1.2 million jobs. But the greatest jobs president God ever created doesnt seem to care.

The show set a new viewership record.

If he runs in 2020 much less in 2024 Bernie Sanders would be pushing the envelope on the maximum acceptable age of elected political leaders.

Paul Ryan: You have to remember the law is in what the actuaries tell us [is] a death spiral. Well, I happen to have some actuaries right here.

White House aides are apparently worried that Trump wont be ready to meet with the KGB agent turned strongman.

Stay in an attempt to influence a hostile administration, or go when your personal red line is crossed?

North Korea places a huge value on projecting itself as a Great Power that can deter its enemies. And thats true, whether or not it has nukes.

On July Fourth weekend, Senate Republicans either hid from their constituents or were showered in praise for not passing their health-care bill.

[T]he Senate health-care bill boils down to benefit cuts for the poor to pay for tax cuts for the rich. Heavens!

Representative Clay Higgins, once known as the Cajun John Wayne, has a knack for courting national controversy.

Miosotis Familia was a 12-year veteran of the force.

The president tried to be a bit too inoffensive when referring to Karen Pence.

Pyongyangs first ICBM test doesnt leave the U.S. with great options and tweeting probably wont help.

Christie refused to apologize for the photos, saying, I think my poll numbers show that I dont care about optics.

This appears to be getting a little excessive.

Continued here:
Trump Rejected Military's ISIS Strategy Because It Was Too Similar to Obama's - New York Magazine

Related Posts

Comments are closed.