Letter: Billy Liar: Coming Soon To a Theater Near You The Suburban Times – The Suburban Times
Submitted by Aaron Arkin.
In the 1963 movie of the same name, Billy Liar (played by Tom Courtenay) is an aggrieved young man, described as ambitious but lazy, living at home in a middle-class English family. Unable to free himself from his dependency and lacking the strength of character to move himself into the world of adult choices, he resorts to constant lying (thus the name) and frequent fantasizing. Of the latter, the most striking is when in response to a harangue from his parents, we see him armed with a machine gun angrily mowing down his entire family. For the movie audience, the contrast between Billys fantasy and what is actually and mundanely taking place at the family dinner table is shocking, and maybe for some, even vindicatory.
Of course, Billy wouldnt really murder his family, and in England he wouldnt have ready access to a machine gun. But experiencing grievance is not rare, and in our country awash in assault weaponry, the aggrieved dont always settle for just fantasy.
When establishing responsibility for a criminal act, three elements are sought: means, motive, and opportunity. In the case of mass murder, means is easy access to guns. Here in the US, their ubiquity was turbocharged by the Supreme Courts most recent interpretation of the Second Amendment which reads: A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear, Arms, shall not be infringed.
Historian consensus for most of American history however, was that the Second Amendment limited the un-infringed possession of Arms to a citizen militia. They concluded the Founding Fathers were focused on keeping state militias from being disarmed in the absence of a national armed service. The revised interpretation of the Amendment, giving individuals that constitutional right, was provided by the opinion of Justice Antonin Scalia. Writing for the 5 to 4 majority in District of Columbia v. Heller (June 20, 2008), he ignored both the Amendments historical context, and its grammatical construction.
The Second Amendments grammatical construction, it is built on two clauses, the building blocks of sentences. Clauses are groups of related words (phrases) that contain both a subject and a verb. When a clause can stand alone as a complete sentence with a clear meaning, its considered independent. If it only makes sense when you join it with another clause, its dependent (or subordinate). A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free State is a dependent clause because it makes sense, that is, it is only a complete thought when combined with its following clause the right to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed.
Another way we know that the Second Amendments grammatical construction is a complete and logical thought only when the two clauses are combined is because, according to the grammar text, Writing and Thinking, Foerster and Steadman, revised by McMillan, the meaning of the independent and dependent clauses holds if the full statement can be preceded by the terms if, in case that, provided that, unless, since, as, because, inasmuch as, in that, or and now that, without changing the thought of the sentence. For example: Inasmuch as a well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed has the same meaning as the Second Amendment.
Summing up, the complete thought and logic of the two Second Amendment clauses is that, if militias are necessary for the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms wont be infringed. The converse of that statement is that, if militias are not necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms does not automatically follow. Since we no longer have or utilize self-armed citizen militias to secure the State, the Second Amendments rationale became irrelevant or inapplicable when the United States created its own armed services. One could reasonably argue that, in effect, the Second Amendment repealed itself.
As an avowed constitutional textualist (by the way, a questionable and controversial mode of legal interpretation of historic documents), who supposedly focused on the plain meaning of the text of legal documents to understand and emphasize how the terms in the Constitution would be understood by people at the time they were ratified, as well as the context in which those terms appeared, it is striking and ironic that Judge Scalia chose to ignore both the grammatical construction of the Amendment, and its historical context. In his dissenting opinion, Justice John Paul Stevens (joined by Ruth Bader Ginsberg, David Souter, and Steven Breyer) argued that the courts judgment was a strained and unpersuasive reading which overturned longstanding precedent, and that the court had bestowed a dramatic upheaval in the law. One may fairly conclude that in his desire to provide individual citizens the right to have Arms for self-protection, Judge Scalias commitment as a constitutional textualist was conditional.
Many supporters of Scalias interpretation do seem to sense that his reading of the Second Amendments intent rests on shaky legal ground; seeing any restriction on gun rights as a hole in the dike or a slippery slope, if you will, that could cause Scalias legal edifice to fail. Pointedly, we dont see similarly strenuous advocacy in service to the other nine Bill of Rights Amendments which, presumably, sit on firmer legal grounds. Shaky grounds or not, with the Courts ruling, we are now left to deal with its unintended consequences.
When it comes to grievance as a common human experience for motive (the second element of a criminal act) at the heart of mass shootings, I am brought in mind of an ironic saying, Lucky the man who knows who his enemy is. I take this to mean that if ones focus is on an enemy for ones difficulties or failures, it is not necessary to look within. And unfortunately as it turns out for us, for many people with that need there is no lack of enemies: different races, religions, political views, sexual identity and preferences, immigrants, economic classes, event attendees, people in power, people without power, high achievers, old people, young people, people who criticized, bullied, bested, insulted, or made fun of you; who cut you off on the highway, drove too slowly, wore the wrong color clothing, said something you didnt like, looked at you funnily, had something you were lacking. In other words, the other.
Opportunity (the third element of a criminal act) for mass murder is provided by so-called soft targets: night clubs, houses of worship, places of employment, grocery stores, schools, restaurants, malls, public gatherings, festivals, highways, homes, neighborhood streets. There is really no limit. Considering all of the above, we have a perfect storm for increasing the number of mass killings using semi-automatic and what are effectively automatic weapons.
Even in the face of this horrific violence however, there has been little appetite for meaningful political solutions. There is even refusal by many politicians to accept that the proliferation of lethal weaponry contributes to the slaughter. Instead we get the mantra: Guns dont kill people; people kill people, followed by arguments for increasing funding for mental health care (which ironically many politicians on the right have voted to defund in the past), hardening all soft targets (as if that were really possible), and getting tougher on criminals (although we incarcerate more people than any other nation on earth): anything but meaningful restrictions on access to guns and banning the most dangerous weapons.
Supporters of least restrictive gun laws also make the argument that we would be safer with more arming of the citizenry, including teachers, more open carry laws, and fewer restrictions on concealed weapons. As it is estimated there are already more guns in private hands in America then there are people, by that measure we should already be the safest country in the world. In fact, we have the second highest number of gun deaths in the world.
A more rational approach would be the one that has been adopted by other advanced democracies. They ignore any right to bear Arms type of construct, and balancing the interest in of public safety against providing self-protection for responsible citizens, just regulate the sale of weapons and the kinds of weapons permitted.
But back to Billy Liar: at the end of the movie, he finds himself in a position to make an actual grownup choice. Hes met a free-spirited young woman (Julie Christie, in her break-out role) who is ready to meet the challenges of the adult world and who offers him the opportunity to join her and start life on their own. And part of him wants this: to overcome his need for dependency; to have an adult relationship, and to make his own way. Sitting on a train about to leave the station, poised for an entry into an adult future, Billy chooses to leave the train to get some milk to drink (what could be more emblematic of dependency and lack of real agency?), promising Julie there is plenty of time for him to get back before the train leaves.
The audience instantly realizes Billy will not be coming back. True to form, he delays his return, described by one critic as the train leaves the station without him as, . . . shrugging on the platform and settling for the mediocrity he despises and probably deserves. Turns out Billy reserved the worst lies for himself. Seems he is not alone.
Read more:
Letter: Billy Liar: Coming Soon To a Theater Near You The Suburban Times - The Suburban Times
- Second Amendment advocate fires back against controversial gun bill: This is going to cost lives in the long run - MyNorthwest.com - April 3rd, 2025 [April 3rd, 2025]
- Restoration of Second Amendment Rights After They Are Lost - The Truth About Guns - April 3rd, 2025 [April 3rd, 2025]
- House Republicans Honor Second Amendment Promises, Advance Key Legislation - National Shooting Sports Foundation - March 28th, 2025 [March 28th, 2025]
- Congress poised to strengthen Second Amendment rights with national concealed carry reciprocity - Washington Times - March 28th, 2025 [March 28th, 2025]
- Senators team up to support proposed legislation protecting veterans Second Amendment rights - Washington Examiner - March 28th, 2025 [March 28th, 2025]
- Governor vetoes local lawmakers Second Amendment Protection Act bill - County 10 News - March 28th, 2025 [March 28th, 2025]
- Second Amendment Roundup: Court Seems Disposed to Rule for S&W and Against Mexico - Reason - March 13th, 2025 [March 13th, 2025]
- Governor Murphys Latest Plan is to Tax the Second Amendment Rights of New Jerseyans - Shore News Network - March 5th, 2025 [March 5th, 2025]
- Second Amendment Protection Act changes head to governor's desk - Wyoming Tribune - March 5th, 2025 [March 5th, 2025]
- WY: TELL THE GOVERNOR Support Second Amendment Protections! - Gun Owners of America - March 5th, 2025 [March 5th, 2025]
- Second Amendment Protection Act changes head to governor's desk - Wyoming News Now - March 5th, 2025 [March 5th, 2025]
- Gun Advocates Demand Results After Second Amendment Executive Order - MSN - March 5th, 2025 [March 5th, 2025]
- Could The Washington Post Go Pro-Second Amendment? | An Official Journal Of The NRA - America's 1st Freedom - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Second Amendment Concerns Raised After Long Island Village Bans All Gun and Ammo Sales - MSN - March 1st, 2025 [March 1st, 2025]
- Trumps bold move to strengthen the Second Amendment - Washington Times - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- After York County shootings, its time to update the Second Amendment [letter] - LNP | LancasterOnline - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- NSSF Praises South Dakotas Gov. Larry Rhoden for Protecting Second Amendment Privacy - National Shooting Sports Foundation - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- Fear not the endless presidency: The Twenty-second Amendment - Convention of States Action - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- New Florida bill would strengthen Second Amendment rights at colleges and universities - Campus Reform - February 27th, 2025 [February 27th, 2025]
- How USAID Funded the War on the Second Amendment | An Official Journal Of The NRA - America's 1st Freedom - February 14th, 2025 [February 14th, 2025]
- Bills affect homeless, addresses wildfires, makes OK a Second Amendment sanctuary state - Yahoo - February 14th, 2025 [February 14th, 2025]
- Trump Issues Executive Order: Protecting Second Amendment Rights Where are we now? - Firearms News - February 12th, 2025 [February 12th, 2025]
- Executive Order 14206Protecting Second Amendment Rights - The American Presidency Project - February 12th, 2025 [February 12th, 2025]
- Trump is protecting the Second Amendment - Washington Times - February 12th, 2025 [February 12th, 2025]
- Trump Signs Executive Order Strengthening Second Amendment | An Official Journal Of The NRA - American Hunter - February 12th, 2025 [February 12th, 2025]
- Executive Order Seeks to Protect Second Amendment After Prior Administration - Turning Point USA - February 12th, 2025 [February 12th, 2025]
- Executive Order on the Second Amendment, which doesn't need any help - Daily Kos - February 12th, 2025 [February 12th, 2025]
- NRA Statement on President Trumps Executive Order Protecting Second Amendment Rights - NRA Women - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- President Trump signs executive order 'protecting Second Amendment rights' - Buckeye Firearms Association - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- Trump starts unwinding Biden regulations that infringe on Second Amendment rights of Americans - Must Read Alaska - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- White House Wields Executive Power to Bolster Second Amendment: - Hoodline - February 9th, 2025 [February 9th, 2025]
- DeSantis Second Amendment Summer is more about his aspirations than Floridas budget | Opinion - Miami Herald - February 5th, 2025 [February 5th, 2025]
- Dueling Gun Groups Strike Truce To Push Wyoming Second Amendment Rights Bill - Cowboy State Daily - February 5th, 2025 [February 5th, 2025]
- Trump AG Pick: I Am an Advocate for the Second Amendment, but I Will Enforce the Laws of the Land - The Reload - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Second Amendment advocates skeptical of Pam Bondi - Washington Examiner - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Federal Judges (Still) Have No Earthly Idea What to Do With the Supreme Courts Second Amendment Cases - Balls & Strikes - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Tuberville, Britt reintroduce pro-second amendment Constitutional Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act - Yellowhammer News - January 19th, 2025 [January 19th, 2025]
- Donald Trump Jr. says younger people are getting into the Second Amendment amid GrabAGun SPAC deal - Fox Business - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- GrabAGun, a Mobile-Focused Online Firearms Retailer Defending the Second Amendment, to Become a Public Company through a Business Combination with... - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Secretary Gray Calls on Wyoming Legislature to Protect Second Amendment Rights by Repealing Gun Free Zones - Sheridan Media - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- Bernstine Takes Oath of Office, Committed to Protecting Second Amendment Rights, Fighting Wasteful Spending - EllwoodCity.org - January 9th, 2025 [January 9th, 2025]
- NRA-ILA demonstrates its influence in advancing Second Amendment causes - Buckeye Firearms Association - December 18th, 2024 [December 18th, 2024]
- Availability of a second Amendment to the 2023 Universal Registration Document - Yahoo Finance - December 14th, 2024 [December 14th, 2024]
- Justices Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch Signal Readiness to Revisit Second Amendment Licensing Disputes - USA Herald - December 14th, 2024 [December 14th, 2024]
- Supreme Court Passes On Chance To Correct Hawaii Ruling Finding Spirit Of Aloha Trumps Second Amendment - Daily Caller - December 10th, 2024 [December 10th, 2024]
- AG nominee Pam Bondi's mixed record on Second Amendment raises 'red flags' - Buckeye Firearms Association - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- Nearly 100 Anti-Second Amendment Measures Proposed To Texas Legislature - Firearms News - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- Sen. Cruz Takes Stand to Stop Mexico from Violating U.S. Constitution & Second Amendment - Texas Border Business - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- Sen. Cruz Leads Bicameral Amicus Urging Supreme Court to Uphold American Sovereignty and the Second Amendment - TexasGOPVote - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- The bill aims to protect Texans Second Amendment rights by blocking enforcement of extreme risk protective orders - The Dallas Express - December 8th, 2024 [December 8th, 2024]
- Trumps New Attorney General Pick Should Face Tough Questions at Confirmation. She Flouts the Second Amendment - The Stream - November 26th, 2024 [November 26th, 2024]
- Ames Moot Court Competition takes on the Second Amendment - Harvard Law School - November 26th, 2024 [November 26th, 2024]
- State Leaders Take Aim at the Second Amendment - The Dallas Express - November 26th, 2024 [November 26th, 2024]
- Trump's victory over Harris proves 'Second Amendment won,' gun rights groups say - Fox News - November 16th, 2024 [November 16th, 2024]
- Mecklenburg Co. Sheriff's Office stripping sober gun owners of their Second Amendment right - WCNC.com - November 16th, 2024 [November 16th, 2024]
- Where John Thune Stands on Gun Control and the Second Amendment - Guns.com - November 16th, 2024 [November 16th, 2024]
- Elections have consequences, particularly when it comes to the Second Amendment - Rome Sentinel - November 10th, 2024 [November 10th, 2024]
- Analysis: Can Arms in Common Use be Banned Under the Second Amendment? [Member Exclusive] - The Reload - November 2nd, 2024 [November 2nd, 2024]
- Where the Harris/Walz Ticket Stands on the Second Amendment - Catalyst - November 2nd, 2024 [November 2nd, 2024]
- Harris Claims She, Not Trump, Will Defend the Second Amendment | An Official Journal Of The NRA - America's 1st Freedom - November 2nd, 2024 [November 2nd, 2024]
- An NRA Shooting Sports Journal | Royce Gracie Speaks Out About NRA And The Second Amendment - Shooting Sports USA - October 29th, 2024 [October 29th, 2024]
- Future of SCOTUS and Second Amendment rights on the ballot - Buckeye Firearms Association - October 29th, 2024 [October 29th, 2024]
- A Second Amendment Rally Like No Other - MSN - October 29th, 2024 [October 29th, 2024]
- Second Amendment Voters Arent Buying Harriss Pandering But Theyre Glad She Feels Compelled to Try - National Review - October 29th, 2024 [October 29th, 2024]
- Elon Musk Gets to the Basis of the Second Amendment | An Official Journal Of The NRA - America's 1st Freedom - October 29th, 2024 [October 29th, 2024]
- Hovde and Baldwin on the Second Amendment and gun control - PBS Wisconsin - October 21st, 2024 [October 21st, 2024]
- Kamala Harris claims she's got a gun, but Second Amendment supporters say good luck getting yours - Fox News - October 14th, 2024 [October 14th, 2024]
- Trump fans fear for Second Amendment at festival of God, guns and motorcycles - FRANCE 24 English - October 14th, 2024 [October 14th, 2024]
- Second Amendment Roundup: The VanDerStok Argument - Reason - October 14th, 2024 [October 14th, 2024]
- Second Amendment Roundup: ATF's Wish to Trace More Firearms Doesn't Justify Redefining "Firearm" - Reason - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Harris and Walz Are Gunning for the Second Amendment - Heritage.org - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Travis Kelce slams NFL for punishing player over gun celebration: 'It's my second amendment! I have the right - Daily Mail - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Massachusetts Governor Healey Subverts Democratic Process And The Second Amendment - The Truth About Guns - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- Local leaders take part in Peterborough Town Library discussion on Second Amendment - Monadnock Ledger Transcript - October 3rd, 2024 [October 3rd, 2024]
- An Official Journal Of The NRA | Kamala Harris Would Destroy The Second Amendment - America's 1st Freedom - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Rep. Tenney Recognized for Support of the Second Amendment - Finger Lakes Daily News - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Amy Swearer: Harris and Walz are gunning for the Second Amendment - Arizona Daily Star - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Amy Swearer: Harris and Walz are gunning for the Second Amendment - Quad-City Times - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Lower courts willingly thumb nose at SCOTUS over Second Amendment - Buckeye Firearms Association - September 28th, 2024 [September 28th, 2024]
- Glenn Grothman will defend our Second Amendment rights -- Nathan Pollnow - Madison.com - September 26th, 2024 [September 26th, 2024]